Felix Screwed

Tequilla

Enough said about that ...

dhdawg

Félix won in ERA, WHIP, and BB/9
Kluber won in FIP, WAR, K/9 and also pitched in a more hitter friendly park with a shitty defense behind him. Hard to go wrong either way

TierbsHsotBoobs

Moogs gonna Moog

WilburHooksHands

Coin flip. I've been trying to talk Mooriners off the ledge for the last half hour.

RaceBannon

Was listening to Kershaw being interviewed on the drive home. All I could think was how he got lit up by the cards.

Win.

greenblood

What did Felix expect playing for the Mariners? That's what I thought, until I see he lost to a Cleveland Indian. I guess they picked the player that plays for the taller midget.

RoadDawg55

IDGAF, but it does seem like Felix deserved the award.

Doogles

Felix wanted this award. His comments about it are borderline sour grapes, but i'm going to chalk it up to him being a big time competitor who wants to go down as one of the greats. It's got to be frustrating having a historical season and then not even being the awarded the best pitcher in your half of the league.

WilburHooksHands

Voters pay attention to September. Kluber finished the season with 14, 14, and 11 K games. Felix got lit up in Toronto when his team's season was in the balance.

dhdawg

WilburHooksHands said:

Voters pay attention to September. Kluber finished the season with 14, 14, and 11 K games. Felix got lit up in Toronto when his team's season was in the balance.

I'm not bashing the decision to pick kluber, but come on, both pitchers had a bad start in September, kluber's just came earlier in September.
Besides, it's about the total body of work

WilburHooksHands

but still...

bigcc

it's that WAR number I'm guessing that got him.... the "pitchers park" factors into the equation as well as being on top of writers heads (even though he gave up more HR's at safeco than on the road 10-6), as does our "superior defense"....

I remember one writer who voted talking about how much of a difference Zunino was for felix over Gomes for Kluber.....