Is Petersen our Truman?

YellowSnow

I.e., a leader with lower approval ratings from us after the 2018 and 2019 disappointment, but who will be judged more favorably in decades to come by Hardcore Historians (invite still stands @CarlinBuff )?

I still hate Pete for not wanting to nuke the North Koreans and Chinese in the 2019 Rose Bowl and for whatever his role was in the Jimmy Lake getting hired.

But some of that hate has faded over the past week of DeBoerGate.

RaceBannon

They each fucked the program for different reasons

But 2023 will always be better than anything Pete did

PurpleBaze

I still hate him for the 2018 & 2019 Cal & Oregon games.

He killed my inner doog.

whatshouldicareabout

Pete had his flaws, but he's the only genuine guy we've had as a coach since forever

That said, DeBoer is the better coach and won games that Pete would've lost (like ASU and OSU this year)

HFNY

If Pete's heart and soul wasn't into being a big-time CFB coach anymore, how would it have benefited UW for him to stick around after the 2019 season?

If anything, it was Cohen's fault for not doing a more aggressive search. Sure Lake was a natural candidate but he had never been a HC before and she should be judged by the results of his tenure (and lingering buyout). She also saddled UW with Hopkins.

dirtysouwfdawg

He could recruit, he was honest, and he was sincere.

I hate him less now but that’s only because I have so much haie in my heart to allocate and dedouche and TOF get the majority of it.

YellowSnow

RaceBannon said:

They each fucked the program for different reasons

But 2023 will always be better than anything Pete did

Agree.

But my DeBoer hate is burning much more intensely than my Pete hate, and I don't see that changing anytime soon.

I require my Husky Football head coaches to be ALL IN, LFG during Natty runs. Anything less, is an unforgiveable sin.

Geevis_and_Butthead

whatshouldicareabout said:

Pete had his flaws, but he's the only genuine guy we've had as a coach since forever

That said, DeBoer is the better coach and won games that Pete would've lost (like ASU and OSU this year)

That said, Petersen is the better recruiter and brought in the talent that allowed DeBoer to win games like Oregon (thrice) and Texas

haie

Petersen appears to be trying to hang out in the background and bring some stability to the program. He did it for DeBoer and he's putting even more effort now with Fisch. Showed up to the natty, backs us on national TV in front of a bunch of SC/B1G homers, and in general has been a positive. He truly just doesn't want the grind anymore.

I will still never forgive him for the 2019 + Lake stuff, but I can't say that it isn't healthy for the program to have this kind of asset. Just sucks he never finished the job those 3 years.

Geevis_and_Butthead

James: A

DeBoer: A-

Petersen: B+

Lambright: B/B-

Neuheisel: B/B-

Sarkisian: B-/C+

Gilbertson: F

Willingham: F

Lake: F-

DerekJohnson

Petersen was a B-, Lambo as much as I loved him, was a C

Houhusky

haie said:

Petersen appears to be trying to hang out in the background and bring some stability to the program. He did it for DeBoer and he's putting even more effort now with Fisch. Showed up to the natty, backs us on national TV in front of a bunch of SC/B1G homers, and in general has been a positive. He truly just doesn't want the grind anymore.

I will still never forgive him for the 2019 + Lake stuff, but I can't say that it isn't healthy for the program to have this kind of asset. Just sucks he never finished the job those 3 years.

I do give Petersen some credit for recognizing that he was burned out and done, and for stepping aside. Most coaches tend to do what Chip is doing at UCLA— not giving a fuck, banging towel boys in the locker room after practice, and watching everything decay while cashing paychecks.

TXDawg

At least Pete has stuck around and works to help the program out. Didn't just catch a flight to Destin.

PurpleJ

Neuheisel > Pete

Winners win

PostGameOrangeSlices

PurpleJ said:

Neuheisel > Pete

Winners win

Petersen wouldve clown stomped 8-5 Purdue.

Petersen got insanely tougher games than that.

PurpleJ

PostGameOrangeSlices said:

PurpleJ said:

Neuheisel > Pete

Winners win

Petersen wouldve clown stomped 8-5 Purdue.

Petersen got insanely tougher games than that.

I don’t deal in hypotheticals. Winners win. Pete was 0-3 in major bowls.

The COOG bored is thattaway

CallMeBigErn

PurpleJ said:

Neuheisel > Pete

Winners win

PostGameOrangeSlices

PurpleJ said:

PostGameOrangeSlices said:

PurpleJ said:

Neuheisel > Pete

Winners win

Petersen wouldve clown stomped 8-5 Purdue.

Petersen got insanely tougher games than that.

I don’t deal in hypotheticals. Winners win. Pete was 0-3 in major bowls.

The COOG bored is thattaway

Different era.

Petersen faced 13-1 Bama in the South, 11-2 Penn State (losses by a total of 4 points), and 11-1 tOSU.

I tell Duck fans the same shit when they pop off about the 2019 Rose Bowl. Congrats, you beat the 3 loss conference Runner Up.

Neu popped off and then imploded. The leftovers of Peterlips made a natty.

Petersen > Neu.

PurpleJ

Doogs gonna Doog. Never had much hope for you anyways.

whlinder

whatshouldicareabout said:

Pete had his flaws, but he's the only genuine guy we've had as a coach since forever

Rick was pretty genuine. He was who he was.

PostGameOrangeSlices

PurpleJ said:

Doogs gonna Doog. Never had much hope for you anyways.

Neu's plummeting tanked the program and led to 0-12

Doog.