JCCPCCIR

chuck

How can you ask us to rate such shitty players? One 4*? This survey sucks.

Need half points. Dexter Charles got a 3 because he seemed to play for a long time however mediocre and overrated he might have been. Corey Littleton got the same rating, as I couldn't justify a 4 for him. He's way better than Charles though so fuck.

Should've just given Charles 2*. My bad but I'm not editing.

CokeGreaterThanPepsi

I'm hearing Sark was a great recruiter, everyone says so!

CokeGreaterThanPepsi

This is two years in a row when the survey has been very depressing. Hopefully that improves over the coming seasons. We still got one more full year of likely Sark survey results to go through and then we'll start seeing Petersen results.

TommySQC

chuck said:

How can you ask us to rate such shitty players? One 4*? This survey sucks.

Need half points. Dexter Charles got a 3 because he seemed to play for a long time however mediocre and overrated he might have been. Corey Littleton got the same rating, as I couldn't justify a 4 for him. He's way better than Charles though so fuck.

Should've just given Charles 2*. My bad but I'm not editing.

I gave Cyler a 5

GrundleStiltzkin

CokeGreaterThanPepsi said:

This is two years in a row when the survey has been very depressing. Hopefully that improves over the coming seasons. We still got one more full year of likely Sark survey results to go through and then we'll start seeing Petersen results.

HuskyJW

I might have been a bit too generous this year especially with Tupou....

Ah well.

Sarkingham

This was tough. My criteria was as follows:

1 - Never contributed anything of note or flamed out before contributing
2 - Role player, special teams contributor
3 - Regular starter (for at least 1 season)
4 - All conference type player
5 - 1st team all conference and/or AA mentions

I had the hardest time with Charles (got a 3 mostly because he had to retire or may have ended at a 4), Littleton (3), Perkins (3), and Tupou (3). I had one 4 (Feeney), four 1's (Fuavai, Black Power, Jermaine Kelly, and Naijiel Hale), and four 2's (Miles, Finau, Lawyer, and Hall). Sadly, I had to give Mickens a 3.

Alexis

Christ, I'm not happy with any of my grades. I am way too easy on these guys.

Fucking doog.

There should be an option where you can give a guy a 4 because he was a multiyear starter and is on some of the all time UW numbers lists, but also kick him in the nuts just because he sucks.

FremontTroll

Alexis said:

Christ, I'm not happy with any of my grades. I am way too easy on these guys.

Fucking doog.

There should be an option where you can give a guy a 4 because he was a multiyear starter and is on some of the all time UW numbers lists, but also kick him in the nuts just because he sucks.

I sure hope you're not talking about Jaydon.

TommySQC

FremontTroll said:

Alexis said:

Christ, I'm not happy with any of my grades. I am way too easy on these guys.

Fucking doog.

There should be an option where you can give a guy a 4 because he was a multiyear starter and is on some of the all time UW numbers lists, but also kick him in the nuts just because he sucks.

I sure hope you're not talking about Jaydon.

who else would be be talking about?

BlowItUp

that was a terribly depressing activity.

haie

The real question is what the fuck is Cyler? He is a 2 by definition but played like a 1. We would have won more games direct-snapping to Washington on run plays and Hall on pass plays.

I had to give him a 2, and Troy Williams a 2 knowing that only a fucking retard would start Cyler over Williams.

haie

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

FremontTroll

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

haie

FremontTroll said:

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.

Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.

Hippopeteamus

haie said:

FremontTroll said:

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.

Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.

Aren't these ratings based on what players did, not on whether the coaches are idiots and the player might have been good if he had actually played?

haie

Hippopeteamus said:

haie said:

FremontTroll said:

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.

Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.

Aren't these ratings based on what players did, not on whether the coaches are idiots and the player might have been good if he had actually played?

I'll take Troy's time against Oregon and start against ASU over Cyler's career (except the Oregon State Game of course )

HTH

RaceBannon

Black Power forever

Hippopeteamus

haie said:

Hippopeteamus said:

haie said:

FremontTroll said:

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.

Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.

Aren't these ratings based on what players did, not on whether the coaches are idiots and the player might have been good if he had actually played?

I'll take Troy's time against Oregon and start against ASU over Cyler's career (except the Oregon State Game of course )

HTH

That made him a role player? I think special teams only players contributed more to the team than Troy. Again, this is not saying he isn't better than Cyler, so don't twist, I'm just not sure how you could rate his career at UW as being anything other than a 1.
P.S. Of course, I didn't fill out this survey, so, who am I to say who is worth what.

haie

Hippopeteamus said:

haie said:

Hippopeteamus said:

haie said:

FremontTroll said:

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.

Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.

Aren't these ratings based on what players did, not on whether the coaches are idiots and the player might have been good if he had actually played?

I'll take Troy's time against Oregon and start against ASU over Cyler's career (except the Oregon State Game of course )

HTH

That made him a role player? I think special teams only players contributed more to the team than Troy. Again, this is not saying he isn't better than Cyler, so don't twist, I'm just not sure how you could rate his career at UW as being anything other than a 1.

He was a role player in that his role was showing us how fucktarded it was to start Cyler every fucking game. It was a pretty pivotal role, imo.

Alexis

FremontTroll said:

haie said:

Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?

Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.

If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.

We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.

The shitty part about Jaydon, Timu, Ossai, Nigel Burton, etc, is that they were multi year starters. Sure they sucked,and we're easily replaced, but for their time, they were the best at their position. Shitty as it is, you have to say Jaydon was the best receiver numbers wise the last few years (caught more than he dropped).

You know he sucked, I know he sucked, but shit, the guy was a recruit that gave you multiple years of starts. Not an A definitely, but shit, C+/B- is 80%, 4 out of 5. Need more choices.