Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Brandon Kaho Commemorative Collegiate Career Impact Forecast - 2019 Results
Woof
Member Posts: 770
Thank you to everyone who participated, even those of you that forgot which alt you used to sign up with and voted under a different handle which was really fucking confusing for me.
Loots of dooging for this class. The average score was a 3.63, and only 22 times was the score of 1 given out to a scholarship player.
In reverse order, from lowest ranked, to highest ranked:
#22) Dylan Morris with a score of 2.15 - a bit of a surprise that he's so low, but it appears everyone is of the opinion that he is unlikely to beat out Yankoff/Sirmon/Huard and be a career backup at best. Half a point lower than the next guy in the class, which was a bit of a surprise for me.
#21) Corey Luciano with a score of 2.73 - score that implies spot starter-ish impact for the future. Not really surprising to me.
#20) Bralen Trice with a score of 2.76 - lowest rated defensive recruit, and a guy we beat out some decent schools for. Coaches definitely see something that the bored does not.
#17 (Tie) Taj Davis, Tim Horn, and Miki Ah You, with a score of 2.88 - Three way tie for 17th between our only WR, our K, and the 4th ILB. Amazing that a kicker isn't last overall, but I think that says something about our special teams. Horn and Ah You were also the only two players to have been rated across the entire spectrum of 1-5. Shout out to @bananasnblondes and @PineapplePirate for thinking Horn is going to be a 5, and @GreenRiverGatorz giving Ah You a 5.
#16) Nathaniel Kalepo with a score of 3.20 - Big jump here into what is effectively a solid starter rating. Given what he did for our recruiting, I hope he outperforms our projections.
#14 (Tie) Noa Ngalu and Alphonzo Tuputala with a score of 3.24 - Another tie here with solid scores for a couple of our more underrated recruits. @Mad_Son gave Ngalu his only 5, while Tuputala's scores all fell between 2-4.
#13) Cameron Williams with a score of 3.41 - The first of Jimmy Lake's recruits comes in at 13th, with mostly 3s and 4s. @1to392831weretaken gave him the only 5, but he also got about a half dozen 2s.
#12) Kamren Fabiculanan with a score of 3.61 - Similar to C-Will, but a few more 5s, and only @ExtraChrisB @HuskyJW and @Doogles giving him a 2.
#11) Julius Buelow with a score of 3.68 - Above average starter score. I was one of the few that gave him a 2. Hopefully I'm wrong, but his lack of foot speed scares me.
#10) Cameron Davis with a score of 3.73 - Squeaks out Buelow to be the 2nd highest offensive player. 5s came from @KrunkJuice @bananasnblondes and @1to392831weretaken while @whatshouldicareabout gave him the only 2.
#9) Josh Calvert with a score of 3.80 - Quickly approaching all-conference level starter. Almost all 4s, with a smattering of 3s and 5s. @HuskyJW only felt him worthy of a 2 though.
#8) Asa Turner with a score of 4.21 - Asa is the bottom of the next tier of players who all score comfortably above a 4. Almost all 4s and 5s here, with @1to392831weretaken giving him the only 2.
#7) Troy Fautanu with a score of 4.29 - highest ranked offensive player. Lowest score was a 3, given by 5 people. Got 24 5s from the crowd.
#6) Jacob Bandes with a score of 4.30 - the 3rd highest ranked DL is the 6th overall player in the class. Malloe did incredible. Beat Fautanu by virtue of one fewer 3.
#5) Trent McDuffies with a score of 4.52 - Jimmy Lake is slipping when his highest player is only 5th in the class (kidding). McDuffie's lowest score was a 4.
#3 (Tie) Sama Pa'ama and Daniel Heimuli with a score of 4.55 - Tie at the 3rd spot. Pa'ama had one more 5, but also 2 3s from @Houhusky and @godawgst . Heimuli got his only 3 from @Bread .
#2) Laiatu Latu with a score of 4.56 - Tight race at the top, but loses out by virtue of 3s from @Saracen and @HuskyJW
#1) Faatui Tuitele with a score of 4.59 - Lowest score was a 4, and 41 5s. Also, likely the winner of favorite dad.
Will follow up with PWOs, recruiter rankings, and other data tomorrow-ish.
Loots of dooging for this class. The average score was a 3.63, and only 22 times was the score of 1 given out to a scholarship player.
In reverse order, from lowest ranked, to highest ranked:
#22) Dylan Morris with a score of 2.15 - a bit of a surprise that he's so low, but it appears everyone is of the opinion that he is unlikely to beat out Yankoff/Sirmon/Huard and be a career backup at best. Half a point lower than the next guy in the class, which was a bit of a surprise for me.
#21) Corey Luciano with a score of 2.73 - score that implies spot starter-ish impact for the future. Not really surprising to me.
#20) Bralen Trice with a score of 2.76 - lowest rated defensive recruit, and a guy we beat out some decent schools for. Coaches definitely see something that the bored does not.
#17 (Tie) Taj Davis, Tim Horn, and Miki Ah You, with a score of 2.88 - Three way tie for 17th between our only WR, our K, and the 4th ILB. Amazing that a kicker isn't last overall, but I think that says something about our special teams. Horn and Ah You were also the only two players to have been rated across the entire spectrum of 1-5. Shout out to @bananasnblondes and @PineapplePirate for thinking Horn is going to be a 5, and @GreenRiverGatorz giving Ah You a 5.
