the return of 5 reasons

dhdawg

finally got the fucktard who refuted every reason with stats to back up his "facts"
then someone quoted his post and said "boom"

dhdawg

I do find it funny when he says wilson isn't even a top 10 QB. give me 10 you'd take over him.
reg season manning, brady, luck, rodgers, no one immediately comes to mind after that. maybe Ryan? Rivers?

PurpleBaze

dhdawg said:

I do find it funny when he says wilson isn't even a top 10 QB. give me 10 you'd take over him.
reg season manning, brady, luck, rodgers, no one immediately comes to mind after that. maybe Ryan? Rivers?

At this point in time, Wilson is right where he belongs. He is in good company with Brady, Rodgers, and Luck. Stick a fork in Manning, he's done. Matt Ryan can be good, but he doesn't have a good supporting cast around him. Rivers, while incredibly talented, doesn't seem to have what it takes to carry the team to the next level.

dnc

dhdawg said:

I do find it funny when he says wilson isn't even a top 10 QB. give me 10 you'd take over him.
reg season manning, brady, luck, rodgers, no one immediately comes to mind after that. maybe Ryan? Rivers?

There's no way you can find 10 QB's better than Wilson.

Your top 4 are the only obvious options. No way I'd take Ryan or Rivers over him. I think you could actually make a good argument for Romo who's been chronically underrated IMO. Playing all those years for Jerry Jones FS has destroyed his national rep, but dude's really good. I'd rather have Wilson for Seattle though.

After Seattle wins three or four championships I'd like to see them acquire a legitimate top 2 or 3 WR in the league like NE did with Moss just to see what Wilson could do with that type of weapon. But as long as the defense and running game is as strong as it is I'd rather just keep winning titles.

I really think Luck-Wilson is setting up as the next Manning-Brady with Luck having the numbers and all the press but Wilson the postseason success.

HeretoBeatmyChest

There are only a few QB's who can sniff Russ' jock.

dhdawg

romo's in that category with rivers and ryan

Fire_Marshall_Bill

I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.

dhdawg

ah yes, forgot Ben. that's my top 5.
Luck Manning Brady Ben Rodgers in some order.

SteveInShelton

No way you take Manning over Wilson, unless you want to lose in the playoffs every year. Before the Patriots game you could make an argument for Flacco over Wilson but Flacco royally fucked up that game. Agree about Big Ben, the gap is closing there. Rodgers, Romo, Brady are better right now but are also older. I would probably take Luck too, his coaching staff seems retarded and I think Carroll would coach the turnovers out of him.

Doogles

Fire_Marshall_Bill said:

I'd take Brady, Rodgers, P. Manning, and probably Rapelisberger over RW but that's it, and Peyton is fading fast and RW is closing in on Rapelisberger's level.

If he had a horrific knee, hip, or general leg injury and lost his speed, then he's probably behind the Romo/Rivers/Ryan class.

Manning is done. He was horrific today. His postseason woes are only magnified by his decreasing physicality. He simply could not push the ball down the field.

I noticed how he kept overthrowing his receivers during that stretch of 6 incomplete passes where Denver kept trying to go deep. This is because he no longer has the arm to afford touch on his deep ball. He is overthrowing because anything less than 100% and it won't get home or float for an easy pick.

That was the moment I knew he was done. Psychologically this game finished him. Wilson is better today and forever more moving forward.