HH Favorite Rock Album Round 1 (1980- 90) - #7 War vs #10 And Justice For All

YellowSnow

For @Swaye

GrundleStiltzkin

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

ATBS, War is quite good.

YellowSnow

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

GrundleStiltzkin said:

ATBS, War is quite good.

Agree. ATBS, AJFA is my favorite Metallica, rather easily. But I'm a weirdo.

dnc

7) U2 - War

Feels like the right thread for this classic

Swaye

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

YellowSnow said:

GrundleStiltzkin said:

ATBS, War is quite good.

Agree. ATBS, AJFA is my favorite Metallica, rather easily. But I'm a weirdo.

AJFA is 3rd or 4th for me, depending on the day, but still epic shit going on. I know many will disagree but I still think Metallica had the best 4 album start in history, top to bottom. I bet there is some stiff comp for the best lead off 4 pack though. Zeppelin for sure. Beatles. Neil Young. Stones. Dylan. Clash. Prince. ACDC. Thats all top of my head stuff and making some major assumptions.

Metallicas first 4 is beast mode for sure though.

dnc

7) U2 - War

Swaye said:

YellowSnow said:

GrundleStiltzkin said:

ATBS, War is quite good.

Agree. ATBS, AJFA is my favorite Metallica, rather easily. But I'm a weirdo.

AJFA is 3rd or 4th for me, depending on the day, but still epic shit going on. I know many will disagree but I still think Metallica had the best 4 album start in history, top to bottom. I bet there is some stiff comp for the best lead off 4 pack though. Zeppelin for sure. Beatles. Neil Young. Stones. Dylan. Clash. Prince. ACDC. Thats all top of my head stuff and making some major assumptions.

Metallicas first 4 is beast mode for sure though.

If you count Band of Gypsys then Hendrix is right there as well.

dflea

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

Great albums in a row?

High Voltage
Dirty Deeds
Let There Be Rock
Powerage
Highway to Hell
death of lead singer
Back in Black

That's a respectable list right there.

greenblood

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

I'll always vote against U2

chuck

7) U2 - War

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

YouKnowIt

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

Fuck u2

GrundleStiltzkin

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

The Virginian
Furnace Room Lullaby
Blacklisted
Fox Confessor Brings the Flood
/thread.

YellowSnow

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

I'll take it under consideration.

dnc

7) U2 - War

GrundleStiltzkin said:

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

The Virginian
Furnace Room Lullaby
Blacklisted
Fox Confessor Brings the Flood
/thread.

NCFAO

YellowSnow

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

GrundleStiltzkin said:

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

The Virginian
Furnace Room Lullaby
Blacklisted
Fox Confessor Brings the Flood
/thread.

Beggar's
Let it Bleed
Sticky Fingers
Exile on Main Street

RaceBannon

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

After the Gold Rush
Harvest
Time Fades Away
On the Beach
Tonights the Night

I'm probably wrong on the order or them being consecutive but c'mon man

YellowSnow

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

RaceBannon said:

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

After the Gold Rush
Harvest
Time Fades Away
On the Beach
Tonights the Night

I'm probably wrong on the order or them being consecutive but c'mon man

dnc

7) U2 - War

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

It’s got nothing on

An Old Raincoat Won’t Ever Let You Down
Gasoline Alley
Every Picture Tells A Story
Never A Dull Moment

YellowSnow

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

dnc said:

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

It’s got nothing on

An Old Raincoat Won’t Ever Let You Down
Gasoline Alley
Every Picture Tells A Story
Never A Dull Moment

Those are actually 4 terrific albums.

GrundleStiltzkin

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

dnc said:

chuck said:

Four great albums in a row contest would be a fun pole.

Neil's best run:

Freedom
Ragged Glory
Harvest Moon
Sleeps with Angels

I think it's the best ever, but I'm pretty biased.

It’s got nothing on

An Old Raincoat Won’t Ever Let You Down
Gasoline Alley
Every Picture Tells A Story
Never A Dull Moment

First,



Then,

RaceBannon

10) Metallica – And Justice For All

Every Picture Tells A Story is a classic album

Big favorite of my girlfriend in high school. I was 65

huskyhooligan

7) U2 - War

I love One, but every song on AJFA is 8 minutes long, which was the deciding factor.