Buy or Sell

RaceBannon

A PTI rip off

For the next ten years, who you got

Cam Newton

Russell Wilson

I would buy them both (profile in courage) but if I have to pick one, I take Cam. And I don't hate the Hawks or the 12s and will be rooting for Seattle

Cam is bigger which means he should have a longer career. I like his arm strength.

Intangibles are all Russell so far. This is a huge game for Newton. No one wants to be Manning to Wilson's Brady

dhdawg

This is a cop out, but whoever wins this game. They'll probably be 1-2 (unless rodgers can last into his late 30's) in 5 years

RoadDawg55

I would go with Russell Wilson. Tough call though.

BennyBeaver

Couldn't agree more.

greenblood

Both are incredible, but what Cam has done this year, is nothing short of amazing. Take Cam Newton off the field, and this team not only misses the playoffs, but could have finished last in their division.

RaceBannon

TheGlove said:

Couldn't agree more.

Thanks BEAVER!

SpoonieLuv

Not a hook homer but I see Cam being poised for a meltdown at some point and reverting to his Florida primadonna state.

Russ is too worried about protecting his heterosexual image and not breaking out in tears during a presser to ever lose. I'll take Closet Russ.

Kaepsknee

RaceBannon said:

A PTI rip off

For the next ten years, who you got


Intangibles are all Russell so far. This is a huge game for Newton. No one wants to be Manning to Wilson's Brady

Not a good comparison at least to this point. Up until this Season Cam hasn't had a team in the top half of the league.

section_332

First off I would take Luck over both

But between the 2, Russ
Cameron's running style is just asking to get hurt one of these days, he takes contact on
Russ has figured out he ain't the biggest strongest mother fucker and gets outta bounce
Both are leaders through and through. But I'd want Russ experience over Cameron's athletic gifts.

PurpleBaze

RaceBannon said:

I would buy them both (profile in courage) but if I have to pick one, I take Cam. And I don't hate the Hawks or the 12s and will be rooting for Seattle

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the fact that 'ole Race is putting Cam & Russ on a flatbed for comparison.

section_332 said:

First off I would take Luck over both

But between the 2, Russ
Cameron's running style is just asking to get hurt one of these days, he takes contact on
Russ has figured out he ain't the biggest strongest mother fucker and gets outta bounce
Both are leaders through and through. But I'd want Russ experience over Cameron's athletic gifts.

This!

DerekJohnson

Russell in a heartbeat. His mind, maturity and work ethic put him on a level above.

ThomasFremont

section_332 said:

First off I would take Luck over both

But between the 2, Russ
Cameron's running style is just asking to get hurt one of these days, he takes contact on
Russ has figured out he ain't the biggest strongest mother fucker and gets outta bounce
Both are leaders through and through. But I'd want Russ experience over Cameron's athletic gifts.

ROFL.

I'd go with Russ.

Cam not so close 2nd.

Luck is overrated. He has more in common with RG3 than the others.

section_332

ThomasFremont said:

section_332 said:

First off I would take Luck over both

But between the 2, Russ
Cameron's running style is just asking to get hurt one of these days, he takes contact on
Russ has figured out he ain't the biggest strongest mother fucker and gets outta bounce
Both are leaders through and through. But I'd want Russ experience over Cameron's athletic gifts.

ROFL.

I'd go with Russ.

Cam not so close 2nd.

Luck is overrated. He has more in common with RG3 than the others.

Considering Luck has never had a running game, defense, or a coherent offensive line...and has still been to the AFC title game.....id say he's overrated also

ThomasFremont

section_332 said:

ThomasFremont said:

section_332 said:

First off I would take Luck over both

But between the 2, Russ
Cameron's running style is just asking to get hurt one of these days, he takes contact on
Russ has figured out he ain't the biggest strongest mother fucker and gets outta bounce
Both are leaders through and through. But I'd want Russ experience over Cameron's athletic gifts.

ROFL.

I'd go with Russ.

Cam not so close 2nd.

Luck is overrated. He has more in common with RG3 than the others.

Considering Luck has never had a running game, defense, or a coherent offensive line...and has still been to the AFC title game.....id say he's overrated also

Russel's worst season was watching the defense give up the game winning FG in the divisional round.

But grats to Luck for making it all the way to the AFC champ game...once...and losing.

RaceBannon

By 50

Fenderbender123

Wilson.

Wilson never folds. Cam is resilient, but has some quit in him. Also, Wilson throw a better deep ball.

Don't get me wrong...I like Cam a lot. Dude is a gamer and talented as hell. I'd be happy with him. But Wilson is better.

Doogles

2013: Wilson or RG3

2014 Part 1: Wilson or Kap
2014 Part 2: Wilson or Luck

2015: Wilson or Cam

2016: Wilson or ?


You're not a Hook to pick Wilson here.

ThomasFremont

RaceBannon said:

By 50

But the balls were deflated!!1!

PurpleJ

I'll take Tom Brady.

phineas

Russell Wilson is a champion. Cam is an immature overgrown child with what, 1 playoff win? I'm going with Russell

dnc

Wilson wiff a bullet. Russell's the only one of those two who has shown for any stretch at all that he can win and lead a team with just his ability to throw. Luck's overrated but I'd take his next ten years over Cam's. Wilson's the best I've ever seen at avoiding big hits. Cam seeks them out. Cam is an absolute monster at the goal line but that's the only thing he does better than either of the others. He might be able to get away with that shit for another 3-4 years but his body is guaranteed to break down.

Russ is also 4-1 head to head and it's not like Carolina's defense has sucked.