Quintin Somerville, 2021 4* SDE, Scottsdale (Saguaro), AZ (Offered 1/29/20)

bananasnblondes

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

dnc

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He was never actually a five star.

RoadDawg55

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

bananasnblondes

RoadDawg55 said:

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

Sub K said Somerville is the #2 absolute must get recruit after JTT. That's really all I need to hear to know this guy is probably not that good.

dnc

bananasnblondes said:

RoadDawg55 said:

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

Sub K said Somerville is the #2 absolute must get recruit after JTT. That's really all I need to hear to know this guy is probably not that good.

Please stand up to bnb

insinceredawg

bananasnblondes said:

RoadDawg55 said:

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

Sub K said Somerville is the #2 absolute must get recruit after JTT. That's really all I need to hear to know this guy is probably not that good.

This year's Jordan Banks

bananasnblondes

insinceredawg said:

bananasnblondes said:

RoadDawg55 said:

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

Sub K said Somerville is the #2 absolute must get recruit after JTT. That's really all I need to hear to know this guy is probably not that good.

This year's Jordan Banks

Went from a top 100 prospect to dropping all the way off the charts in the 247 rankings.

GrundleStiltzkin

bananasnblondes said:

insinceredawg said:

bananasnblondes said:

RoadDawg55 said:

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

Sub K said Somerville is the #2 absolute must get recruit after JTT. That's really all I need to hear to know this guy is probably not that good.

This year's Jordan Banks

Went from a top 100 prospect to dropping all the way off the charts in the 247 rankings.

I am truly gutted reading this.

dirtysouwfdawg

GrundleStiltzkin said:

bananasnblondes said:

insinceredawg said:

bananasnblondes said:

RoadDawg55 said:

bananasnblondes said:

Another 5* sophomore in high school.

"Just imagine how big and fast he'll get by the time hes a senior.He'll be at least 6'3" 240. What? he didnt grow anymore? Well we cant change anything now. We've already established that he's an elite recruit.""

He doesn’t look very good compared to his ranking.

Sub K said Somerville is the #2 absolute must get recruit after JTT. That's really all I need to hear to know this guy is probably not that good.

This year's Jordan Banks

Went from a top 100 prospect to dropping all the way off the charts in the 247 rankings.

I am truly gutted reading this.

Shaking & vomiting?

RoadDawg55

RoadDawg55 said:

Watched the Hudl. Did not see a guy that looked like the #4 DE in the country, but maybe it’s a tools ranking and I’m missing something.

Shameless bump. He doesn’t look close to the #4 DE.

DugtheDoog

RoadDawg55 said:

RoadDawg55 said:

Watched the Hudl. Did not see a guy that looked like the #4 DE in the country, but maybe it’s a tools ranking and I’m missing something.

Shameless bump. He doesn’t look close to the #4 DE.

I def agree. And I'll really admit my TBS eval skills are fairly rudimentary. Comparing the fluidity of the hip swivel between two 16 year old boys is a daunting task for a simpleton like myself, and is best left to the elite evaluation skills of people like Ektard and F3.

Having said that, fluctuations in rankings... absolutely understandable even expected for things like new information coming to light, injuries, updated film, physical growth, impressing yogi Roth and Trent Dilfer in basketball shorts throwing routes vs air, etc. to lead to a shifting in the rankings where needed. But how in the flying fuck can you rank a kid fringe top 100 player and demote him at least 145 spots when very few if any high school players have participated in a game camp, practice, etc. in close to 6 months? And not a single player has done much more than play catch in their front yard in over 2 months, if they've done anything at all?

Again, I don't pretend to be half as smart as a guy like F3, but to a simpleton like me this either says (a) your evaluation from the previous 3 years is fucking terrible, (b) your new evaluation is fucking terrible or (c) besides the obvious blue chip talent that would jump off the page even to G'pa Sankey, there aren't enough resources, evalutors, tools, information sharing /recording/collating, parity of competition or precise physical maturity projections analysis to rank players, say150-550 with any degree of certainty and really all depends on whose educated(?) guesses you count as less fallible than others.

PS. Or (D) the field.

RoadDawg55

DugtheDoog said:

RoadDawg55 said:

RoadDawg55 said:

Watched the Hudl. Did not see a guy that looked like the #4 DE in the country, but maybe it’s a tools ranking and I’m missing something.

Shameless bump. He doesn’t look close to the #4 DE.

I def agree. And I'll really admit my TBS eval skills are fairly rudimentary. Comparing the fluidity of the hip swivel between two 16 year old boys is a daunting task for a simpleton like myself, and is best left to the elite evaluation skills of people like Ektard and F3.

Having said that, fluctuations in rankings... absolutely understandable even expected for things like new information coming to light, injuries, updated film, physical growth, impressing yogi Roth and Trent Dilfer in basketball shorts throwing routes vs air, etc. to lead to a shifting in the rankings where needed. But how in the flying fuck can you rank a kid fringe top 100 player and demote him at least 145 spots when very few if any high school players have participated in a game camp, practice, etc. in close to 6 months? And not a single player has done much more than play catch in their front yard in over 2 months, if they've done anything at all?

