Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Options
7 Huskies to combine
Mad_Son
Member Posts: 10,120
Baker
Jones
King
Qualls
Daniels
Mathis
Ross
To think we were light on upper classmen...
Jones
King
Qualls
Daniels
Mathis
Ross
To think we were light on upper classmen...
Comments
Don't twist that to me saying this class ain't better than in years past. It is, but the ratings are higher all around.
What I don't dispute from what you said is that there's clearly a better evaluation process for players today than 10 years ago whether it be from the camps, more "scouts" in the field, Hudl film, etc. 10 years ago a guy like Mason Foster was an unknown because he was outside of a traditional area and because of that he was viewed as a 2 star not because that was his ceiling but because a 2 star basically was indicative that nobody evaluated him.
Where I find your comment lacking is that it would have taken you no more than 5-10 minutes of research to go through historical rankings from Scout by an average star rating to figure out how much inflation there is in today's star rankings versus in years prior. I took the top 25 classes by star average to find what the average star ranking was for those classes (using average star to make sure that I'm picking up quality versus quantity):
2009: 3.43
2013: 3.53
2017: 3.61
So, from 2009 to 2017, there's about a 5% "inflation" if you will in the average star rating for the average player in a Top 25 quality class. From 2013 to 2017, it's a little more than a 2% gap in inflation.
The conclusion to me is that going back in Sark's tenure, you could make an argument that the "inflation" was systematic because not all recruits were getting evaluated. By 2013 though, 2% inflation to me can't be viewed as systematic and instead can be tied to the growing gap in college football between the have's and the have not's.
2009: Sark's class sucked because he stayed to coach in the Rose Bowl and didn't put much effort into putting too much of a class together until early January ... the class flamed out as a result not only in quality at the time but in quantity down the road as attrition was massive.
2010-2011: Sark built off the 2009 +5 in win total to show that the program was on the upswing and then a fairly strong finish in 2010 ending in the Holiday Bowl win over Nebraska to show that the program was moving in the right direction. The classes picked up as a result.
2012: After a strong start, the season basically fell apart and then exposed with a defensive no show in the Alamo Bowl ending with the balance of the Defensive Staff being fired. Class saved at the end by pulling in Shaq Thompson after hiring Tosh away from Cal.
2013: This is the class that Softy was calling a monster ... and clearly the impact of Tosh was felt throughout the process. Looking at the names on the list that were major factors in the 2016 season are obvious: Victor, Bierria, King, Coleman, Shelton, Mathis, Ross, Qualls, and Daniels. But the misses are also staggering as the players that either never made it in, flamed out, or transferred include: Troy Williams, Patrick Enewally, Jermaine Kelly, Marcus Farria, Stringfellow, Dane Crane, and Jamie Bryant.
2014: Pete's transition class was 16% better than Sark's transition class ... and when you go back and look at the talent in the class, it's clear that the talent in Pete's class was undervalued (Budda, McGary, Jaylen Johnson, Gaines, Sidney Jones - 84th ranked CB, Pettis - 87th ranked WR)
2015: A small uptick in Pete's 1st full class but you can definitely see a bit of a delay in getting things going as the on-field results and recruiting connections (challenges w/ existing coaches) were magnified
2016: Another small uptick mixed with a couple of big wins late in the process (Murphy and Levi) ...
2017: Monster class punctuated with change in WR coaching --> massive haul there ... still a few areas to take a look at for improvement but very clear that our recruiting philosophy has shifted with guys we targeted in the 2017 class and how the 2018 class is starting ... this is an ELITE level for UW recruiting historically
Anyone have a link to a listing by school how many players being invited to this year's combine?
I'm assuming Alabama has 253 ....
2. Alabama, LSU: 10 each
3. Clemson, Miami, Texas A&M: 9 each
4. Florida, Florida State, Ohio State, USC, Utah: 8 each
5. Louisville, North Carolina, Washington: 7 each
6. Pittsburgh, Tennessee, Virginia Tech, Wisconsin: 6 each
Link