Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Why is it so fucking hard for so many people to admit...
Comments
-
Confirmation from @HHusky’s children needed.RaceBannon said:
Is that what your two students told you?PurpleThrobber said:
Uncle Joe was a peacemaker. Wouldn't hurt a fly. Just misunderstood.RaceBannon said:And it sent Joe home helping to win the peace
No wall in Japan
Same as Mao. -
Coeds with daddy issues. Clearly.NorthwestFresh said:
Confirmation from @HHusky’s children needed.RaceBannon said:
Is that what your two students told you?PurpleThrobber said:
Uncle Joe was a peacemaker. Wouldn't hurt a fly. Just misunderstood.RaceBannon said:And it sent Joe home helping to win the peace
No wall in Japan
Same as Mao.
-
Rumor is, one of his Daddy Issue Daughters ended up in Pullman in a Sorority
-
I didn't want to do it. But rulz are rulz.doogie said:Rumor is, one of his Daddy Issue Daughters ended up in Pullman in a Sorority
YKW
-
I used to subscribe to that too. But we wouldn't have had to invade. Not playing violins for Japan; you can't start a war and complain of the consequences. But our bombers were creating mass devastation using just conventional bombs and Japan was prepared to surrender.PurpleThrobber said:ThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
March 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Iwo_JimaThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
June 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Okinawa
Except the Japanese mounted even more fierce defense as the US troops inched closer.
Invasion would have been a bloodbath - both sides. -
Source?HHusky said:
I used to subscribe to that too. But we wouldn't have had to invade. Not playing violins for Japan; you can't start a war and complain of the consequences. But our bombers were creating mass devastation using just conventional bombs and Japan was prepared to surrender.PurpleThrobber said:ThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
March 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Iwo_JimaThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
June 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Okinawa
Except the Japanese mounted even more fierce defense as the US troops inched closer.
Invasion would have been a bloodbath - both sides. -
No they weren’t. They were crippled, but far from ready to surrender.HHusky said:
I used to subscribe to that too. But we wouldn't have had to invade. Not playing violins for Japan; you can't start a war and complain of the consequences. But our bombers were creating mass devastation using just conventional bombs and Japan was prepared to surrender.PurpleThrobber said:ThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
March 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Iwo_JimaThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
June 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Okinawa
Except the Japanese mounted even more fierce defense as the US troops inched closer.
Invasion would have been a bloodbath - both sides. -
As I recall, certain military elements threatened a coup to stop surrender.ThomasFremont said:
No they weren’t. They were crippled, but far from ready to surrender.HHusky said:
I used to subscribe to that too. But we wouldn't have had to invade. Not playing violins for Japan; you can't start a war and complain of the consequences. But our bombers were creating mass devastation using just conventional bombs and Japan was prepared to surrender.PurpleThrobber said:ThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
March 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Iwo_JimaThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
June 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Okinawa
Except the Japanese mounted even more fierce defense as the US troops inched closer.
Invasion would have been a bloodbath - both sides. -
The Japanese Imperial Army was much more extreme w/r/t Bushido code than the Navy. Without checking, I’d assume that any coup attempt originated there.GrundleStiltzkin said:
As I recall, certain military elements threatened a coup to stop surrender.ThomasFremont said:
No they weren’t. They were crippled, but far from ready to surrender.HHusky said:
I used to subscribe to that too. But we wouldn't have had to invade. Not playing violins for Japan; you can't start a war and complain of the consequences. But our bombers were creating mass devastation using just conventional bombs and Japan was prepared to surrender.PurpleThrobber said:ThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
March 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Iwo_JimaThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
June 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Okinawa
Except the Japanese mounted even more fierce defense as the US troops inched closer.
Invasion would have been a bloodbath - both sides. -
There were feelers by Japan to negotiate a peace as early as 1944 and surrender had plainly been offered by June 1945. It's not seriously disputed now and you can find it discussed in multiple histories. We ended up leaving the Emperor in place anyway, which was really the only condition the Japanese had sought .GrundleStiltzkin said:
Source?HHusky said:
I used to subscribe to that too. But we wouldn't have had to invade. Not playing violins for Japan; you can't start a war and complain of the consequences. But our bombers were creating mass devastation using just conventional bombs and Japan was prepared to surrender.PurpleThrobber said:ThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
March 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Iwo_JimaThomasFremont said:
Implying that the state of WWII right before we dropped the bomb was the equivalent to a 1-0 lead is the exact opposite of reality.USMChawk said:
A better sports analogy is you’re taking a 1-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth.Yeah, you’re winning but you still need to close it out. The atomic bombs are your closers.Houhusky said:
The real sport analogy is that the bombs were back to back possessions of holding until the shot-clock is low and then nailing 3 pointers near the end of the game.GrundleStiltzkin said:
There is fair debate on the impact (lol) of The Bomb, but that's a bad analogy.ThomasFremont said:
VE Day came before we dropped the bomb. Japan was pushed back to the home islands cut off from resources and allies before we dropped the bomb. The bomb sped up the timeline of the Japanese surrender, but they were finished with or without it.TurdBomber said:
Okay, I'll play along. Let's hear the Revisions, SlowTommy.ThomasFremont said:
The atomic bomb didn’t win WWII, are you that simple?TurdBomber said:Besides, FDR won WWII, so he can pop off.
Leave the history to the pros, pal. This ain’t your wheelhouse.
Source: @ThomasFremont: The Legend, the History Pro, and Pal.
Good think I have @ThomasFremont around to remind me that the Great Depression lasted only 4 years and it was FDR who dropped the Atomic Bombs on Japan that won WW2.
So I guess it wasn't over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor, right Tommy?
Leave history to the pros, pal.
Indeed. POTD
What won WW2, SlowTommy?
If you want to make the case that the bomb saved us the trouble of invading the home islands, I’m all good. But that wasn’t your point. If you want to argue the bomb halted further Soviet expansion since we got it FIRST!!1! I’d hear what you had to say. Still would have nothing to do with winning WWII.
Saying the atomic bomb “won” the war is like saying the third string freshman phenom RB “won” the game because he scored a highlight garbage time TD as the clock expired up 4 scores.
They were daggers that ensured no miracle comeback, no 20 mins of fouling and commercials, delaying the inevitable in the hopes a miracle occurs. The away team gave up and saw the inevitable, so everyone could get on the bus and go home a little bit earlier.
Also, baseball is for fags so it’s doubly perfect for this board...and this discussion.
It was the end of a hard fought but ultimately decisive game and you just want to run the clock out and get out of there without any injuries.
June 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Okinawa
Except the Japanese mounted even more fierce defense as the US troops inched closer.
Invasion would have been a bloodbath - both sides.
I'm not bashing Truman. Like I say, they are the ones who attacked Pearl Harbor and the atomic bomb was probably only somewhat more cruel than our virtually unopposed bombing using conventional weapons. But Japan had offered surrender. Both Halsey and Eisenhower believed our use of the atomic bomb was entirely unnecessary.
