Round 1 (60's Groups) - #2 Rolling Stones vs #15 Crosby, Stills and Nash (and Young?)

YellowSnow

Greatest Rock and Roll Band in the World vs CSN(Y)

GrandpaSankey

# 2 The Rolling Stones

Swaye

# 2 The Rolling Stones

This will be a fucking blowout.

Joey

#15 Crosby, Stills, and Nash

Either I never got into the Stones or I heard every song way too many times by the age of 5 and it was over

YellowSnow

# 2 The Rolling Stones

joeEDangerously said:

Either I never got into the Stones or I heard every song way too many times by the age of 5 and it was over

There are more Rolling Stones songs than what is on Hot Rocks.

89ute

# 2 The Rolling Stones

YellowSnow said:

joeEDangerously said:

Either I never got into the Stones or I heard every song way too many times by the age of 5 and it was over

There are more Rolling Stones songs than what is on Hot Rocks.

or Hot Rocks II

oregonblitzkrieg

#15 Crosby, Stills, and Nash

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Southerndawg

# 2 The Rolling Stones

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

YellowSnow

# 2 The Rolling Stones

Southerndawg said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Oh schnapp!

dflea

# 2 The Rolling Stones

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Holy fuck.

dnc

# 2 The Rolling Stones

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

YellowSnow

# 2 The Rolling Stones

dnc said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

I'm hearing you can get the entire Stone's catalog on CD from Amazon at reasonable prices.

oregonblitzkrieg

#15 Crosby, Stills, and Nash

dflea said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Holy fuck.

Most overrated rock n roll band of all tim.

Southerndawg

# 2 The Rolling Stones

oregonblitzkrieg said:

dflea said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Holy fuck.

Most overrated rock n roll band of all tim.

dflea

# 2 The Rolling Stones

oregonblitzkrieg said:

dflea said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Holy fuck.

Most overrated rock n roll band of all tim.

Sure, faggot.

UW_Doog_Bot

# 2 The Rolling Stones

oregonblitzkrieg said:

dflea said:

oregonblitzkrieg said:

Rolling Stones = 60's buttrock IMO. Like the 60's version of Warrant or some other shit band but one that made it bigger due to the charisma of the band members and the tabloid circus of their private lives. Never heard a song from them that really caught on with me. So it's Crosby by default.

Holy fuck.

Most overrated rock n roll band of all tim.

Early stones >>>>>>> Whatever modern bullshit they've debuted.

PurpleThrobber

# 2 The Rolling Stones

Stones are Kobe, Wilt, Kareem status.

CSN&Y is Doug Christie.

Dennis_DeYoung

# 2 The Rolling Stones

There are two Rolling Stoneses on some level: the Mick Stones which is just “let’s do what everyone else is doing” and the Keith Stones which produced all their classic work.

If you just take the Keith Stones, they are as good as anyone... the Mick Stones are basically Stone Temple Pilots.

YellowSnow

# 2 The Rolling Stones

Dennis_DeYoung said:

There are two Rolling Stoneses on some level: the Mick Stones which is just “let’s do what everyone else is doing” and the Keith Stones which produced all their classic work.

If you just take the Keith Stones, they are as good as anyone... the Mick Stones are basically Stone Temple Pilots.

Some oversimplification here, but the poont becomes mor valid post Exile. Mick is the OG bad boy front man in Rock and everyone that came thereafter owes him a debt.

Dennis_DeYoung

# 2 The Rolling Stones

YellowSnow said:

Dennis_DeYoung said:

There are two Rolling Stoneses on some level: the Mick Stones which is just “let’s do what everyone else is doing” and the Keith Stones which produced all their classic work.

If you just take the Keith Stones, they are as good as anyone... the Mick Stones are basically Stone Temple Pilots.

Some oversimplification here, but the poont becomes mor valid post Exile. Mick is the OG bad boy front man in Rock and everyone that came thereafter owes him a debt.

I’m talking about songwriting. Mick’s direction always led to Ruby Tuesday, Satanic Majesty’s and Shattered.

Keith’s songwriting produced Street Fighting Man, Gimmie Shelter, etc.

Mick is a truly great frontman.

YellowSnow

# 2 The Rolling Stones

Dennis_DeYoung said:

YellowSnow said:

Dennis_DeYoung said:

There are two Rolling Stoneses on some level: the Mick Stones which is just “let’s do what everyone else is doing” and the Keith Stones which produced all their classic work.

If you just take the Keith Stones, they are as good as anyone... the Mick Stones are basically Stone Temple Pilots.

Some oversimplification here, but the poont becomes mor valid post Exile. Mick is the OG bad boy front man in Rock and everyone that came thereafter owes him a debt.

I’m talking about songwriting. Mick’s direction always led to Ruby Tuesday, Satanic Majesty’s and Shattered.

Keith’s songwriting produced Street Fighting Man, Gimmie Shelter, etc.

Mick is a truly great frontman.

You know what fucking crazy though about Mick following the trendy bands in 1966- 67, is that "Ruby Tuesday / Let's Spend The Night Together" might have been better than anything the Beatles did on Pepper or Magical Mystery Tour. It's one of the greatest double A sides ever. And Between the Buttons and Stanic's Majesties are loaded with great Stones "deep" tracks that many here have never fucking heard. 2000 man is fucking amazing.