Which of these coaches would you prefer to lead your college football team?

AtomicPiss

Swaye

Chip Kelly

The Chipster. I like the gays.

RaccoonHarry

Would be hard to overcome my Saban/Meyer hate and I didn't seriously consider Janet Reno. Condi Rice, maybe...

MisterEm

Urban Meyer

If the pole was in 2005 - Saban.

2014 - Meyer all day, errryday.

topdawgnc

Urban Meyer

I kept looking for Helfrich.

TierbsHsotBoobs

Urban Meyer

RaccoonHarry said:

Would be hard to overcome my Saban/Meyer hate and I didn't seriously consider Janet Reno. Condi Rice, maybe...

Why do you hate winners?

RaccoonHarry

Envy

RoadDawg55

Urban Meyer

Splitting hairs between Urban and Saban. I give Urban the edge because he has never struggled. It took Saban time at Michigan State and a year at Alabama. I think Meyer can do more with less.

Tequilla

Janet Reno

Gary Patterson

H_D

Urban Meyer

Because he's the dreamiest in a 75K way.

Dick_B

Urban Meyer

I would prefer Jim Tressel- because he looks so awesome in a sweater vest

oregonblitzkrieg

Where's the Mark Helfrich option?

TTJ

Nick Saban

Harbaugh's gonna make Urban stroke out.

For my $$$, it's Saint Nick.

TierbsHsotBoobs

Urban Meyer

TTJ said:

Harbaugh's gonna make Urban stroke out.

For my $$$, it's Saint Nick.

Saint Nick is talking like a dude ready to retire. He was the best though.

Doogles

Urban Meyer

TierbsHsotBoobs said:

TTJ said:

Harbaugh's gonna make Urban stroke out.

For my $$$, it's Saint Nick.

Saint Nick is talking like a dude ready to retire. He was the best though.

He really did seem defeated. I think the pace of the game bothers him. His bitching a few years ago about the high tempo spread and "is this how the game was intended to be played" really exposes this.

He prefers old school football and the urbz clearly is not that.

RaceBannon

There is a short shelf life at schools like Bama and Oklahoma. Urban had to leave Florida before he died. A year off and a trip home to Ohio has him revitalized. But he's building and in year 3 when the fans are just happy that he got them here. From now on he has to do this every year.

RoadDawg55

Urban Meyer

Doogles said:

TierbsHsotBoobs said:

TTJ said:

Harbaugh's gonna make Urban stroke out.

For my $$$, it's Saint Nick.

Saint Nick is talking like a dude ready to retire. He was the best though.

He really did seem defeated. I think the pace of the game bothers him. His bitching a few years ago about the high tempo spread and "is this how the game was intended to be played" really exposes this.

He prefers old school football and the urbz clearly is not that.

He also whined about expectations being too high earlier this year. He had a great rant about giving second chances because he was criticized for bringing back DJ Pettway. He seems worn out. Chasing championships and being under the microscope at Alabama has probably taken a toll.

HFNY

Nick Saban

Saban has won 4 (FOUR!) National Championships. 3 with Alabama and 1 with LSU.

Meyer has won 2 and Kelly is 0-1.

CASE CLOSED.

PostGameOrangeSlices

can we retire the Janet Reno bullshit yet?

Shit was never funny.

GrundleStiltzkin

Urban Meyer

PostGameOrangeSlices said:

can we retire the Janet Reno bullshit yet?

Shit was never funny.

I see you're a Barney Frank kinda guy

RoadDawg55

Urban Meyer

HFNY said:

Saban has won 4 (FOUR!) National Championships. 3 with Alabama and 1 with LSU.

Meyer has won 2 and Kelly is 0-1.

CASE CLOSED.

That's pretty simplistic. There is no wrong answer, but it's not that hard to make a convincing case for Urban Meyer.

Saban - 19 years as a college head coach

Urban Meyer- 13 years.

If Ohio State wasn't on probation in 2012, the title count would likely be 3-3. 12-1 Alabama faced 12-0 Notre Dame. Ohio State was 12-0 that season. Maybe the BCS would have found a way to sneak Alabama in, but considering Ohio State and Notre Dame are two huge, prestigious programs, I highly doubt it.

They are 2-2 head to head. 3 of those 4 games had national title implications and might as well have been part of the playoffs. Both SEC title games were #1 vs #2. Urban Meyer has a higher winning percentage.