Hypothetically speaking, better option for UW Football in 2024 and going forward: DeBoer or Fisch?

Geevis_and_Butthead

DeBoer or Fisch?

I'll go with the guy who rebuilt a lower-resource bottom feeder in Tucson and is unquestionably the better recruiter of the two

#Upgrade

TheHB

I’ll wait until next January to answer. Right now, I’d go DeBoner based on what he was able to do here, knowing the talent coming back.

EsophagealFeces

LIPO

dtd

Oh boy, here we go!

whatshouldicareabout

Depends who we get from UA and who we keep from the portal

We can debate once we see the end of spring ball

jecornel

Dumb topic. Have to go with Defraud if you must know.

Geevis_and_Butthead

TheHB said:

I’ll wait until next January to answer. Right now, I’d go DeBoner based on what he was able to do here, knowing the talent coming back.

I think DeBoer and his staff's limpdick recruiting effort was gonna catch up big-time beginning next fall.

If Fisch brings along Fifita, it's a major upgrade over the try-hard Mike Leach system guy who ended the season on the bench at Mississippi State

LawDawg1

dtd said:

Oh boy, here we go!

are you jealous of offseason natty talk or only Oregon wins those championships?

thechatch

Lol

dtd

LawDawg1 said:

dtd said:

Oh boy, here we go!

are you jealous of offseason natty talk or only Oregon wins those championships?

UW doesn't even make the 12 team playoff.

But no, I just find all of this quite amusing, and predictable. It was only a matter of tim before we got the "Fisch > DeBoer" thread.

dirtysouwfdawg

dtd said:

LawDawg1 said:

dtd said:

Oh boy, here we go!

are you jealous of offseason natty talk or only Oregon wins those championships?

UW doesn't even make the 12 team playoff.

But no, I just find all of this quite amusing, and predictable. It was only a matter of tim before we got the "Fisch > DeBoer" thread.

Yeah and all the people that chinned the OP show that the bored seconds the sentiment.

phineas

fuck deboer im going with the guy i dont hate as much yet

dtd

dirtysouwfdawg said:

dtd said:

LawDawg1 said:

dtd said:

Oh boy, here we go!

are you jealous of offseason natty talk or only Oregon wins those championships?

UW doesn't even make the 12 team playoff.

But no, I just find all of this quite amusing, and predictable. It was only a matter of tim before we got the "Fisch > DeBoer" thread.

Yeah and all the people that chinned the OP show that the bored seconds the sentiment.

haha, word.

DoogmanRefund

Gonna take awhile to earn the trust of this jilted lover again. Does he have decent defensive coaching contacts?I don’t follow recruiting at all anymore. Is there a JTT or non-Fetters 5 star coming up anytime soon? Can he repair relationships with Eastside Catholic, O’Dea, Kennedy, Bellevue, Rainier Beach etc? Do those schools matter anymore? Does teen boy stalking matter anymore?
This team probably sucks next year with literally anyone coaching. So, no. Would have won 7 with staff intact. Might not make a bowl next year.

dtd

DoogmanRefund said:

Gonna take awhile to earn the trust of this jilted lover again. Does he have decent defensive coaching contacts?I don’t follow recruiting at all anymore. Is there a JTT or non-Fetters 5 star coming up anytime soon? Can he repair relationships with Eastside Catholic, O’Dea, Kennedy, Bellevue, Rainier Beach etc? Do those schools matter anymore? Does teen boy stalking matter anymore?
This team probably sucks next year with literally anyone coaching. So, no. Would have won 7 with staff intact. Might not make a bowl next year.

UW will definitely not suck next year with Fifita, TMac and an infusion of talent from UA's oline.

DoogmanRefund

dtd said:

DoogmanRefund said:

Gonna take awhile to earn the trust of this jilted lover again. Does he have decent defensive coaching contacts?I don’t follow recruiting at all anymore. Is there a JTT or non-Fetters 5 star coming up anytime soon? Can he repair relationships with Eastside Catholic, O’Dea, Kennedy, Bellevue, Rainier Beach etc? Do those schools matter anymore? Does teen boy stalking matter anymore?
This team probably sucks next year with literally anyone coaching. So, no. Would have won 7 with staff intact. Might not make a bowl next year.

UW will definitely not suck next year with Fifita, TMac and an infusion of talent from UA's oline.

I’m not even a little bit convinced they’re transferring. Could totally see a situation where they rally around a shitty coordinator to HC promotion and try to finish what they started in Tucson.

dirtysouwfdawg

DoogmanRefund said:

dtd said:

DoogmanRefund said:

Gonna take awhile to earn the trust of this jilted lover again. Does he have decent defensive coaching contacts?I don’t follow recruiting at all anymore. Is there a JTT or non-Fetters 5 star coming up anytime soon? Can he repair relationships with Eastside Catholic, O’Dea, Kennedy, Bellevue, Rainier Beach etc? Do those schools matter anymore? Does teen boy stalking matter anymore?
This team probably sucks next year with literally anyone coaching. So, no. Would have won 7 with staff intact. Might not make a bowl next year.

UW will definitely not suck next year with Fifita, TMac and an infusion of talent from UA's oline.

I’m not even a little bit convinced they’re transferring. Could totally see a situation where they rally around a shitty coordinator to HC promotion and try to finish what they started in Tucson.

This. I’ll believe it when I see it.

bananasnblondes

Eklund is usually useless but right after DeBoer left he did have some insight that I think is correct. He said one of the main reasons DeBoer left was he felt like he was in for a long season in 2024 due to players leaving and his own lack of recruiting success. He mentioned that even some of the players penciled in as returning starters for 2024 were planning on hitting the portal regardless of deboor being coach or not. Muhammad was one of them.

A world could exist where we end up with a better roster next year with Fisch than we would have with DeBoor

haie

bananasnblondes said:

Eklund is usually useless but right after DeBoer left he did have some insight that I think is correct. He said one of the main reasons DeBoer left was he felt like he was in for a long season in 2024 due to players leaving and his own lack of recruiting success. He mentioned that even some of the players penciled in as returning starters for 2024 were planning on hitting the portal regardless of deboor being coach or not. Muhammad was one of them.

A world could exist where we end up with a better roster next year with Fisch than we would have with DeBoor

We're 100% going to have a better roster. Doesn't mean DeBoer couldn't get more wins out of next year. Either way it was going to be reloading/rebuilding and DeBoer's a bitch if that was a big deal to him.

chuck

*We upgraded from the guy who followed 4-8 with 25-3 because this guy might be a better recruiter?

Nah I'd be happier if I woke up and the whole thing was a bad dream. A 21 game win streak, 9-2 ( or whatever it ended at) record against ranked teams, perfect regular season and championship game appearance were pretty cool. Those things speak louder to me than TBS rankings.

I'm happy with Fisch. Great job by the school and AD. UW surprised and impressed me. Twisting so that this is better than Deboer being the guy I'd hoped he was and telling Alabama to fuck off is a leap I can't make though.

LawDawg1

dtd said:

LawDawg1 said:

dtd said:

Oh boy, here we go!

are you jealous of offseason natty talk or only Oregon wins those championships?

UW doesn't even make the 12 team playoff.

But no, I just find all of this quite amusing, and predictable. It was only a matter of tim before we got the "Fisch > DeBoer" thread.

Pretty sure UW wouldn’t make the 12 team playoff with Deboer. 2024 was always going to take a nose dive. Not sure a single person on this board thought we would.