Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Pac-12 Power Rankings Week Four

123578

Comments

  • TheHB
    TheHB Member Posts: 6,705
    bisonduck said:

    TheHB said:

    I like to call short passes an extension of the run game. I do that.

    Philosophically you can hate it. That said, it doesn’t mean Nix cannot process the play when it’s a designed throw behind the LOS.
    Of course. And I think Nix is a good QB. I still think he is quicker to check down and/or run than Penix is. Regardless of the play call. That's all. Not really a knock, but I know you guys like to find slights even when they're not there. (Hi Dan Lanning!)
  • bisonduck
    bisonduck Member Posts: 715
    edited September 2023
    Also, is everyone here saying Polk is better than Troy Franklin? It seems to be the consensus.
  • bisonduck
    bisonduck Member Posts: 715
    TheHB said:

    bisonduck said:

    TheHB said:

    I like to call short passes an extension of the run game. I do that.

    Philosophically you can hate it. That said, it doesn’t mean Nix cannot process the play when it’s a designed throw behind the LOS.
    Of course. And I think Nix is a good QB. I still think he is quicker to check down and/or run than Penix is. Regardless of the play call. That's all. Not really a knock, but I know you guys like to find slights even when they're not there. (Hi Dan Lanning!)
    I think Bo might have scrambled 3x on a designed pass plays and each time it extended the drive. Also, it’s not a check down if play is required to be behind the LOS. I didn’t take it as a slight. I didn’t take it as a slight. It’s just wrong.

    There’s a lot of RPOs with throws that are required behind the LOS because of the blocking scheme.

    A check down by definition should be a throw behind the sticks when there are vertical routes beyond the sticks.

  • dnc
    dnc Member Posts: 56,855
    bisonduck said:

    TheHB said:

    Sources said:

    dtd said:

    Nix is not a clutch QB.

    Nix is skittish in the pocket and an unsure passer.

    Doog bullshit.

    Define clutch. He had game winning last minute drives against WSU, and UNC in the bowel game, last year. He played on 1 leg in the win against Utah when everyone, including myself, thought it was going to be a bloodbath. The UW and OS losses are all time nut kicks I will never forget, but Nix had 600 yards and 5 TDs in those 2.

    He's also constantly looking down field and going for big plays instead of running the ball. He's the opposite of skittish, he's in total command.

    Oh, and I spent $400 to drive up to Dallas to watch him lead a last minute drive to beat Oregon(nothing else matters).

    And yes, UW/UO is a name your score game for the Huskies this year, and I have come to peace with that. FYFMFE.
    I agree with most of this, but Nix is not a guy who looks downfield "constantly"

    Well, he might look downfield, but he is is quicker to pull the trigger on check downs and runs than Penix ... for a variety of reasons.
    On many of those throws we have blockers downfield and the throw has to be behind the LOS. Those are an extension of the run game.

    It’s like many of you don’t watch Oregon.

    It's because we do watch Oregon that the 80% completion percentage is meaningless.

    At least half his passes against CU were at or behind the LOS.

    Oregon's weapons on the outside are impressive and if no one can stop it then there's no reason to do anything different. But there's no point comparing Nix's numbers (or the pass protection numbers) to anyone else. Oregon's passing attack this year makes the Air Raid look vertical.
  • pawz
    pawz Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 22,515 Founders Club

    DucksFC said:

    I almost thought this was the Duck bored with all this dooging and quooking bullshit.

    UW/UO game will be a pick your score. Both teams offense with the best of them, and defense questionably. First team to not shit their pants and actually play pass defense wins.

    Oregon is getting boat raced at Huskieieiie Stadium

    Take all the screenshots you need
    Agree.

    #BringYourOwnPlunger


  • WoolleyDoog
    WoolleyDoog Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 5,740 Founders Club
    dnc said:

    bisonduck said:

    TheHB said:

    Sources said:

    dtd said:

    Nix is not a clutch QB.

    Nix is skittish in the pocket and an unsure passer.

    Doog bullshit.

    Define clutch. He had game winning last minute drives against WSU, and UNC in the bowel game, last year. He played on 1 leg in the win against Utah when everyone, including myself, thought it was going to be a bloodbath. The UW and OS losses are all time nut kicks I will never forget, but Nix had 600 yards and 5 TDs in those 2.

    He's also constantly looking down field and going for big plays instead of running the ball. He's the opposite of skittish, he's in total command.

    Oh, and I spent $400 to drive up to Dallas to watch him lead a last minute drive to beat Oregon(nothing else matters).

