Is Petersen a top 3 college football coach?

Gladstone

Tough call.

1. Saban 2. Meyer 3. ??? Harbaugh? Petrino? Pete? Dabo? Fisher? Sark?

CFetters_Nacho_Lover

Yes

Invalid pole. No Janet Reno (RIP). No field.

Dennis_DeYoung

Yes

I said yes because I think he's up in that top tier. Fisher is a tier below, I think... but the top is Sab, Urb, Pete and Dabo and probably Harbs...

Sark would be there immediately if he got the Wake Forest job like he should.

PurpleBaze

No

Peterman would be top-tier if he fired that shitbag Babushka and hired a real OC.

Dennis_DeYoung

Yes

PurpleBaze said:

Peterman would be top-tier if he fired that shitbag Babushka and hired a real OC.

Literally the only discernible chink (ISAFNRC) in Pete's armor is his allegiance to shitty white dude coaches. Babushka has to go. He should've been DAO when Bush tried to leave.

Gladstone

Yes

CFetters_Nacho_Lover said:

Invalid pole. No Janet Reno (RIP). No field.

CFetters_Nacho_Lover

Yes

Gladstone said:

CFetters_Nacho_Lover said:

Invalid pole. No Janet Reno (RIP). No field.

I went back & forth on whether Peterman beats out Dabo. Dabo beat Bama for the title and came damn close year but a doogs gotta Doog and I'm dooging

RaceBannon

Dabo would outrank Petersen at this point. As do Saban and Urban.

It's a short list these days

Gladstone

Yes

RaceBannon said:

Dabo would outrank Petersen at this point. As do Saban and Urban.

It's a short list these days

YellowSnow

Yes

Dabo has the Natty, but in year 8.5. I argued in another thread a while back that Pete in year 3 had better results than Dabo in year 3.5 and got made fun of and shit for making a supposedly shitty transitive argument.

doogie

No

Top 4

TierbsHsotBoobs

No

I need to see a natty to put him in the top 3.

oregonblitzkrieg

No

You can't place someone in the top 3 who hasn't even yet eclipsed Slingblade's acheevments. To be top 3 he would need to be higher ranked than Saban, Urban, Harbaugh. Not going to happen.

YellowSnow

Yes

oregonblitzkrieg said:

You can't place someone in the top 3 who hasn't even yet eclipsed Slingblade's acheevments. To be top 3 he would need to be higher ranked than Saban, Urban, Harbaugh. Not going to happen.

Getting his good friend, Slingblade, fired and going 1-0 against Slingblade's predecessor has to count for something.

haie

Yes

Doogs who say things like now that we have the right coach deserve Darnold sticking the full plunger in next year, if Stanford doesn't do it first.

oregonblitzkrieg

No

YellowSnow said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

You can't place someone in the top 3 who hasn't even yet eclipsed Slingblade's acheevments. To be top 3 he would need to be higher ranked than Saban, Urban, Harbaugh. Not going to happen.

Getting his good friend, Slingblade, fired and going 1-0 against Slingblade's predecessor has to count for something.

Quooks are grateful for that, he certainly helped getting Slingblade axed.

RoadDawg55

No

I voted no because there is an unwritten rule about rankings players or coaches without championships above one that has.

Other than Saban, I'm not sure there is another coach I would trade for, especially at UW.

Meyer has had a better career, but he burned out at Florida and could again at Ohio State.

Harbaugh is too psycho.

Dabo is good but I question if that good ol boy bullshit works as well in Seattle.

Same for Fisher.

Not sure who else can legitimately be in the conversation.

Pitchfork51

No

Petrino is the man. It's like if sark was actually a good coach.

Mad_Son

Yes

Yes because it is pretty indiscernible at the top. I'd give Saban and Meyer a nod over him but he is arguably third (like what has Harbaugh done that Pete hasn't?).

Bread

No

Not a chance. Coaches should be ranked on likely hood of being a poaster on our lovely site. 1. Sark 2. Harbuagh 3. Mike gundy. Petersen is probably not even top 50.

Thump

No

A top 3 coach wouldn't still have Smith as OC.

Well, I guess he did hire a co-OC now?

I'll give Pete top 10. Maybe top 5. Not sure about top 3 yet.