Results - 7th Annual Jesse Callier Commemorative Post-Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Initiative
Comments
-
thanks @Woof, this was good entertainment
-
It was a health issue that made him leave? I never heard the reason.Bread said:Yary's coke tales was the highlight of the season.
Sama Paaama did wonders for our avg weight across the line and overall youngness of our team. I'm not gonna knock a guy for health issues out of his control. -
Tryon sucked until halfway through last season and then bailed on the team this season. You could easily pin the Cal loss on him although the entire team had AIDS that game.
I thought I was generous giving him a 2. -
Holy fuck.TTJ said:
MoldenRoadDawg55 said:
McKinney was so bad he never started another game and was beat out by two shitty true freshmen the next year. The Dabo and Browning shit is some next level stupidity. You actually think you’re making a good argument?TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3?
Guys that play terrible and only start one game in 4 years aren’t three star guys.
Joyner
Gilchrist
Gordon
Hampton
Taylor
Irvin
Pete coulda chosen any of these guys to start in Rapp’s place. In the Rose Bowl. He chose McKinney.
But hey, I filled out my survey. You fill out yours.
Joyner- was already medically retired
Gilchrist- terrible, barely played in garbage time
Gordon- redshirt, already played 4 games
Hampton- redshirt, already played 4
Irvin- redshirt, already played 4
Taylor- wrong position
Molden- wrong position
In hindsight fucking obviously CP should have rearranged the defense to get his best backups in there (Molden and Taylor) instead of the listed backup but when your best defender opts out of the game in pre-game warm-ups one doesn’t have a lot of time to make those kinds of decisions.
Why McKinney should get any credit for happening to be the guy behind the guy that infamously chickened out of the Rose Bowl is beyond me.
Just burn it all down. We are full. -
Best way to describe Taylor is that he’s an upper end JAG ... he does his job but doesn’t do anything that really pops
-
A growing trend (obviously portal rules aren’t helping) is seeing more guys flame out of the program
This puts an increasing emphasis on the need to stack quality classes because the threat of attrition will increase -
Bryant or Molden to safety should have been the move. I’m with you about the absurdity of propping McKinney up for starting against Ohio State. If McKinney is a 3 star, Psalm is a 5 star for starting a full season and the playoff game against Alabama.FremontTroll said:
Holy fuck.TTJ said:
MoldenRoadDawg55 said:
McKinney was so bad he never started another game and was beat out by two shitty true freshmen the next year. The Dabo and Browning shit is some next level stupidity. You actually think you’re making a good argument?TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3?
Guys that play terrible and only start one game in 4 years aren’t three star guys.
Joyner
Gilchrist
Gordon
Hampton
Taylor
Irvin
Pete coulda chosen any of these guys to start in Rapp’s place. In the Rose Bowl. He chose McKinney.
But hey, I filled out my survey. You fill out yours.
Joyner- was already medically retired
Gilchrist- terrible, barely played in garbage time
Gordon- redshirt, already played 4 games
Hampton- redshirt, already played 4
Irvin- redshirt, already played 4
Taylor- wrong position
Molden- wrong position
In hindsight fucking obviously CP should have rearranged the defense to get his best backups in there (Molden and Taylor) instead of the listed backup but when your best defender opts out of the game in pre-game warm-ups one doesn’t have a lot of time to make those kinds of decisions.
Why McKinney should get any credit for happening to be the guy behind the guy that infamously chickened out of the Rose Bowl is beyond me.
Just burn it all down. We are full. -
Psalm actually forced a fumbleRoadDawg55 said:
Bryant or Molden to safety should have been the move. I’m with you about the absurdity of propping McKinney up for starting against Ohio State. If McKinney is a 3 star, Psalm is a 5 star for starting a full season and the playoff game against Alabama.FremontTroll said:
Holy fuck.TTJ said:
MoldenRoadDawg55 said:
McKinney was so bad he never started another game and was beat out by two shitty true freshmen the next year. The Dabo and Browning shit is some next level stupidity. You actually think you’re making a good argument?TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3?
Guys that play terrible and only start one game in 4 years aren’t three star guys.
Joyner
Gilchrist
Gordon
Hampton
Taylor
Irvin
Pete coulda chosen any of these guys to start in Rapp’s place. In the Rose Bowl. He chose McKinney.
But hey, I filled out my survey. You fill out yours.
Joyner- was already medically retired
Gilchrist- terrible, barely played in garbage time
Gordon- redshirt, already played 4 games
Hampton- redshirt, already played 4
Irvin- redshirt, already played 4
Taylor- wrong position
Molden- wrong position
In hindsight fucking obviously CP should have rearranged the defense to get his best backups in there (Molden and Taylor) instead of the listed backup but when your best defender opts out of the game in pre-game warm-ups one doesn’t have a lot of time to make those kinds of decisions.
Why McKinney should get any credit for happening to be the guy behind the guy that infamously chickened out of the Rose Bowl is beyond me.
Just burn it all down. We are full. -
Huh?
-
Shit. My favorite exercise of the year (I don't exercise much) and I missed it. I guess I have to get over to the recruiting bored more often.
-
Holy crap just saw this. I'd give browning a -5.TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3?
