Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Conservatives hate the constitution part 1

2»

Comments

  • RaceBannonRaceBannon Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 107,693 Founders Club

    Sledog said:

    Sledog said:

    .

    How that tax equality working out? Then the rich should be taxed at the same rate as everyone else. No one can find the "tax the wealthy" shit in the constitution as it doesn't exist.
    We didn't have personal income taxes the government was supposed to run on tariffs etc.

    Sweet…does that mean we get a flat tax rate? Oh, that’s right

    A progressive tax is uniform.
    Answered!
    No it's not. Uniform is far from progressive. And that's state to state. Show me where the constitution says higher percentage for higher income. I'll wait.
    With a progressive tax everyone is subject to the exact same tax rates. I would pay the same percentage for income over a million that Elon Musk would pay. And he would pay the same percentage on the first $50,000 that I would pay. It is the same, in all cases, the definition of uniform.

    The real problem with your argument is the logic of it suggests that a flat tax would also be unconstitutional. Because if the tax rate is 10% and I make $10 and you make $100 then you’re paying more. You’d make more and you’d pay more which you are currently defining as not uniform.

    So if a flat tax is unconstitutional and a progressive tax in unconstitutional, kinda makes you wonder why they bothered to make taxes constitutional. If I didn’t know any better, I’d say you’re just wrong.
    No
  • SledogSledog Member Posts: 34,460 Standard Supporter
    edited November 2021

    Sledog said:

    Sledog said:

    .

    How that tax equality working out? Then the rich should be taxed at the same rate as everyone else. No one can find the "tax the wealthy" shit in the constitution as it doesn't exist.
    We didn't have personal income taxes the government was supposed to run on tariffs etc.

    Sweet…does that mean we get a flat tax rate? Oh, that’s right

    A progressive tax is uniform.
    Answered!
    No it's not. Uniform is far from progressive. And that's state to state. Show me where the constitution says higher percentage for higher income. I'll wait.
    With a progressive tax everyone is subject to the exact same tax rates. I would pay the same percentage for income over a million that Elon Musk would pay. And he would pay the same percentage on the first $50,000 that I would pay. It is the same, in all cases, the definition of uniform.

    The real problem with your argument is the logic of it suggests that a flat tax would also be unconstitutional. Because if the tax rate is 10% and I make $10 and you make $100 then you’re paying more. You’d make more and you’d pay more which you are currently defining as not uniform.

    So if a flat tax is unconstitutional and a progressive tax in unconstitutional, kinda makes you wonder why they bothered to make taxes constitutional. If I didn’t know any better, I’d say you’re just wrong.
    Progressive tax is unequal treatment under the law just like what you claim is happening to minorities. You are dumb.
  • TheKobeStopperTheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959
    Sledog said:

    Sledog said:

    Sledog said:

    .

    How that tax equality working out? Then the rich should be taxed at the same rate as everyone else. No one can find the "tax the wealthy" shit in the constitution as it doesn't exist.
    We didn't have personal income taxes the government was supposed to run on tariffs etc.

    Sweet…does that mean we get a flat tax rate? Oh, that’s right

    A progressive tax is uniform.
    Answered!
    No it's not. Uniform is far from progressive. And that's state to state. Show me where the constitution says higher percentage for higher income. I'll wait.
    With a progressive tax everyone is subject to the exact same tax rates. I would pay the same percentage for income over a million that Elon Musk would pay. And he would pay the same percentage on the first $50,000 that I would pay. It is the same, in all cases, the definition of uniform.

    The real problem with your argument is the logic of it suggests that a flat tax would also be unconstitutional. Because if the tax rate is 10% and I make $10 and you make $100 then you’re paying more. You’d make more and you’d pay more which you are currently defining as not uniform.

    So if a flat tax is unconstitutional and a progressive tax in unconstitutional, kinda makes you wonder why they bothered to make taxes constitutional. If I didn’t know any better, I’d say you’re just wrong.
    Progressive tax is unequal treatment under the law just like what you claim is happening to minorities. You are dumb.
    Right. The unvaccinated are like Jews during the Holocaust and rich people paying taxes make them just like black people.
  • RaceBannonRaceBannon Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 107,693 Founders Club

    Sledog said:

    Sledog said:

    Sledog said:

    .

    How that tax equality working out? Then the rich should be taxed at the same rate as everyone else. No one can find the "tax the wealthy" shit in the constitution as it doesn't exist.
    We didn't have personal income taxes the government was supposed to run on tariffs etc.

    Sweet…does that mean we get a flat tax rate? Oh, that’s right

    A progressive tax is uniform.
    Answered!
    No it's not. Uniform is far from progressive. And that's state to state. Show me where the constitution says higher percentage for higher income. I'll wait.
    With a progressive tax everyone is subject to the exact same tax rates. I would pay the same percentage for income over a million that Elon Musk would pay. And he would pay the same percentage on the first $50,000 that I would pay. It is the same, in all cases, the definition of uniform.

    The real problem with your argument is the logic of it suggests that a flat tax would also be unconstitutional. Because if the tax rate is 10% and I make $10 and you make $100 then you’re paying more. You’d make more and you’d pay more which you are currently defining as not uniform.

    So if a flat tax is unconstitutional and a progressive tax in unconstitutional, kinda makes you wonder why they bothered to make taxes constitutional. If I didn’t know any better, I’d say you’re just wrong.
    Progressive tax is unequal treatment under the law just like what you claim is happening to minorities. You are dumb.
    Right. The unvaccinated are like Jews during the Holocaust and rich people paying taxes make them just like black people.
    No
  • MikeDamoneMikeDamone Member Posts: 37,781

    You’re a fucktard. It doesn’t say seize and redistribute wealth. Idiot. The “uniform” part is what makes your favorite wack jobs proposal to tax wealth unconstitutional.

    Sweet…does that mean we get a flat tax rate? Oh, that’s right

    A progressive tax is uniform.
    Answered!
    Thanks for proving me right, dumbshit.
    Agree to disagree.
    No,,you’re wrong. And ignorant.
  • RoadTripRoadTrip Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 7,926 Founders Club
    hardhat said:

    I support a tax on progressives

    Death tax
  • SledogSledog Member Posts: 34,460 Standard Supporter
    TKS doesn't know the constitution. Who'd have thought.................
  • SourcesSources Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 4,015 Founders Club
    Sledog said:

    TKS doesn't know the constitution. Who'd have thought.................

    He hasn't read it - it's too long for a tweet, especially after you finish typing RACIST a few times to get attention
Sign In or Register to comment.