    And yes, UW/UO is a name your score game for the Huskies this year, and I have come to peace with that. FYFMFE.
    I agree with most of this, but Nix is not a guy who looks downfield "constantly"

    Well, he might look downfield, but he is is quicker to pull the trigger on check downs and runs than Penix ... for a variety of reasons.
    On many of those throws we have blockers downfield and the throw has to be behind the LOS. Those are an extension of the run game.

    It’s like many of you don’t watch Oregon.

    It's because we do watch Oregon that the 80% completion percentage is meaningless.

    At least half his passes against CU were at or behind the LOS.

    Oregon's weapons on the outside are impressive and if no one can stop it then there's no reason to do anything different. But there's no point comparing Nix's numbers (or the pass protection numbers) to anyone else. Oregon's passing attack this year makes the Air Raid look vertical.
    If you can throw a bunch of sideways passes and succeed, why not? Especially because it probably slows pass rush and spreads out defenses for run game success. Outside of Franklin, and Irving as a receiver somewhat, are their outside weapons really that impressive? After Franklin the receivers have looked pretty JAGy thus far and have maybe had 100 yards in their two games against P5 opponents, including Colorado's awful D.
    bisonduck said:

    Also, is everyone here saying Polk is better than Troy Franklin? It seems to be the consensus.

    Stats are comparable. I've been super impressed with Polk so far. Hard to say because you could say Franklin should get credit for doing it without Odunze and McMillan distracting coverage but you could also say Polk might be even more productive and impressive if he was a clear number one target.
  • bisonduck
    bisonduck Member Posts: 715
    edited September 2023
    Oregon’s other WRs are Tez Johnson, Gary Bryant Jr and Taeshon Holden. Tez is an absolute mismatch in the slot. Oregon doesn’t throw it 50x downfield so production is meaningless.

    They’re not as good as UWs trio but probably the best collection at Oregon that I can remember.
  • dnc
    dnc Member Posts: 56,855

    dnc said:

    bisonduck said:

    TheHB said:

    Sources said:

    dtd said:

    Nix is not a clutch QB.

    Nix is skittish in the pocket and an unsure passer.

    Doog bullshit.

    Define clutch. He had game winning last minute drives against WSU, and UNC in the bowel game, last year. He played on 1 leg in the win against Utah when everyone, including myself, thought it was going to be a bloodbath. The UW and OS losses are all time nut kicks I will never forget, but Nix had 600 yards and 5 TDs in those 2.

    He's also constantly looking down field and going for big plays instead of running the ball. He's the opposite of skittish, he's in total command.

    Oh, and I spent $400 to drive up to Dallas to watch him lead a last minute drive to beat Oregon(nothing else matters).

    And yes, UW/UO is a name your score game for the Huskies this year, and I have come to peace with that. FYFMFE.
    I agree with most of this, but Nix is not a guy who looks downfield "constantly"

    Well, he might look downfield, but he is is quicker to pull the trigger on check downs and runs than Penix ... for a variety of reasons.
    On many of those throws we have blockers downfield and the throw has to be behind the LOS. Those are an extension of the run game.

    It’s like many of you don’t watch Oregon.

    It's because we do watch Oregon that the 80% completion percentage is meaningless.

    At least half his passes against CU were at or behind the LOS.

    Oregon's weapons on the outside are impressive and if no one can stop it then there's no reason to do anything different. But there's no point comparing Nix's numbers (or the pass protection numbers) to anyone else. Oregon's passing attack this year makes the Air Raid look vertical.
    If you can throw a bunch of sideways passes and succeed, why not? Especially because it probably slows pass rush and spreads out defenses for run game success. Outside of Franklin, and Irving as a receiver somewhat, are their outside weapons really that impressive? After Franklin the receivers have looked pretty JAGy thus far and have maybe had 100 yards in their two games against P5 opponents, including Colorado's awful D.
    bisonduck said:

    Also, is everyone here saying Polk is better than Troy Franklin? It seems to be the consensus.

    Stats are comparable. I've been super impressed with Polk so far. Hard to say because you could say Franklin should get credit for doing it without Odunze and McMillan distracting coverage but you could also say Polk might be even more productive and impressive if he was a clear number one target.
    I wouldn't trade weapons with them by any means but they have been really good at making people miss and turning those screens into very positive yards. They seem to block pretty well on the outside too.
  • bisonduck
    bisonduck Member Posts: 715
    From what I’ve seen, Polk has elite hands. Troy Franklin has an elite release off the line. The dude is constantly wide open.

    Tez Johnson will be the quickest on the field.

    This should be an absolute battle royale.