Soul Train BOTBs Elite 8 (Mid 1990's to present) - #1 Beyonce vs #2 Mariah Carey

YellowSnow

GrundleStiltzkin

Opposite of abundance

Dennis_DeYoung

#1 Beyonce

Rather easily.

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

Only because of Destiny's Chile.

chuck

#2 Mariah Carey

Rather easily. Singing talent vs none. Looks vs this...

Joey

#2 Mariah Carey

Mariah has a voice. Beyonce is a hack.

chuck

#2 Mariah Carey

joeEDangerously said:

Mariah has a voice. Beyonce is a hack.

Beyonce isn't a horrible singer, used to be pretty,and used to be fun to watch. Then she turned into that photo I posted. Sad.

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

joeEDangerously said:

Mariah has a voice. Beyonce is a hack.

Mariah's voice is better but let's not act like Beyonce can't sing. She ain't Brittney Spears, she's a real talent.

Dennis_DeYoung

#1 Beyonce

HillsboroDuck said:

joeEDangerously said:

Mariah has a voice. Beyonce is a hack.

Mariah's voice is better but let's not act like Beyonce can't sing. She ain't Brittney Spears, she's a real talent.

Let's also not act like one fucking unflattering picture during the middle of gyration means she isn't hot... she's a fucking smoke show and every loser here would beat their own mother with an aluminum bat to have a go.

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

Dennis_DeYoung said:

HillsboroDuck said:

joeEDangerously said:

Mariah has a voice. Beyonce is a hack.

Mariah's voice is better but let's not act like Beyonce can't sing. She ain't Brittney Spears, she's a real talent.

Let's also not act like one fucking unflattering picture during the middle of gyration means she isn't hot... she's a fucking smoke show and every loser here would beat their own mother with an aluminum bat to have a go.

Yeah that too

PurpleJ

This is what happens when you let white people do a soul train tournament.

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

PurpleJ said:

This is what happens when you let white people do a soul train tournament.

Who would you have chosen Mr. TacTownTuff?

PurpleJ

HillsboroDuck said:

PurpleJ said:

This is what happens when you let white people do a soul train tournament.

Who would you have chosen Mr. TacTownTuff?

Rod Stewart

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

PurpleJ said:

HillsboroDuck said:

PurpleJ said:

This is what happens when you let white people do a soul train tournament.

Who would you have chosen Mr. TacTownTuff?

Rod Stewart

Like I thought. Easy to criticize when you're too pussy to put your own evaluations out there.

TacTownTuff weeps.

chuck

#2 Mariah Carey

Dennis_DeYoung said:

HillsboroDuck said:

joeEDangerously said:

Mariah has a voice. Beyonce is a hack.

Mariah's voice is better but let's not act like Beyonce can't sing. She ain't Brittney Spears, she's a real talent.

Let's also not act like one fucking unflattering picture during the middle of gyration means she isn't hot... she's a fucking smoke show and every loser here would beat their own mother with an aluminum bat to have a go.

I prefer to act like, thank you very much.

That photo is representative of her whole act that day. It all looked that shitty. I know it's not always the case.

Dennis_DeYoung

#1 Beyonce

She's into high fashion now and a lot of the point of that is to look weird... but... let's live inside reality.

PurpleJ

HillsboroDuck said:

PurpleJ said:

HillsboroDuck said:

PurpleJ said:

This is what happens when you let white people do a soul train tournament.

Who would you have chosen Mr. TacTownTuff?

Rod Stewart

Like I thought. Easy to criticize when you're too pussy to put your own evaluations out there.

TacTownTuff weeps.

Fine! I choose Bone Thugs N Harmony or Nate Dogg.

Also, where the fuck was Usher in this festival of dreck?

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

PurpleJ said:

HillsboroDuck said:

PurpleJ said:

HillsboroDuck said:

PurpleJ said:

This is what happens when you let white people do a soul train tournament.

Who would you have chosen Mr. TacTownTuff?

Rod Stewart

Like I thought. Easy to criticize when you're too pussy to put your own evaluations out there.

TacTownTuff weeps.

Fine! I choose Bone Thugs N Harmony or Nate Dogg.

Also, where the fuck was Usher in this festival of dreck?

Troof be told he was in my original top 8 for the mid90s on and somehow got ommitted. Total eff up on my part. I don't think he would have won his first round matchup but he should have made the tourney.

Bone (for sure) and Nate (I think) were both in the rap bracket IIRC. I know Nate was at least considered for the rap bracket but I can't remember if he made the final cut. Agree he could fit in here.

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

Here's my initial list for the mid90s to present. Bold were people I thought needed to make the top 8. Somehow I had 9 of them and I guess I scrolled down and missed Ursher. Sad!

PurpleJ

Saw Ginuwine and now I'm gonna have Pony stuck in my head all day.

HillsboroDuck

#1 Beyonce

PurpleJ said:

Saw Ginuwine and now I'm gonna have Pony stuck in my head all day.

Yep yep yep