Conservatives want to ban trans athletes from girls sports. Their evidence is shaky.
Comments
-
The studies show performance declines when transitioning, middle of the pack in boys sports become middle of the pack in girls sports. The top end has not been shown to overwhelmingly dominate.greenblood said:For somebody that slobbers for science, it’s strange you ignore the science regarding the bone density and muscle mass advantage even in transgenders going through testosterone reduction treatment.
I blame standardized tests. -
TheKobeStopper said:
The studies show performance declines when transitioning, middle of the pack in boys sports become middle of the pack in girls sports. The top end has not been shown to overwhelmingly dominate.greenblood said:For somebody that slobbers for science, it’s strange you ignore the science regarding the bone density and muscle mass advantage even in transgenders going through testosterone reduction treatment.
I blame standardized tests.
Got a link? -
Maybe, the poll numbers on this are tricky now but it’s going to pull our way. The science is on our side and eventually all the moms in the suburbs that you’re after with this are going to realize that there aren’t any transgender girls stealing their daughters spot on the soccer team.RaceBannon said:Must be a lot of conservatives in this country
Speaking of evidence let's see it on transgender being genetic
That’s the problem when you go after 0.2% of the population, eventually people look around and wonder where the problem is. -
Got a link to that actually happening? I don’t deal in hypotheticals.WestlinnDuck said:
Got a link? A mid level varsity 6'4" boy high school basketball player would be getting multiple D1 college women schollie offers if he transitioned.TheKobeStopper said:
The studies show performance declines when transitioning, middle of the pack in boys sports become middle of the pack in girls sports. The top end has not been shown to overwhelmingly dominate.greenblood said:For somebody that slobbers for science, it’s strange you ignore the science regarding the bone density and muscle mass advantage even in transgenders going through testosterone reduction treatment.
I blame standardized tests. -
It's a problem for the girls competing against boy. If you kid doesn't start because of unfair competition, it matters.TheKobeStopper said:
Maybe, the poll numbers on this are tricky now but it’s going to pull our way. The science is on our side and eventually all the moms in the suburbs that you’re after with this are going to realize that there aren’t any transgender girls stealing their daughters spot on the soccer team.RaceBannon said:Must be a lot of conservatives in this country
Speaking of evidence let's see it on transgender being genetic
That’s the problem when you go after 0.2% of the population, eventually people look around and wonder where the problem is. -
The science is on your side? You’re a god damn wack job. Your definition of science fluctuates with whatever feeling DeJour is among the radical left win nut jobs.TheKobeStopper said:
Maybe, the poll numbers on this are tricky now but it’s going to pull our way. The science is on our side and eventually all the moms in the suburbs that you’re after with this are going to realize that there aren’t any transgender girls stealing their daughters spot on the soccer team.RaceBannon said:Must be a lot of conservatives in this country
Speaking of evidence let's see it on transgender being genetic
That’s the problem when you go after 0.2% of the population, eventually people look around and wonder where the problem is.
Why doesn’t the science have female to male champions in boys events? Women are always come to compete with men, trans or not. Many sports already co-ed up to the age of 10 or so and no one GAF. After 13 it’s a different deal. And no leftist bullshit “science” is ever going to change actual biology, But I get it, you don’t want to protect women’s spaces.
Some people are willing to fight for it though, just as they did in the 60’s 70’s and 80’s
https://www.wqad.com/article/news/three-high-school-girls-track-athletes-file-suit-after-males-win-their-event/526-251056d3-b45d-49d8-a9dc-96fb144b6376 -
Huh?TheKobeStopper said:
The studies show performance declines when transitioning, middle of the pack in boys sports become middle of the pack in girls sports. The top end has not been shown to overwhelmingly dominate.greenblood said:For somebody that slobbers for science, it’s strange you ignore the science regarding the bone density and muscle mass advantage even in transgenders going through testosterone reduction treatment.
I blame standardized tests.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1252764
You have got to be smarter than this Kobe. Read something for once. -
But what about after 2 years? What then? That’s what I thought.greenblood said:
Huh?TheKobeStopper said:
The studies show performance declines when transitioning, middle of the pack in boys sports become middle of the pack in girls sports. The top end has not been shown to overwhelmingly dominate.greenblood said:For somebody that slobbers for science, it’s strange you ignore the science regarding the bone density and muscle mass advantage even in transgenders going through testosterone reduction treatment.
I blame standardized tests.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1252764
You have got to be smarter than this Kobe. Read something for once.
-
What science is on your side?TheKobeStopper said:
Maybe, the poll numbers on this are tricky now but it’s going to pull our way. The science is on our side and eventually all the moms in the suburbs that you’re after with this are going to realize that there aren’t any transgender girls stealing their daughters spot on the soccer team.RaceBannon said:Must be a lot of conservatives in this country
Speaking of evidence let's see it on transgender being genetic
That’s the problem when you go after 0.2% of the population, eventually people look around and wonder where the problem is.
No one is going after trannies. They have entered into the arena. Game on
You're going against parents with girls in sports
Good luck -
Not a fucking chance Kobe. And science is on your side? Did your mom drop you as a kid?TheKobeStopper said:
Maybe, the poll numbers on this are tricky now but it’s going to pull our way. The science is on our side and eventually all the moms in the suburbs that you’re after with this are going to realize that there aren’t any transgender girls stealing their daughters spot on the soccer team.RaceBannon said:Must be a lot of conservatives in this country
Speaking of evidence let's see it on transgender being genetic
That’s the problem when you go after 0.2% of the population, eventually people look around and wonder where the problem is.
You’re basically telling me bone density and muscle mass make zero difference as long as you have low testosterone. Then when you get called out as a moron, you deflect to the number of transgender competitors there are.
You sure love moving that goal post, and even moving the goal post will put you on the wrong side of history on this one. This is about as stupid of a stance as your standardized test nonsense.
