Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Feel the Bern

RaceBannon
RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 114,143 Founders Club
«1

Comments

  • Fire_Marshall_Bill
    Fire_Marshall_Bill Member Posts: 25,681 Standard Supporter
    Hmm, we can't reach this page.
  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 114,143 Founders Club
    I see. The guy who set up Hillary's server has been granted immunity by the Justice Dept. He took the 5th before Congress
  • Sledog
    Sledog Member Posts: 37,875 Standard Supporter
    Now that you mention it my wallet seems to be warmer....
  • 2001400ex
    2001400ex Member Posts: 29,457
    Great webpage is unavailable post as always.
  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 114,143 Founders Club
    2001400ex said:

    Great webpage is unavailable post as always.

    I told you what it said. It's all over the news.
  • DerekJohnson
    DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,543 Founders Club

    image

    You.

    oh come on now
  • doogsinparadise
    doogsinparadise Member Posts: 9,320
    Looks like even if she were to be convicted it wouldn't mean any jail time, after the precedent of the Petraeus case. Just a fat fine and probation. Is that unjust? Idk.

    https://washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/in-clinton-email-investigation-justice-department-grants-immunity-to-former-state-department-staffer/2016/03/02/e421e39e-e0a0-11e5-9c36-e1902f6b6571_story.html
  • 2001400ex
    2001400ex Member Posts: 29,457
    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.
  • Sledog
    Sledog Member Posts: 37,875 Standard Supporter
    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
  • 2001400ex
    2001400ex Member Posts: 29,457
    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
  • PurpleJ
    PurpleJ Member Posts: 37,643 Founders Club
    edited March 2016
    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    Kenya*
  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 114,143 Founders Club
    Betrayus gave his schedule book to an author of his biography.

    Hillary set up a private server at her home, it was not secure, conducted secure business on it then deleted the emails.

    Its exactly the same,

    Whether she goes to prison or not, a conviction does not allow her to be President.
  • HoustonHusky
    HoustonHusky Member Posts: 6,000
    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    Those are all things documented to have been on Hillary's server.

    Keep gurgling....slurp...slurp...
  • pawz
    pawz Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 22,480 Founders Club

    Betrayus gave his schedule book to an author of his biography.

    Hillary set up a private server at her home, it was not secure, conducted secure business on it then deleted the emails.

    Its exactly the same,

    Whether she goes to prison or not, a conviction does not allow her to be President.

    Convictions take time. Like more than 6 months. I'm not sure how that applies here, but maybe HondaFS can tell us.
  • PurpleJ
    PurpleJ Member Posts: 37,643 Founders Club
    Just build the cell in the Oval Office. Problem solved!
  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 114,143 Founders Club
    Her choice for VP will be our president
  • doogsinparadise
    doogsinparadise Member Posts: 9,320

    Her choice for VP will be our president

    Just thinking that, maybe she'll tab Bill.
  • EwaDawg
    EwaDawg Member Posts: 4,339
    PurpleJ said:

    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    Kenya*
    @AZDuck, true?

  • sarktastic
    sarktastic Member Posts: 9,208
    edited March 2016

    Looks like even if she were to be convicted it wouldn't mean any jail time, after the precedent of the Petraeus case. Just a fat fine and probation. Is that unjust? Idk.

    https://washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/in-clinton-email-investigation-justice-department-grants-immunity-to-former-state-department-staffer/2016/03/02/e421e39e-e0a0-11e5-9c36-e1902f6b6571_story.html

    Only a doog living in Algona, believing it's paradise, would equate these two examples.

    Romney will enter the race... as Gerald Ford II, when Hiliary is indighted
  • Sledog
    Sledog Member Posts: 37,875 Standard Supporter
    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    You can't prove Obama was born in Hawaii and neither can he! Birth cert forged it's obvious to a 3rd grader. Funny the gal that issued it was the only death in a small plane crash and had long ties to the Obama machine back to his childhood. Hmmm....... Like I said playing by the rules allowed for BHO makes Cruz entirely eligible as both his parents were citizens which makes him one no matter where he is born.
  • dnc
    dnc Member Posts: 56,840
    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    You can't prove Obama was born in Hawaii and neither can he! Birth cert forged it's obvious to a 3rd grader. Funny the gal that issued it was the only death in a small plane crash and had long ties to the Obama machine back to his childhood. Hmmm....... Like I said playing by the rules allowed for BHO makes Cruz entirely eligible as both his parents were citizens which makes him one no matter where he is born.
    Even if Obama was born in Kenya he was eligible just as Cruz is. Citizen mother = natural born citizen. It's always been that way, always will be that way.
  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 114,143 Founders Club
    dnc said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    You can't prove Obama was born in Hawaii and neither can he! Birth cert forged it's obvious to a 3rd grader. Funny the gal that issued it was the only death in a small plane crash and had long ties to the Obama machine back to his childhood. Hmmm....... Like I said playing by the rules allowed for BHO makes Cruz entirely eligible as both his parents were citizens which makes him one no matter where he is born.
    Even if Obama was born in Kenya he was eligible just as Cruz is. Citizen baby mama = natural born citizen. It's always been that way, always will be that way.
  • Kaepsknee
    Kaepsknee Member Posts: 14,913
    KOMO4 or GTFO!
  • Kaepsknee
    Kaepsknee Member Posts: 14,913
    dnc said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    You can't prove Obama was born in Hawaii and neither can he! Birth cert forged it's obvious to a 3rd grader. Funny the gal that issued it was the only death in a small plane crash and had long ties to the Obama machine back to his childhood. Hmmm....... Like I said playing by the rules allowed for BHO makes Cruz entirely eligible as both his parents were citizens which makes him one no matter where he is born.
    Even if Obama was born in Kenya he was eligible just as Cruz is. Citizen mother = natural born citizen. It's always been that way, always will be that way.
    So what ur saying is that d2...,er sledog needs to learn the difference?
  • Sledog
    Sledog Member Posts: 37,875 Standard Supporter
    salemcoog said:

