Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
10 Greatest Movies of All Time According to Roger Ebert
DerekJohnson
Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,543 
Comments
-
-
About what I expected
Meh -
Shit list. Shit reviewer.
-
Probably not a big deal now but in the shared culture era there was always a disconnect between the critic and consumer. The more popular a band or movie the more the critics turned up their noseYellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
That band is too commercial - meaning they sold millions of albums and made millions of dollars
I'd want to be in that band. I'll take the shitty review -
It's oft been said that the Beatles were perhaps the only artist(s) in any medium who were simultaneously the most popular and the best (in the eyes of the critics).RaceBannon said:
Probably not a big deal now but in the shared culture era there was always a disconnect between the critic and consumer. The more popular a band or movie the more the critics turned up their noseYellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
That band is too commercial - meaning they sold millions of albums and made millions of dollars
I'd want to be in that band. I'll take the shitty review
Godfather = The Beatles. -
It always helps to be firstYellowSnow said:
It's oft been said that the Beatles were perhaps the only artist(s) in any medium who were simultaneously the most popular and the best (in the eyes of the critics).RaceBannon said:
Probably not a big deal now but in the shared culture era there was always a disconnect between the critic and consumer. The more popular a band or movie the more the critics turned up their noseYellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
That band is too commercial - meaning they sold millions of albums and made millions of dollars
I'd want to be in that band. I'll take the shitty review
Godfather = The Beatles. -
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
Suck his dick some more will you?BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
He also didn't have the Professional. You should be hella pissed.BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
Never seen it but I love me some Natalie Portman. 👸🏼YellowSnow said:
He also didn't have the Professional. You should be hella pissed.BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
Low tweak. Looks like I struck a nerve.RaceBannon said:
Suck his dick some more will you?BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
That's the joke!BennyBeaver said:
Never seen it but I love me some underage Natalie Portman. 👸🏼YellowSnow said:
He also didn't have the Professional. You should be hella pissed.BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
No you're just entirely predictableBennyBeaver said:
Low tweak. Looks like I struck a nerve.RaceBannon said:
Suck his dick some more will you?BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month. -
Because I remember stupid, random things from decades ago, I thought I knew his top five from memory. I saw him and the other guy do rundowns of their top 5 or ten at some point. I could swear that they both had The Right Stuff on their lists. I thought that was #1 but maybe not. I do know for sure that Raging Bull, Casablanca, and Citizen were on it.
Whatever. My favorites change minute to minute and few of them make any lists.YellowSnow said:
That's the joke!BennyBeaver said:
Never seen it but I love me some underage Natalie Portman. 👸🏼YellowSnow said:
He also didn't have the Professional. You should be hella pissed.BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month.
-
4:24.RaceBannon said:
No you're just entirely predictableBennyBeaver said:
Low tweak. Looks like I struck a nerve.RaceBannon said:
Suck his dick some more will you?BennyBeaver said:
People like different things. Big deal. It’s his OPINION. And he made a good career of writing his OPINIONS about film before his face melted and he died.YellowSnow said:Shit list. Shit reviewer.
And he loved many commercially successful movies too.
Imagine if you averaged seeing 300 movies a year. You *might* have a different top 10 than the average joe that sees one or two a month.
Checks out. -
-
Thanks Taft!
-
The Pale Blue Eye is very good. Bale is excellent.
