Your solution to fix the College Football Playoff (Pic Thread)
Comments
-
I have 128. Everyone gets a shot. Plus it has round robin. Do you have round robin? I thought not.Rubberfist said:The ONLY solution is a 64 team playoff with two play in games.
-
creepycoug said:
This will be heresy here, but I think fuck all that and go back to the old bowl system. I just don't think it's that important and it was sorta fun to have some fuzzy in there to debate. Go back to a two-tie Rose, one-tie Orange, one-tie Sugar, and wide open Fiesta. It mostly worked IMO, and it was more interesting.
The playoffs are anticlimactic to me. But then again, no team I like or follow closely has done anything in the playoffs, so I'm biased.
And here's some more for you
-
minion_doog said:
I like it except I think the 5 P5 champs should get spots 1-5, and then 3 at large get spots 6-8. There should be some reward to winning your conference championship game, which should be one of the spots at 5 or higher. -
If you are a fan of college football then an 8 team playoff is clearly the best solution. Every conference plays an 8 game conference schedule and the regular season is dialed back to 11 games. This allows you three out of conference games
with absolutely no pressure to win or lose because they would have somewhat limited input into whether you make the 8 team playoff. Imagine the UW actually getting back to an A-B-C schedule where we as fans wouldn't have to watch North Dakota or Eastern Washington. Our schedule could be Michigan, OK State and Minnesota. Go 0 and 3 and it doesn't matter because you can still make the playoff by winning your conference. Screw this bullshit regular season patsy scheduling that you have to do now to improve your chances of being selected to a final four. -
The problem is that our sport is being ruined my mouth breathing, booger eating, NFL losers. The old Bowl system was fine. All that needed to happen was the AP #1 and AP #2 (or by some selection committee) play 2 weeks later in the @Dennis_DeYoung Cherry Bowl. When we gave up the Rose Bowl we ceded a huge amount of power and prestige to the SEC. Before the BCS the Rose paid out double that of the Orange or Sugar.
-
Don't agree. Winning matters. Full stop. Win and you're in. We don't need to keep trying to overcome long standing biases from old men in conference rooms. Win and there's no discussion. You can always get blown out in the final eight but at least you earned the right to be there. This ain't hard. Settle it on the field.YellowSnow said:The problem is that our sport is being ruined my mouth breathing, booger eating, NFL losers. The old Bowl system was fine. All that needed to happen was the AP #1 and AP #2 (or by some selection committee) play 2 weeks later in the @Dennis_DeYoung Cherry Bowl. When we gave up the Rose Bowl we ceded a huge amount of power and prestige to the SEC. Before the BCS the Rose paid out double that of the Orange or Sugar.
-
Either go back to the old traditional bowls or have real playoffs. The problem is that hybrid structures are unsatisfying. The bowls as they stand now are virtually all semi-interesting but usually not worthwhile non conference games. A real playoff would be much, much more fun, but less money probably.
-
Almost. Leach''s plan is to play 10 games then seed 64. Those who don't get in get 2 more games vs other dreck. The remainder playoff with the higher seed hosting to ensure big crowds.RaceBannon said:We're either going to get a playoff with enough teams so it won't matter getting rid of the bowl games
But then the champ and runner up will play 4-6 games to win it
So the non play off teams play an 8 game schedule and like it?
It's fucked up. Let college ball be college ball and watch your 9-7 team lose in the wild card and fuck off -
You guys who compare wanting a playoff to waiting to turn this into the NFL are hilarious. Literally every other team sport has some sort of a playoff to determine a true champion. All of them. Including every other division of college football. You don't have to love the nFL to want a playoff, you just have to love sports.
I get that you guys are college football purists and that's cute and all but the past is for doogs and you're all living in it. -
Most other team sports suck ass compared to D1 football. Not saying causation, don’t twist.HillsboroDuck said:You guys who compare wanting a playoff to waiting to turn this into the NFL are hilarious. Literally every other team sport has some sort of a playoff to determine a true champion. All of them. Including every other division of college football. You don't have to love the nFL to want a playoff, you just have to love sports.
I get that you guys are college football purists and that's cute and all but the past is for doogs and you're all living in it.
