Would you trade Petersen for Kyle Whittingham straight up?

DerekJohnson

Just answer the question

GrundleStiltzkin

ha, fuck no

Mad_Son

No

GrundleStiltzkin said:

ha, fuck no

Les Miles?

BleachedAnusDawg

No

Whittingham loses to Pete every year (at least until 2 weeks from now) and has an even worse offense.

PostGameOrangeSlices

No

Why would we trade Petersen for Whitt after what I thought was a well-played college football game? We did a nice job against a good football team.

PurpleJ

Janet Reno

It’s a wash. He does more with less, but we said that about Pete at one time.

DerekJohnson

Yes

PurpleJ said:

It’s a wash. He does more with less, but we said that about Pete at one time.

He gets his players to play hard consistently

oregonblitzkrieg

No

Nothing wrong with your offense this game, it showed up against one of the nation's toughest defenses. It's hard beating a scrappy team at home with it's backed into a corner in a must win game.

GrundleStiltzkin

Mad_Son said:

GrundleStiltzkin said:

ha, fuck no

Les Miles?

haven't followed him too close, but have a friend who's a huge LSU fan, they were ready to fire him the last 3 years.

Baseman

No

I'd thrown in Bob Gregory to make the deal

PurpleJ

Janet Reno

He’s never won the conference...

I’m not sold that he couldn’t with better talent, but I don’t think he would come here and win big bowl games either.

whatshouldicareabout

No

That made me laugh

gabemarksknee

No

JFC

BeerThirty

No

Pete recruits much better

DoogieMcDoogerson

No

We’ll see how this post ages. I don’t think it’s one of the nations toughest. Stats may say so but reality may be much different.

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Nothing wrong with your offense this game, it showed up against one of the nation's toughest defenses. It's hard beating a scrappy team at home with it's backed into a corner in a must win game.

Swaye

No

No reason to trade one guy who can't win a NC for another guy who can't.

RoadDawg55

No

Tough call but no. I do think Whittingham would do well at UW because it’s easier to recruit than Utah.

Whittingham has never figured out how to have an offense tho. He’s flawed too.

JustWinNow

Janet Reno

I chose Janey Reno. But you fags after Utah whips us will be change your answer to yes.

GrundleStiltzkin

RoadDawg55 said:

Tough call but no. I do think Whittingham would do well at UW because it’s easier to recruit than Utah.

Whittingham has never figured out how to have an offense tho. He’s flawed too.

Multiply the OKG outrages by 100, that's what the Wittingham experience would be here.

RaceBannon

No

I was going to say this is fucking stupid but Stalin started it so its a brilliant and thought provoking poll that shows why we are stuck with Petersen because even a doog legend like Witlessham is far worse than Pete

JaWarrenJaHooker

No

Whittingham SUCKS