Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Johnny Manziel: What Jake Locker could have been...

24

Comments

  • dnc
    dnc Member Posts: 56,855

    Totally disagree. Manziel can actually throw the ball with competence and accuracy:

    http://espn.go.com/college-football/player/_/id/517475/johnny-manziel

    Jack Lockner was never remotely close to that efficiency as a passer.

    Boobs please come back d00d, we need you now more than ever!
  • Meek
    Meek Member Posts: 7,031
    DeLarry said:

    Jake was nowhere near the passer Manziel is, on the run or from the pocket. He also seemed to wilt in big situations. Locker, and I liked the guy, more often than not found ways to come up small when it counted.

    i respect your opinion, but i actually disagree on this based on Jake keeping us close with Ohio State single handedly, pulling that epic win against USC after he was crushed by Shareece Wright, and a few other games against Oregon, BYU and WSU. I personally think the "stepping up in big games wilting thing" is actually more a product of both Ty completely leaving Jake on his own while the rest of the team boycotted and then the Sark forcing everyone into a system that didn't align with Jake's skills. He rotted with us.
  • Meek
    Meek Member Posts: 7,031
    also at Notre Dame when he threw that straight arm and we lost after fucking up 8 plays in a row at the goal line. That wasn't Jake coming up small in my eyes.
  • ApostleofGrief
    ApostleofGrief Member Posts: 3,904
    Meek said:

    DeLarry said:

    Jake was nowhere near the passer Manziel is, on the run or from the pocket. He also seemed to wilt in big situations. Locker, and I liked the guy, more often than not found ways to come up small when it counted.

    i respect your opinion, but i actually disagree on this based on Jake keeping us close with Ohio State single handedly, pulling that epic win against USC after he was crushed by Shareece Wright, and a few other games against Oregon, BYU and WSU. I personally think the "stepping up in big games wilting thing" is actually more a product of both Ty completely leaving Jake on his own while the rest of the team boycotted and then the Sark forcing everyone into a system that didn't align with Jake's skills. He rotted with us.
    WTF? "I respect your opinion" on this bored?
  • pawz
    pawz Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 22,515 Founders Club
    dnc said:

    Totally disagree. Manziel can actually throw the ball with competence and accuracy:

    http://espn.go.com/college-football/player/_/id/517475/johnny-manziel

    Jack Lockner was never remotely close to that efficiency as a passer.

    Boobs please come back d00d, we need you now more than ever!
    i respect your opinion, but i actually disagree on this based on Jake keeping us close with Ohio State single handedly, pulling that epic win against USC after he was crushed by Shareece Wright, and a few other games against Oregon, BYU and WSU. I personally think the "stepping up in big games wilting thing" is actually more a product of both Ty completely leaving Jake on his own while the rest of the team boycotted and then the Sark forcing everyone into a system that didn't align with Jake's skills. He rotted with us.
  • FireCohen
    FireCohen Member Posts: 21,823
    At times like this, its important to remember that no one on this site knows what the fuck they're talking about
  • chuck
    chuck Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 11,837 Swaye's Wigwam
    Meek said:

    DeLarry said:

    Jake was nowhere near the passer Manziel is, on the run or from the pocket. He also seemed to wilt in big situations. Locker, and I liked the guy, more often than not found ways to come up small when it counted.

    i respect your opinion, but i actually disagree on this based on Jake keeping us close with Ohio State single handedly, pulling that epic win against USC after he was crushed by Shareece Wright, and a few other games against Oregon, BYU and WSU. I personally think the "stepping up in big games wilting thing" is actually more a product of both Ty completely leaving Jake on his own while the rest of the team boycotted and then the Sark forcing everyone into a system that didn't align with Jake's skills. He rotted with us.
    Agree. He shit the bed against Nebraska twice (they shit it worse the second time). He never really did aside from those games though. He was never a good quarterback, but wasn't any worse in the clutch than out of it. Could be argued that he stepped up a bit.

    Sark > Ty statement...Locker came up with more big plays in tight games than our current QB has (anything is more than zero, I know).