Again, I don't pretend to be half as smart as a guy like F3, but to a simpleton like me this either says (a) your evaluation from the previous 3 years is fucking terrible, (b) your new evaluation is fucking terrible or (c) besides the obvious blue chip talent that would jump off the page even to G'pa Sankey, there aren't enough resources, evalutors, tools, information sharing /recording/collating, parity of competition or precise physical maturity projections analysis to rank players, say150-550 with any degree of certainty and really all depends on whose educated(?) guesses you count as less fallible than others.

PS. Or (D) the field.

If they are ranked that high, they should jump out. This guy hardly even has highlights. Just looks like a guy that holds his own and makes a couple plays here and there.

Simon is another that will continue to fall until they final rankings.

The only tough part is judging guys compared to all the players in the US. I know what 4 and 5 star guys should look like tho. They should absolutely dominate. If they don’t, they are very likely overrated.

DugtheDoog

RoadDawg55 said:

DugtheDoog said:

RoadDawg55 said:

RoadDawg55 said:

Watched the Hudl. Did not see a guy that looked like the #4 DE in the country, but maybe it’s a tools ranking and I’m missing something.

Shameless bump. He doesn’t look close to the #4 DE.

I def agree. And I'll really admit my TBS eval skills are fairly rudimentary. Comparing the fluidity of the hip swivel between two 16 year old boys is a daunting task for a simpleton like myself, and is best left to the elite evaluation skills of people like Ektard and F3.

Having said that, fluctuations in rankings... absolutely understandable even expected for things like new information coming to light, injuries, updated film, physical growth, impressing yogi Roth and Trent Dilfer in basketball shorts throwing routes vs air, etc. to lead to a shifting in the rankings where needed. But how in the flying fuck can you rank a kid fringe top 100 player and demote him at least 145 spots when very few if any high school players have participated in a game camp, practice, etc. in close to 6 months? And not a single player has done much more than play catch in their front yard in over 2 months, if they've done anything at all?

Again, I don't pretend to be half as smart as a guy like F3, but to a simpleton like me this either says (a) your evaluation from the previous 3 years is fucking terrible, (b) your new evaluation is fucking terrible or (c) besides the obvious blue chip talent that would jump off the page even to G'pa Sankey, there aren't enough resources, evalutors, tools, information sharing /recording/collating, parity of competition or precise physical maturity projections analysis to rank players, say150-550 with any degree of certainty and really all depends on whose educated(?) guesses you count as less fallible than others.

PS. Or (D) the field.

If they are ranked that high, they should jump out. This guy hardly even has highlights. Just looks like a guy that holds his own and makes a couple plays here and there.

Simon is another that will continue to fall until they final rankings.

The only tough part is judging guys compared to all the players in the US. I know what 4 and 5 star guys should look like tho. They should absolutely dominate. If they don’t, they are very likely overrated.

Then I guess the question is why did they screw to so bad until today? Iirc, I think Simon dropped roughly 50 spots. That, I can buy.

FireCohen

RoadDawg55 said:

RoadDawg55 said:

Watched the Hudl. Did not see a guy that looked like the #4 DE in the country, but maybe it’s a tools ranking and I’m missing something.

Shameless bump. He doesn’t look close to the #4 DE.

Roadie is batting 1.000

Fear_Boner

FireCohen said:

RoadDawg55 said:

RoadDawg55 said:

Watched the Hudl. Did not see a guy that looked like the #4 DE in the country, but maybe it’s a tools ranking and I’m missing something.

Shameless bump. He doesn’t look close to the #4 DE.

Roadie is batting 1.000

Can’t hit .081 in this biz man.

insinceredawg

Donged to Michigan

FKA_Mousecop

We gonna 0-fer out of Arizona

GrundleStiltzkin

FKA_Mousecop said:

We gonna 0-fer out of Arizona

Thanks, Inslee

Neighbor2972

sonics1993 said:

Washington is in great shape with him and right now I would be surprised if he went elsewhere.

Too bad we didn't have room!

https://twitter.com/247recruiting/status/1339242063884378122

CallMeBigErn

Neighbor2972 said:

sonics1993 said:

Washington is in great shape with him and right now I would be surprised if he went elsewhere.

Too bad we didn't have room!

https://twitter.com/247recruiting/status/1339242063884378122

Isn't he a JAG?

Neighbor2972

CallMeBigErn said:

Neighbor2972 said:

sonics1993 said:

Washington is in great shape with him and right now I would be surprised if he went elsewhere.

Too bad we didn't have room!

https://twitter.com/247recruiting/status/1339242063884378122

Isn't he a JAG?

We could use some JAGS

thechatch

The year of the de-commitment

DoogerMcFarland

bananasnblondes

DoogerMcFarland said:

Apparently he and I have the same "biggest drawback"

thechatch

Ecklund is just the best

AtomicDawg

DoogerMcFarland said:

Ryan bowman may be 6ft. Maybe. But we look for a different kind of athlete. Just make shit up and post. Maybe we didn’t want him. But that’s not why.