Round 1 - #2 Fleetwood Mac vs #15 Rush

YellowSnow

Swaye

#15 Rush

Close one

BleachedAnusDawg

I can't vote on this one. Both feature exceedingly bad singers (billy goat vs nasally Canadian).

YellowSnow

#2 Fleetwood Mac

I don't care if it's cliché, I fucking love Rumors!! Plus Stevie Nicks is the GOAT baton gurl.

Southerndawg

#15 Rush

Another crazy matchup. Both good within their genres, but c'mon man, Rush and Fleetwood Mac have nothing in common.

YellowSnow

#2 Fleetwood Mac

Southerndawg said:

Another crazy matchup. Both good within their genres, but c'mon man, Rush and Fleetwood Mac have nothing in common.

True but I chose to create the 4 different regions based on eras vs genres. Yes, it creates some random matchups, but I like this because it forces people to make some hard calls if they like both artists a lot.

Southerndawg

#15 Rush

YellowSnow said:

Southerndawg said:

Another crazy matchup. Both good within their genres, but c'mon man, Rush and Fleetwood Mac have nothing in common.

True but I chose to create the 4 different regions based on eras vs genres. Yes, it creates some random matchups, but I like this because it forces people to make some hard calls if they like both artists a lot.

Fair enough.

Neil Peart (arguably GOAT) >> Mick Fleetwood

Stevie Nicks > Geddy Lee, but in fairness, neither band would be as good as they are/were with different lead singers

Alex Lifeson > all Fleetwood Mac guitarists

Rush's (Neil Peart's) Ayn Rand inspired lyrics >> Fleetwood Mac pop lyrics

Rush > Fleetwood Mac

But I like them both.

YellowSnow

#2 Fleetwood Mac

Southerndawg said:

YellowSnow said:

Southerndawg said:

Another crazy matchup. Both good within their genres, but c'mon man, Rush and Fleetwood Mac have nothing in common.

True but I chose to create the 4 different regions based on eras vs genres. Yes, it creates some random matchups, but I like this because it forces people to make some hard calls if they like both artists a lot.

Fair enough.

Neil Peart (arguably GOAT) >> Mick Fleetwood

Stevie Nicks > Geddy Lee, but in fairness, neither band would be as good as they are/were with different lead singers

Alex Lifeson > all Fleetwood Mac guitarists

Rush's (Neil Peart's) Ayn Rand inspired lyrics >> Fleetwood Mac pop lyrics

Rush > Fleetwood Mac

But I like them both.

And that's the point. Instead of Beatles or Stones, why not Fleetwood Mac vs Rush or AC DC vs Styx? How many times in your life has someone asked you those type of questions? Only at Hardcore Husky presented by @DerekJohnson can you get this level of content.

Swaye

#15 Rush

I am a HUGE Stevie Nicks homer but still had to go with Rush.

GrundleStiltzkin

#2 Fleetwood Mac

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3s9vt2

Swaye

#15 Rush

GrundleStiltzkin said:

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3s9vt2

To be fair, I didn't say I was a huge Lucy Lawless fan. But I am.

JoeEDangerously

#15 Rush

In guessing the underappreciated Peter Green era is not included

YellowSnow

#2 Fleetwood Mac

joeEDangerously said:

In guessing the underappreciated Peter Green era is not included

It's up to you to decide. I didn't put a qualifier on which version of Fleetwood Mac.

Kaepsknee

#2 Fleetwood Mac

Bad Matchup. Instead of seedings. You should have matched genre's. I hate to vote Rush to get eliminated in the 1st rd but there's no way Fleetwood Mac can go down in the 1st.

Dennis_DeYoung

#2 Fleetwood Mac

This one is straight up: 'are you autistic or can you talk to females for more than 3 minutes at a time?'

This is also the best that white women have to offer:

Dennis_DeYoung

#2 Fleetwood Mac

I once was in a conversation with a relatively famous crack smoking music producer and he said to 18 year old me, "did you know that Neal Peart once read a book on nuclear strategy to write the lyrics to a song?"

18 year old me was like "whoa cool"

Then he said, "Yeah, real fucking cool - if you are trying to sing to a bunch of fucking physicists. I don't know what that is, but that's not rock-n-roll."

Tequilla

#15 Rush

I never turn a Fleetwood Mac song off ... but I never go searching it out

I can mostly say the same for Rush ...

But what it comes down to for me is that if I’m forced to choose between Tom Sawyer and any Fleetwood Mac song I’m choosing Tom Sawyer

DerekJohnson

#15 Rush

Fleetwood Mac is good background music. Rush demands your focus and attention.

BlastDoor

#15 Rush

Who fucking need females when 2112 gets your cock harder?

Dennis_DeYoung

#2 Fleetwood Mac

BlastDoor said:

Who fucking need females when 2112 gets your cock harder?

This should be a required sticker on every Rush record.

WilburHooksHands

If you thought Fleeteood Mac would be a favorite over Rush on an internet message board, I cant help you.