#16) Nathaniel Kalepo with a score of 3.20 - Big jump here into what is effectively a solid starter rating. Given what he did for our recruiting, I hope he outperforms our projections.
#14 (Tie) Noa Ngalu and Alphonzo Tuputala with a score of 3.24 - Another tie here with solid scores for a couple of our more underrated recruits. @Mad_Son gave Ngalu his only 5, while Tuputala's scores all fell between 2-4.
#13) Cameron Williams with a score of 3.41 - The first of Jimmy Lake's recruits comes in at 13th, with mostly 3s and 4s. @1to392831weretaken gave him the only 5, but he also got about a half dozen 2s.
#12) Kamren Fabiculanan with a score of 3.61 - Similar to C-Will, but a few more 5s, and only @ExtraChrisB @HuskyJW and @Doogles giving him a 2.
#11) Julius Buelow with a score of 3.68 - Above average starter score. I was one of the few that gave him a 2. Hopefully I'm wrong, but his lack of foot speed scares me.
#10) Cameron Davis with a score of 3.73 - Squeaks out Buelow to be the 2nd highest offensive player. 5s came from @KrunkJuice @bananasnblondes and @1to392831weretaken while @whatshouldicareabout gave him the only 2.
#9) Josh Calvert with a score of 3.80 - Quickly approaching all-conference level starter. Almost all 4s, with a smattering of 3s and 5s. @HuskyJW only felt him worthy of a 2 though.
#8) Asa Turner with a score of 4.21 - Asa is the bottom of the next tier of players who all score comfortably above a 4. Almost all 4s and 5s here, with @1to392831weretaken giving him the only 2.
#7) Troy Fautanu with a score of 4.29 - highest ranked offensive player. Lowest score was a 3, given by 5 people. Got 24 5s from the crowd.
#6) Jacob Bandes with a score of 4.30 - the 3rd highest ranked DL is the 6th overall player in the class. Malloe did incredible. Beat Fautanu by virtue of one fewer 3.
#5) Trent McDuffies with a score of 4.52 - Jimmy Lake is slipping when his highest player is only 5th in the class (kidding). McDuffie's lowest score was a 4.
#3 (Tie) Sama Pa'ama and Daniel Heimuli with a score of 4.55 - Tie at the 3rd spot. Pa'ama had one more 5, but also 2 3s from @Houhusky and @godawgst . Heimuli got his only 3 from @Bread .
#2) Laiatu Latu with a score of 4.56 - Tight race at the top, but loses out by virtue of 3s from @Saracen and @HuskyJW
#1) Faatui Tuitele with a score of 4.59 - Lowest score was a 4, and 41 5s. Also, likely the winner of favorite dad.
Will follow up with PWOs, recruiter rankings, and other data tomorrow-ish.
Comments
-
You fuckers who gave Heimuli and Pa'ama a 3 are killing me
-
@Woof who was the consensus “sleeper”?
-
-
This was supposed to be a prediction of the Callier rankings four years from now, right? Way too many 5's.
-
There were more 1's than 4's in the last Callier rankings. If the class is half this good we plungering the Pac for 4 years straight.UWhuskytskeet said:This was supposed to be a prediction of the Callier rankings four years from now, right? Way too many 5's.
-
Most likely get homesick and enroll at Bama award goes to Asa Turner, with 51.5% of the vote. Heimuli was the runner up with only 15.1% of the vote. Nobody else registered more than 3 votes.
Most overrated award goes to Dylan Morris with 51.5% of the vote. Kalepo was the runner up with 21.2%, and nobody else registered more than 3 votes.
Most underrated award goes to Alphonzo Tuputala with 17% of the vote. Pa'ama was the runner up with 12% of the vote, and Fautanu was a close 3rd with 11%. Much more spread out on this one, with 19 guys, including Drew Fowler receiving a vote. The only scholarship players who didn't receive a vote were Morris and Kalepo.
I should have been clearer on how to score the PWOs. I believe a subset graded them on a different scale (i.e., there were 16 scores of 4 or 5), so that throws off the scores. I was intending them to be ranked on the same metric as the scholarship guys.
Mishael Powell (DB from O'Dea) - scored a 2.85, which would have put him higher than Trice, Luciano, and Morris
Hunter Hansen (WTE from Bellevue) - scored a 2.51
Drew Fowler (LB from Bellevue) - scored a 3.61. I mean this guy did turn down multiple P12 offers, but I can't imagine the group would say he is as good as the median player on the scholarship list. I could see him becoming a starter/scholarship player in the future. -
@Bread you shit lips!
-
We always like the new recruits better than we should. It’s nothing new.UWhuskytskeet said:This was supposed to be a prediction of the Callier rankings four years from now, right? Way too many 5's.
-
Wait till they play a down, then we will hate themRoadDawg55 said:
We always like the new recruits better than we should. It’s nothing new.UWhuskytskeet said:This was supposed to be a prediction of the Callier rankings four years from now, right? Way too many 5's.
