Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Show your support for what this community means to you:
Choose a Donation Amount
(required for credit)
Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Eli is NOT a Hall of Famer

Stats are not there. If you're going to use the tired Super Bowl argument, then put Fill Simms in it too.

He was a good quarterback. That's it.


  • jhfstyle24jhfstyle24 Posts: 3,206
    2,500 Up Votes 2,500 Awesomes 2500 Comments 250 Answers
    He wasn't eve that good. Career stats are mediocre. He gets volume stats through longevity, but being mediocre for a long time isn't HOF worthy. He simply had flashes of brilliance that translated into 2 super bowls. And also a defense that got super super hot.
  • dncdnc Posts: 46,542
    10,000 Awesomes 10,000 Up Votes 25000 Comments Sixth Anniversary
  • BasemanBaseman Posts: 9,673
    Swaye's Wigwam 10,000 Awesomes 5,000 Up Votes 5000 Comments
    Eli is a sure fire HOF. 57,000 yds (20,000 more than Simms) 366 TDs (170 more than Simms). 4 time pro bowler (2 more than Simms) and 2 super bowl wins.

    He offers a better portfolio than HOFs Jim Kelley and has better bulk than Warren Moon (although half the pro bowls) and 2 super bowl rings. Career top 10 in passing yards, completions and TDs.

    Make your argument Eli sucks but he's future HOF, maybe on the first ballot.
  • doogiedoogie Posts: 7,912
    5,000 Awesomes 2,500 Up Votes 5000 Comments 250 Answers
    Eli may not be but Kolin Copperneck sure is
  • RaceBannonRaceBannon Posts: 58,748
    Swaye's Wigwam 50000 Comments 10,000 Awesomes 10,000 Up Votes
    Eli is famous. Hence the induction into the HOF. Better than Namath objectively. But Joe was famous too.

    Eli led two game winning drives against the greatest dynasty of the century. I don't care much for him or the Giants and I wanted 19-0 but winners win.

    Its enough
Sign In or Register to comment.