Results - 7th Annual Jesse Callier Commemorative Post-Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Initiative
Comments
-
McKinney was so bad he never started another game and was beat out by two shitty true freshmen the next year. The Dabo and Browning shit is some next level stupidity. You actually think you’re making a good argument?TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3?
Guys that play terrible and only start one game in 4 years aren’t three star guys. -
I got my jacobs mixed up. Jacob the QB, not the jacob linebacker
-
More numbers:
Average score by JCCIPIRI survey vintage
2016 – 2.33
2017 – 3.04 (lost the Peach bowl)
2018 – 2.42 (lost the Fiesta bowl)
2019 – 2.95 (lost the Rose bowl)
2020 – 2.35 (won the Vegas bowl)
2021 - 2.14 (AIDS)
Average JCCIPIRI score by recruiting class (I’m excluding earlier years that I only have partial data for, and the start rating listed is only for the guys that have left the program so far)
2013 – 2.59 (21 recruits, avg. star rating was 3.29)
2014 – 2.66 (24 recruits, avg. star rating was 3.04)
2015 – 2.27 (26 recruits, avg. star rating was 3.15)
2016 – 2.67 (13 recruits, avg. star rating was 3.38)
2017 – 2.83 (10 recruits, avg. star rating was 3.60)
2018 – 1.09 (4 recruits, avg. star rating was 3.75) - this is dead weight (Sirmon, Mosiah, Yankoff, Lowe)
2019 – 1.16 (1 recruits, avg. star rating was 4.00) - this is dead weight (Pa'ama)
2020 – 1.04 (2 recruits, avg. star rating was 4.00) - this is dead weight (Yary & Garbers)
JCCIPIRI score by HS recruiting ranking
2 star – 2.33 (11 recruits)
3 star – 2.41 (74 recruits)
4 star – 2.57 (38 recruits) - aka, 4 star talent does appear to matter a little bit, and is being dragged down by the dead weight in '18, '19, and '20 at the moment. Would be 2.79 without those guys.
Doogliest participants:
1. @Bread – 3.04 average, primarily due to his 5 ratings for Yary, Pa'ama, and Chin
2. @Bonedog – 2.67 average
3. @Swaye and @Ice_Holmvik – 2.53 average
Biggest haters:
1. @PurpleSmoke – 1.67 average
2. @dirtysouwfdawg and @NorwegianHusky – 1.73 average
Lowest correlation with other respondents
@Bread
Highest correlation with other respondents
@FecalFeast and @Doogles -
Keith Taylor was the most overrated Husky of the past 10 years - maybe that's hyperbole, but can anyone name one game changing or big play that the guy made?
-
But he is a 4 year contributor, and two-year starter, for one of the nation’s best secondaries.....lolBleachedAnusDawg said:Keith Taylor was the most overrated Husky of the past 10 years - maybe that's hyperbole, but can anyone name one game changing or big play that the guy made?
Just because person behind him sucked and was not able to keep him on the bench does not make him good. UW depth at DB is overhyped -
Yes, because they started in other games. A lot more games. That's such an obvious differentiator.TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3? -
What happens if you adjust by removing 2018-2020 since they did not contribute?Woof said:JCCIPIRI score by HS recruiting ranking
2 star – 2.33 (11 recruits)
3 star – 2.41 (74 recruits)
4 star – 2.57 (38 recruits) - aka, 4 star talent does appear to matter a little bit, and is being dragged down by the dead weight in '18, '19, and '20 at the moment. Would be 2.79 without those guys.
Would be interesting to do a subset of players who stay 3 years in the program. -
The transfer portal is going to largely ruin this exercise. Was fun while it lasted.
-
Yary's coke tales was the highlight of the season.
Sama Paaama did wonders for our avg weight across the line and overall youngness of our team. I'm not gonna knock a guy for health issues out of his control. -
MoldenRoadDawg55 said:
McKinney was so bad he never started another game and was beat out by two shitty true freshmen the next year. The Dabo and Browning shit is some next level stupidity. You actually think you’re making a good argument?TTJ said:Yes, McKinney had a bad game. In the Rose Bowl.
Against tOSU. Ask Dabo whether there’s any shame in getting torched by tOSU.
Was McKinney’s Rose Bowl worse than Browning’s Peach Bowl? Would you give Browning, or any other Husky who started in a NY6 game, a score lower than 3?
Guys that play terrible and only start one game in 4 years aren’t three star guys.
Joyner
Gilchrist
Gordon
Hampton
Taylor
Irvin
Pete coulda chosen any of these guys to start in Rapp’s place. In the Rose Bowl. He chose McKinney.
But hey, I filled out my survey. You fill out yours.
