Results - 6th Annual Jesse Callier Commemorative Post-Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Initiative
Comments
-
Harris at a 3 is a profoundly stupid rating. w/ respectjhfstyle24 said:Ahmed was a 2 for me since he massively underwhelmed. I suppose he deserved a 3 on the basis of how he performed but he was supposed to be a super stud and wasn’t.
Harris I gave a 3 because I thought he regressed some this year, but he probably deserved a 4. -
He’s not a 5 star. Good, but not great. A solid 4.FireCohen said:Adams was 5 his true sophomore season, but his senior year he was just a 3. Let’s be objective. Nick Harris also got some AA love. So he should get a 5 ranking. AJ had a solid career, with no mess ups
-
If you hated Myles Bryant in 2016, you’re a moron. TBS obsession. If he’s a scholarship player with 4 stars or probably even 3, nobody ever thinks he sucks. I remember him and BBK getting singled out for the ASU game in 2017 when our offense completely shit the bed. Missing a tackle on N’Keal Harry does not make one a shitty player.
-
Strange criteria. Most of us try to come up with an objective way of grading. You seem to take the opposite approach.jhfstyle24 said:Ahmed was a 2 for me since he massively underwhelmed. I suppose he deserved a 3 on the basis of how he performed but he was supposed to be a super stud and wasn’t.
Harris I gave a 3 because I thought he regressed some this year, but he probably deserved a 4.
Mine is something like:
*...never played or played, played in significantly, or was a total liability. A * rating means a wasted scholarship.
**...played a decent amount but poorly. A ** rating means the player contributed as a warm body needed to fill a spot, but was a liability. Its still a contribution.
***...played a lot and generally not a liability. A *** player probably wasnt very good and took heat from critics, but was good enough to keep trotting out there. This can also be someone who sat most of their career but finally made somewhat of a splash at some point, usually at the end.
****...Multi year starter that, in my best estimation was good enough to start on a good team. At least in the conversation for all Pac 12. A team full of **** would be good enough to win the conference.
*****...Great player and in the conversation for AA. Dominant, not just good, for at least one season.
Something like that. Ahmed, for example, was an excellent backup to Gaskin who averaged about 6ypc for two years and put up 1000 yards as the primary starter. I dont see how he's not **** even with his obvious shortcomings. 1000 yards is 1000 yards. -
I think I had the highest correlation last year too. Could be a good thing, but it might be bad. EWIWBI.
-
I think I confused Roberts and Hilbers in giving Roberts a 3. Meaning I think I attributed some of the stuff Hilbers did well to Roberts.
Still, I can’t see Roberts lower than a 2 as a part-time player for multiple years. -
@FireCohen Fuck you, mental health is nothing to scoff at. Just ask @backthepack and @LaMichael_Corleonedirtysouwfdawg said:To my defense I’m on the downward part of my cycle and so I really want to kill someone.
Both Bryant and Adams had a full point deducted for dicking out on the team for the bowl. This doesn’t sit well with me so get off my lawn.
Edit: be it crap offense, coaching, or injuries; neither ended as well as I feel they could’ve.
Your reaction to my post has me shaking and vomiting and when I off myself in a customized recruitment video, know that my life is pathetic and this is all I have going for me. Also know you will literally see purple and gold shoot out of the veins on my left wrist. -
Now ask yourself why?dirtysouwfdawg said:
@FireCohen Fuck you, mental health is nothing to scoff at. Just ask @backthepack and @LaMichael_Corleonedirtysouwfdawg said:To my defense I’m on the downward part of my cycle and so I really want to kill someone.
Both Bryant and Adams had a full point deducted for dicking out on the team for the bowl. This doesn’t sit well with me so get off my lawn.
Edit: be it crap offense, coaching, or injuries; neither ended as well as I feel they could’ve.
Your reaction to my post has me shaking and vomiting and when I off myself in a customized recruitment video, know that my life is pathetic and this is all I have going for me. Also know you will literally see purple and gold shoot out of the veins on my left wrist. -
Cause I quit taking my meds.FireCohen said:
Now ask yourself why?dirtysouwfdawg said:
@FireCohen Fuck you, mental health is nothing to scoff at. Just ask @backthepack and @LaMichael_Corleonedirtysouwfdawg said:To my defense I’m on the downward part of my cycle and so I really want to kill someone.
Both Bryant and Adams had a full point deducted for dicking out on the team for the bowl. This doesn’t sit well with me so get off my lawn.
Edit: be it crap offense, coaching, or injuries; neither ended as well as I feel they could’ve.
Your reaction to my post has me shaking and vomiting and when I off myself in a customized recruitment video, know that my life is pathetic and this is all I have going for me. Also know you will literally see purple and gold shoot out of the veins on my left wrist. -
That list is hideous. Lots of dead weight. If you were building a starting roster from the 85 scholarship players to start the year there are maybe 4 on this list.Woof said:
I'm not sure what you're getting at here. This is rank order if that helps.Emoterman said:Is there a simple/easy way to weight the results by playing time?
Harris 4.25
Adams 4.12
M. Bryant 4.07
H. Bryant 3.94
Ahmed 3.57
Potoa'e 3.28
Hilbers 3.21
Whitford 3.03
Eason 2.94
Fuller 2.88
Carty 2.70
McClatcher 2.42
Wellington 2.07
Beavers 1.97
Baccellia 1.87
Pounds 1.70
Roberts 1.70
Rice 1.34
Manu 1.27
Warren 1.16
Haener 1.13
Scrempos 1.12
Nasili-Kite 1.03
Lowe 1.01
Yankoff 1.00
