Not taking the ball at the 35, and having stanford re-kick. Brilliant.

Passion

.

EwaDawg

Well, Jonathan Peterman has no trust/confidence in Miley Cyrus and his O Line.

jecornel

Scrimmages don't mean anything season started today...rekick and fake punt worst calls ever

GrundleStiltzkin

Rekick I didn't like, at all, but I get it. O sucks. Fake punt was ridiculous.

jecornel

Miles and staff totally lost their minds... smith drinking Appletinis in the zone at half....your punting and defense been solid and you try to run for it? Bizarre

jecornel

Miles was in total shambles

allpurpleallgold

I didn't hate the re kick. If Ross takes it the house we're all calling it the greatest decision of all time. I think you take the field position regardless but it's defensible.

TierbsHsotBoobs

allpurpleallgold said:

I didn't hate the re kick. If Ross takes it the house we're all calling it the greatest decision of all time. I think you take the field position regardless but it's defensible.

When you've already fucked the game up twice by giving away field position, why not go for the hat trick.

jecornel

The odds of a second return for TD...almost nill

section8

allpurpleallgold said:

I didn't hate the re kick. If Ross takes it the house we're all calling it the greatest decision of all time. I think you take the field position regardless but it's defensible.

This. Nothing else was working. Put the ball in the hands of the best player on the field.

Oh and Jonathan Smith can DIAF slowly while choking on a bag of dicks.

dnc

jecornel said:

The odds of a second return for TD...almost nill

So roughly equivalent to the odds of a sustained 65 yard drive.

Let's put it this way, how many times had we returned kicks for TD's in that game, and how many times had our offense went down the field and scored TD's? The answer to each is one, but the percentage of kick returns TD's was higher.

It was a desperation call, the kind of call you make when you have no faith whatsoever in your offense.

allpurpleallgold

jecornel said:

The odds of a second return for TD...almost nill

The odds of a second return are the same as the odds for the first return. HTH.

beelzebub

Sark wouldnt have screwed those 2 calls up, anyone still think Petersen is world's best coach?!

RaceBannon

beelzebub said:

Sark wouldnt have screwed those 2 calls up, anyone still think Petersen is world's best coach?!

"lol"

You're cute

AEB

beelzebub said:

Sark wouldnt have screwed those 2 calls up, anyone still think Petersen is world's best coach?!

Gimme a break. Peterson had no trust in his QB and our WRs blow. I would've taken it at the 35 and I would've punted, but we clearly had no chance to sustain a drive. Sark would bubble screen to death. Finally, for those who believe Sark left the cupboards full, DIAFF. Game was brutal.

HeretoBeatmyChest

There really shouldn't be any debate about this. They have to kick it to your best player and biggest threat. Meanwhile, your offense has only scored 1 TD all game. And you gain an extra 5 yards. The odds are very low that you don't return it to close to the 30. Just happened to have a shit return. Big fucking deal. That loss of 19 yards had very little impact on the game. Still had a chance to tie the game with the ball on Stanfords 30, 1st down with a min left.

I didn't agree with the 4th down call but these are the risks you take to beat a better team because the percentages (and risk/reward of the situation) warrant taking these risks. Now if the game were tied, then you'd take the field position. Down 7 with offense not doing anything, you give Ross another crack.

EwaDawg

It was a desperation call, the kind of call you make when you have no faith whatsoever in your offense.


Why the fuck didn't I think of that?


Or why did idiots not realize it was true?

allpurpleallgold

HeretoBeatmyChest said:

There really shouldn't be any debate about this. They have to kick it to your best player and biggest threat. Meanwhile, your offense has only scored 1 TD all game. And you gain an extra 5 yards. The odds are very low that you don't return it to close to the 30. Just happened to have a shit return. Big fucking deal. That loss of 19 yards had very little impact on the game. Still had a chance to tie the game with the ball on Stanfords 30, 1st down with a min left.

I didn't agree with the 4th down call but these are the risks you take to beat a better team because the percentages (and risk/reward of the situation) warrant taking these risks. Now if the game were tied, then you'd take the field position. Down 7 with offense not doing anything, you give Ross another crack.

There is one giant flaw with your point. You want to make them kick it to your best player...but you make no effort to get him the ball yourself all game? If that's the logic, if Ross is worth the risk, then why not get him the ball more?

TierbsHsotBoobs

HeretoBeatmyChest said:

There really shouldn't be any debate about this. They have to kick it to your best player and biggest threat. Meanwhile, your offense has only scored 1 TD all game. And you gain an extra 5 yards. The odds are very low that you don't return it to close to the 30. Just happened to have a shit return. Big fucking deal. That loss of 19 yards had very little impact on the game. Still had a chance to tie the game with the ball on Stanfords 30, 1st down with a min left.

I didn't agree with the 4th down call but these are the risks you take to beat a better team because the percentages (and risk/reward of the situation) warrant taking these risks. Now if the game were tied, then you'd take the field position. Down 7 with offense not doing anything, you give Ross another crack.

It's a lot easier to score from the 11 than the 30.

RaceBannon

allpurpleallgold said:

HeretoBeatmyChest said:

There really shouldn't be any debate about this. They have to kick it to your best player and biggest threat. Meanwhile, your offense has only scored 1 TD all game. And you gain an extra 5 yards. The odds are very low that you don't return it to close to the 30. Just happened to have a shit return. Big fucking deal. That loss of 19 yards had very little impact on the game. Still had a chance to tie the game with the ball on Stanfords 30, 1st down with a min left.

I didn't agree with the 4th down call but these are the risks you take to beat a better team because the percentages (and risk/reward of the situation) warrant taking these risks. Now if the game were tied, then you'd take the field position. Down 7 with offense not doing anything, you give Ross another crack.

There is one giant flaw with your point. You want to make them kick it to your best player...but you make no effort to get him the ball yourself all game? If that's the logic, if Ross is worth the risk, then why not get him the ball more?

Semi related, Williams wanted to beat Miley like a 12 by the end of the game. Cyrus could lose the team if he can't get the ball out to the playmakers

HeretoBeatmyChest

Not the same drive bungsniffer.

Your point (@apag) is a separate issue from the rekick question. I'm sure they tried to get him the ball but Miles being a limp wrist and Stanford's D made it very difficult.