Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

5th Annual Jesse Callier Commemorative Post-Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Survey RESULTS (2019)

12346»

Comments

  • RoadDawg55
    RoadDawg55 Member Posts: 30,388 Standard Supporter
    dhdawg said:

    Doogles said:


    dhdawg said:

    To be a 5 the guy needs to have multiple years playing at an elite level. Rapp and gaskin both had that. Murphy and BBK both had 1 year and that's why they are 4's.

    So guys like Corey Dillon and Minshew can never be 5s?

    Also BBK was all Pac12 as a junior and led the team in tackles by like 20, had just as many picks as Rapp(1), 2 more forced fumbles, more passes defensed, but whatever he's undersized and Dennis hates him.
    maybe my standard for a 5 is too high. I would not give minshew a 5, didn't get to watch dillon. It's almost impossible to have the program building impact required for a 5 in 1 year.
    BBK is a very high 4. Last year he put up a lot of stats but in terms of making big plays and showing up in big moments he was far and away better this year. He was abused in the Stanford game last year.
    He didn’t get abused in the Stanford game. Since Lawyer Milloy said it, it must be true?

    Some idiots on this board: “Teams run right at BBK.”

    You mean that football teams run the ball between the tackles sometimes? Who knew?
  • FireCohen
    FireCohen Member Posts: 21,823
    This thread went to shit in a hurry
  • CFetters_Nacho_Lover
    CFetters_Nacho_Lover Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 32,708 Founders Club

    This thread went to shit in a hurry

    I made the last good poast. Not my fault that I followed up with a shitty poast
  • godawgst
    godawgst Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 2,606 Swaye's Wigwam

    dhdawg said:

    Doogles said:


    dhdawg said:

    To be a 5 the guy needs to have multiple years playing at an elite level. Rapp and gaskin both had that. Murphy and BBK both had 1 year and that's why they are 4's.

    So guys like Corey Dillon and Minshew can never be 5s?

    Also BBK was all Pac12 as a junior and led the team in tackles by like 20, had just as many picks as Rapp(1), 2 more forced fumbles, more passes defensed, but whatever he's undersized and Dennis hates him.
    maybe my standard for a 5 is too high. I would not give minshew a 5, didn't get to watch dillon. It's almost impossible to have the program building impact required for a 5 in 1 year.
    BBK is a very high 4. Last year he put up a lot of stats but in terms of making big plays and showing up in big moments he was far and away better this year. He was abused in the Stanford game last year.
    He didn’t get abused in the Stanford game. Since Lawyer Milloy said it, it must be true?

    Some idiots on this board: “Teams run right at BBK.”

    You mean that football teams run the ball between the tackles sometimes? Who knew?
    Dave Hoffman said the same thing after the Stanford game down there as well.
  • RoadDawg55
    RoadDawg55 Member Posts: 30,388 Standard Supporter
    godawgst said:

    dhdawg said:

    Doogles said:


    dhdawg said:

    To be a 5 the guy needs to have multiple years playing at an elite level. Rapp and gaskin both had that. Murphy and BBK both had 1 year and that's why they are 4's.

    So guys like Corey Dillon and Minshew can never be 5s?

    Also BBK was all Pac12 as a junior and led the team in tackles by like 20, had just as many picks as Rapp(1), 2 more forced fumbles, more passes defensed, but whatever he's undersized and Dennis hates him.
    maybe my standard for a 5 is too high. I would not give minshew a 5, didn't get to watch dillon. It's almost impossible to have the program building impact required for a 5 in 1 year.
    BBK is a very high 4. Last year he put up a lot of stats but in terms of making big plays and showing up in big moments he was far and away better this year. He was abused in the Stanford game last year.
    He didn’t get abused in the Stanford game. Since Lawyer Milloy said it, it must be true?

    Some idiots on this board: “Teams run right at BBK.”

    You mean that football teams run the ball between the tackles sometimes? Who knew?
    Dave Hoffman said the same thing after the Stanford game down there as well.
    I remember Joyner and Bryant getting abused. Love was mostly held in check until a big run late (McIntosh bad angle).