Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Maybe J. Smith isn't a complete retard

24

Comments

  • AEB
    AEB Member Posts: 3,023
  • HuskyInAZ
    HuskyInAZ Member Posts: 1,733
    TTJ said:

    The persistent hard-on for "big plays" is the root cause of Smith's mediocrity. Run with conviction; throw short; avoid penalties; and concentrate on manufacturing and converting favorable down&distance situations. These are the things your players are good at, so just stick to them, and the "big plays" will come. Trust your playmakers to go get YAC on the edges; they don't need 40-yard downfield heaves.

    I don't get the "Smith's mediocrity" thing. I agree that he gets too cute at times and shit the bed in the 2nd half against USC, but UW offense is #3 in PPG in college football, and a whopping .5 PPG from #1. No doubt, some play calls are head scratching, but the body of work suggests he's certainly not mediocre.
  • AIRWOLF
    AIRWOLF Member Posts: 1,840
    edited December 2016
    TTJ said:

    The persistent hard-on for "big plays" is the root cause of Smith's mediocrity. Run with conviction; throw short; avoid penalties; and concentrate on manufacturing and converting favorable down&distance situations. These are the things your players are good at, so just stick to them, and the "big plays" will come. Trust your playmakers to go get YAC on the edges; they don't need 40-yard downfield heaves.

    Jesus. Big plays are good things. And the Huskies have been successful this season in both being incredibly efficient and explosive.

    I don't think Smith is a very good playe caller overall, and I will celebrate when he is hired away, but this criticism reads like the Huskies go 3 and out all the time because they are constantly throwing deep. They don't and they aren't.

    If Smith called games the way you are suggesting, there would be a huge uproar because the Huskies offense would score a lot less and would be both boring and predictable.

    The USC game was a poor gameplan, executed poorly. But the rest of the season, I can't fault the mix of calls that much.
  • RoadDawg55
    RoadDawg55 Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 30,551 Swaye's Wigwam
    AIRWOLF said:

    TTJ said:

    The persistent hard-on for "big plays" is the root cause of Smith's mediocrity. Run with conviction; throw short; avoid penalties; and concentrate on manufacturing and converting favorable down&distance situations. These are the things your players are good at, so just stick to them, and the "big plays" will come. Trust your playmakers to go get YAC on the edges; they don't need 40-yard downfield heaves.

    Jesus. Big plays are good things. And the Huskies have been successful this season in both being incredibly efficient and explosive.

    I don't think Smith is a very good playe caller overall, and I will celebrate when he is hired away, but this criticism reads like the Huskies go 3 and out all the time because they are constantly throwing deep. They don't and they aren't.

    If Smith called games the way you are suggesting, there would be a huge uproar because the Huskies offense would score a lot less and would be both boring and predictable.

    The USC game was a poor gameplan, executed poorly. But the rest of the season, I can't fault the mix of calls that much.
    Big plays are good?