As much as we complain about roster mismanagement, Shaw really one upped us by taking 14 players two years in a row.
Like I don't understand how supposedly smart coaches keep getting into these situations. Its not like Stanford is struggling to recruit, they just aren't taking enough players. This is not hard math.
As much as we complain about roster mismanagement, Shaw really one upped us by taking 14 players two years in a row.
Like I don't understand how supposedly smart coaches keep getting into these situations. Its not like Stanford is struggling to recruit, they just aren't taking enough players. This is not hard math.
i think that a lot of their recruits can't get in and then a whole nother batch can't stay in... a buddy of mine played for Stanford during the Luck/Harbaugh years. He said the academis are really fucking hard and they don't gift wrap passing grades for the athletes. You go to Stanford and you are expected to be a top student and top athlete... it always seems like it'll be easy to get through once you're in but they don't help you that much b/c their global brand isn't worth watering down for a few football players. That said, graduate transfers obviously got the paper already, so that can't be the reason.
As much as we complain about roster mismanagement, Shaw really one upped us by taking 14 players two years in a row.
Like I don't understand how supposedly smart coaches keep getting into these situations. Its not like Stanford is struggling to recruit, they just aren't taking enough players. This is not hard math.
i think that a lot of their recruits can't get in and then a whole nother batch can't stay in... a buddy of mine played for Stanford during the Luck/Harbaugh years. He said the academis are really fucking hard and they don't gift wrap passing grades for the athletes. You go to Stanford and you are expected to be a top student and top athlete... it always seems like it'll be easy to get through once you're in but they don't help you that much b/c their global brand isn't worth watering down for a few football players. That said, graduate transfers obviously got the paper already, so that can't be the reason.
Ultimately most of these kids went to Stanford to win, and win damn it in front of other teams fans. That didn't happen this year and I'm guessing maybe the atmosphere down there isn't the greatest.
Last Sunday before Redskins game local radio was talking about a “splash” hire, and that Bruce Allen wanted Shaw. You want to see a demoralized fan base and apocalyptic attendance at games. Look no further than the Redskins. Come to think of it, David Shaw would be right at home with 60% of the stadium empty or filled with opposing fans.
Doing some fuzzy math between 247's scholarship breakdown and Stanford's roster page, assuming Costello leaves and everybody else stays, one dozen departing seniors puts Stanford at 64 scholarships. That's not the end of the world if they bring in a full class.
The positional breakdown is pretty crazy, though: Discounting true freshmen, they'll have nine offensive linemen (zero listed as guards!) compared to eight running backs and seven tight ends. Only five receivers. A whopping ONE interior defensive lineman, compared to nine linebackers and six defensive ends. Thirteen DBs seems about right, but a single long snapper and single kicker sums up the specialists, so either Jet Toner does all the punting and kicking or they've got a walk-on handling some of that.
They actually have the 20th ranked class at the moment (even with a scholarship to a long snapper), with 18 commits, evenly distributed positionally. They're going to continue to have some UW-2019esque holes in their roster for a couple of years, but it looks like they're recruiting smartly to eventually fix the problem. Even if they don't take another commit this cycle, they'll be carrying more scholarship players than they usually do. Losing these 12 isn't going to kill them, but strange recruiting in previous years (two total OL in '18, one transferring out) might.
Comments
Will he finally go to the NFL or stay and rip our hearts out some more?
Like I don't understand how supposedly smart coaches keep getting into these situations. Its not like Stanford is struggling to recruit, they just aren't taking enough players. This is not hard math.
Weird deal
The positional breakdown is pretty crazy, though: Discounting true freshmen, they'll have nine offensive linemen (zero listed as guards!) compared to eight running backs and seven tight ends. Only five receivers. A whopping ONE interior defensive lineman, compared to nine linebackers and six defensive ends. Thirteen DBs seems about right, but a single long snapper and single kicker sums up the specialists, so either Jet Toner does all the punting and kicking or they've got a walk-on handling some of that.
They actually have the 20th ranked class at the moment (even with a scholarship to a long snapper), with 18 commits, evenly distributed positionally. They're going to continue to have some UW-2019esque holes in their roster for a couple of years, but it looks like they're recruiting smartly to eventually fix the problem. Even if they don't take another commit this cycle, they'll be carrying more scholarship players than they usually do. Losing these 12 isn't going to kill them, but strange recruiting in previous years (two total OL in '18, one transferring out) might.