Comedy / Satire Bracket (Round 1): #1 South Park vs #8 Archer

YellowSnow

dnc

#1 South Park

YellowSnow

#1 South Park

I've only watched bits and pieces of Archer. Looks like a great show. But South Park is some of the funniest shit humans have ever made. Plus my old man almost punched Trey Parker in the face once, so my family has a special connection to those guysm.

Doog_de_Jour

#1 South Park

I fucking LOVE Archer, even as the later seasons lacked the punch of earlier ones. Pam Poovey is my spirit animal, and I always recite this when having Bloody Marys:

https://youtu.be/DeaGXjD_iDY

But South Park was a goddamn phenomenon when it debuted. I saw the original “Spirit of Christmas” short at Spike & Mike’s Sick and Twisted Film Festival and thought even with the crude animation I thought it was brilliant.

https://youtu.be/OBDA6oAorPw

And Archer doesn’t have its own movie:

https://youtu.be/aav9EyVjtWc

GrundleStiltzkin

#1 South Park

Paged @Dardanus

YellowSnow

#1 South Park

Doog_de_Jour said:

I fucking LOVE Archer, even as the later seasons lacked the punch of earlier ones. Pam Poovey is my spirit animal, and I always recite this when having Bloody Marys:

https://youtu.be/DeaGXjD_iDY

But South Park was a goddamn phenomenon when it debuted. I saw the original “Spirit of Christmas” short at Spike & Mike’s Sick and Twisted Film Festival and thought even with the crude animation I thought it was brilliant.

https://youtu.be/OBDA6oAorPw

And Archer doesn’t have its own movie:

https://youtu.be/aav9EyVjtWc

Major Boobage is one of the all timers...

ThomasFremont

#1 South Park

Archer is a better show than this matchup will show, but it ran into a big time power house in South Park.

RoadDawg55

#1 South Park

Archer was really good tho. I eventually quit watching (same for South Park) but South Park had way more stuff that made me crack up.

GrundleStiltzkin

#1 South Park

Voice for the voiceless

https://twitter.com/DardanusFS/status/1243282863920832512

chuck

#1 South Park

This is about as fair as me vs racebannon.

Archer is great, but...

BleachedAnusDawg

#1 South Park

South Park should go far, but I think the past few years makes them vulnerable to an upset in a later round. The show quit being must see for me a while back.

PurpleThrobber

#1 South Park

I voted South Park not that I've watched more than a few episodes but..

I fucking laughed my ass off at Book Of Mormon. That is some funny shit. I still listen to some of the show tunes from time to time and giggle.

So, SP gets the nod from the same family.

1to392831weretaken

#1 South Park

This is a very unfortunate first round. Love both of these shows.

YellowSnow

#1 South Park

Doog_de_Jour said:

I fucking LOVE Archer, even as the later seasons lacked the punch of earlier ones. Pam Poovey is my spirit animal, and I always recite this when having Bloody Marys:

https://youtu.be/DeaGXjD_iDY

But South Park was a goddamn phenomenon when it debuted. I saw the original “Spirit of Christmas” short at Spike & Mike’s Sick and Twisted Film Festival and thought even with the crude animation I thought it was brilliant.

https://youtu.be/OBDA6oAorPw

And Archer doesn’t have its own movie:

https://youtu.be/aav9EyVjtWc

Pam splooshing is an all time favorite GIF

1to392831weretaken

#1 South Park

Doog_de_Jour said:

And Archer doesn’t have its own movie:

Not only did they make an amazing South Park movie, but The Stick of Truth may be the funniest thing that has ever existed. It's like playing a 20 hour long South Park episode that Standards and Practices completely ignored. Highlights:

1.) Playing a game of Simon on the alien spaceship, only every time you mess up the pattern, Randy gets ass-brutalized with an alien dildo.

2.) Shrinking yourself down to gerbil size to battle the Underpants Gnomes on your parents' bed. While they are fucking above you. At one point in the fight, you are prompted to rapidly mash buttons to dodge your dad's nutsack as it flies into frame, which you do in Matrix bullet time fashion.

3.) You enter Canada, at which point the game turns complete 8-bit Zelda style until you leave Canada again. I laughed for like five minutes.

4.) Shrinking yourself again, this time to climb into Mr. Slave's ass to disarm a snuke. The whole level is kind of a puzzle platformer through Mr. Slave's guts, featuring Catatafish, Sparrow Prince, etc.

They made a sequel, The Fractured But Whole, and although the gameplay wasn't as flawed and repetitive, the plot wasn't as good and funny, either.

SECDAWG

Way to much info for a farged up tune.

I must be old.

El_K

#8 Archer

I still watch Archer. Can’t say the same for South Park. SP humor to me had a pull date. Like that episode about Kanye and fish sticks. I would have to look that up to get the reference.

Doogles

#1 South Park

Love Archer, but South Park is the GOAT

huskyhooligan

#1 South Park

Archer is great. I love Pam. But gotta go SP.

Mad_Son

#1 South Park

El_K said:

I still watch Archer. Can’t say the same for South Park. SP humor to me had a pull date. Like that episode about Kanye and fish sticks. I would have to look that up to get the reference.

What? You don't like fish dicks?

CFetters_Nacho_Lover

#1 South Park

I don’t go outta my way to watch South Park but if I see it on TV, I will stop to watch. Those guysm are genius.