5th Annual Jesse Callier Commemorative Post-Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Survey RESULTS (2019)
Comments
-
I'm open to discussion as to why Sugar Shane Bozeman isn't a 1
-
So I think we all sort of vary a little on what 2-3-4 rankings are, but generally, id bet we all think a 5 is a complete baller, best in the nation worthy and a 1 contributed nothing. For me, Bowman hit the field and played. Thats a minimum 2 ranking.
-
People forget why this thing started in the first place.kh83 said:So I think we all sort of vary a little on what 2-3-4 rankings are, but generally, id bet we all think a 5 is a complete baller, best in the nation worthy and a 1 contributed nothing. For me, Bowman hit the field and played. Thats a minimum 2 ranking.
It's because Jessie Callier WAS a 3 star and I'll die on that sword!
-
Unlike previous years this was the first time I actually knew who all the players were, all the Sark baggage has been removed.
-
He was a low 3, but I agree.Doogles said:
People forget why this thing started in the first place.kh83 said:So I think we all sort of vary a little on what 2-3-4 rankings are, but generally, id bet we all think a 5 is a complete baller, best in the nation worthy and a 1 contributed nothing. For me, Bowman hit the field and played. Thats a minimum 2 ranking.
It's because Jessie Callier WAS a 3 star and I'll die on that sword!
My rating system is something like:
1 - never played, or only played in garbage time and generally sucked - Michael Neal
2 - played a bit, maybe some spot starts, but never held down a full season and/or generally was below average when on the field - Shane Bowman
3 - started about a year and likely contributed another year or two, but generally pretty average - Tevis Bartlett
4 - multi-year starter, above average for at least a year, likely with some postseason honors like Pac-12 1st or 2nd team - BBK
5 - multi-year starter that was above average for multiple years. Made lots of splash plays and won a significant award like the Morris Trophy or was an All-American - MMFG
From there, I will bump up or down a point, given my personal like/dislike of said player. My system likely overrates longevity, but IMHO a guy like Gaskin that stays 4 years and sets a ton of records has a more impactful career than a guy like Byron Murphy that kills it for 18 games and then goes to the NFL. This year was tough because there were so many likeable players in that 3+ range (Sample, String, Tevis, Miller, McIntosh, etc.) -
#myJohnson love the kid
-
I’m thinking we should do a poll of everyone who voted. I give myself a 5 because I’m awesome. Probably @swaye a 5 too but only because of white guilt.
-
I give swaye 4, he lost 1 star because he accepted a white woman as his master and has given her his ballsCFetters_Nacho_Lover said:I’m thinking we should do a poll of everyone who voted. I give myself a 5 because I’m awesome. Probably @swaye a 5 too but only because of white guilt.
-
When a white woman lets a red man go backdoor, she becomes an honorary tribe member. Checkmate.WeakarmCobra said:
I give swaye 4, he lost 1 star because he accepted a white woman as his master and has given her his ballsCFetters_Nacho_Lover said:I’m thinking we should do a poll of everyone who voted. I give myself a 5 because I’m awesome. Probably @swaye a 5 too but only because of white guilt.
-
prove it bitch!!! put the premium content in the WAMSwaye said:
When a white woman lets a red man go backdoor, she becomes an honorary tribe member. Checkmate.WeakarmCobra said:
I give swaye 4, he lost 1 star because he accepted a white woman as his master and has given her his ballsCFetters_Nacho_Lover said:I’m thinking we should do a poll of everyone who voted. I give myself a 5 because I’m awesome. Probably @swaye a 5 too but only because of white guilt.