    dnc said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    You can't prove Obama was born in Hawaii and neither can he! Birth cert forged it's obvious to a 3rd grader. Funny the gal that issued it was the only death in a small plane crash and had long ties to the Obama machine back to his childhood. Hmmm....... Like I said playing by the rules allowed for BHO makes Cruz entirely eligible as both his parents were citizens which makes him one no matter where he is born.
    Even if Obama was born in Kenya he was eligible just as Cruz is. Citizen mother = natural born citizen. It's always been that way, always will be that way.
    So what ur saying is that d2...,er sledog needs to learn the difference?
    I did know what it means the problem is the DNC did not or did not care. They certified him as legal to run and signed off by Nancy Pelosi after all she'd never lie and she not crazy. So now that the rules are changed the DNC can't bring it up on Cruz.
  • 2001400ex
    2001400ex Member Posts: 29,457
    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Sledog said:

    2001400ex said:

    Looks like there's a precedent set:

    The officials said they think that Petraeus’s actions were more egregious than those of Clinton and her aides because he lied to the FBI, and classified information he shared with his biographer contained top secret code words, identities of covert officers, war strategy and intelligence capabilities. Prosecutors initially threatened to charge him with three felonies, including conspiracy, violating the Espionage Act and lying to the FBI. But after negotiations, Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of mishandling classified information.

    Really they need to come out and decide prosecute or no. The last thing this country needs is to have an ongoing suit with a presidential nominee. Same deal with Cruz. His eligibility for president needs to be solved, either yes or no.

    It looks like Hillary committed felonies so it's time to hook her up and send her to trial.

    Cruz is just as eligible as Obama but we now are playing by the rules that let Obama run. I don't think either is eligible but we now have new rules. Natural born to the framers of the constitution was two citizen parents and born in the united states. This prevents kings etc from sending sons over to impregnate a female citizen and then throw their financial weight behind that person to get them into power and rule by proxy. The framers had just finished getting rid of kings etc, and didn't want something like that happening. Unfortunately the respective parties certify if the candidate is legal. Their is no governmental entity that performs that function that I can locate or any record of it being done. The bed is now made so we all get to sleep in it.
    Obama was born in Hawaii. Cruz was born in Canada. How are they the same? Not to mention the Cruz deal will end up at the supreme court, this is much larger than a political party deal.

    You are some kind of special retard.
    You can't prove Obama was born in Hawaii and neither can he! Birth cert forged it's obvious to a 3rd grader. Funny the gal that issued it was the only death in a small plane crash and had long ties to the Obama machine back to his childhood. Hmmm....... Like I said playing by the rules allowed for BHO makes Cruz entirely eligible as both his parents were citizens which makes him one no matter where he is born.
    That's funny shit. Nice wwooosssshhhh.

    BTW, did he fake the two newspaper announcements of his birth too?
  • Sledog
    Sledog Member Posts: 37,875 Standard Supporter
    Wouldn't matter under the founders definition as daddy was a foreign national non-citizen communist. Obama couldn't get a security clearance to empty the trash at Boeing.
  • dnc
    dnc Member Posts: 56,840
    Sledog said:

    Wouldn't matter under the founders definition as daddy was a foreign national non-citizen communist. Obama couldn't get a security clearance to empty the trash at Boeing.

    Then Cruz isn't eligible either.

    But they're both eligible.
    What does it mean to be a "natural born citizen"?

    Most legal experts contend it means someone is a citizen from birth and doesn’t have to go through a naturalization process to become a citizen.

    If that’s the definition, then Cruz is a natural born citizen by being born to an American mother and having her citizenship at birth. The Congressional Research Service, the agency tasked with providing authoritative research to all members of Congress, published a report after the 2008 election supporting the thinking that "natural born" citizenship means citizenship held "at birth."

    There are many legal and historical precedents to strongly back up this argument, experts have said.

    Those precedents were the subject of a recent op-ed in the Harvard Law Review by two former solicitor generals of opposing parties, Neal Katyal and Paul Clement, who worked for Presidents Barack Obama and George W. Bush, respectively. They wrote that "natural born" had a longstanding definition dating back to colonial times.

    British common law recognized that children born outside of the British Empire remained subjects, and were described by law as "natural born," Katyal and Clement wrote.

    "The framers, of course, would have been intimately familiar with these statutes and the way they used terms like ‘natural born,’ since the (British) statutes were binding law in the colonies before the Revolutionary War,’" they said.

    Additionally, the first Congress of the United States passed the Naturalization Act of 1790, just three years after the Constitution was written, which stated that children born abroad to U.S. citizens were, too, natural born citizens. Many members of the inaugural Congress were also authors of the Constitution.
  • 2001400ex
    2001400ex Member Posts: 29,457
    dnc said:

    Sledog said:

    Wouldn't matter under the founders definition as daddy was a foreign national non-citizen communist. Obama couldn't get a security clearance to empty the trash at Boeing.

    Then Cruz isn't eligible either.

    But they're both eligible.
    What does it mean to be a "natural born citizen"?

    Most legal experts contend it means someone is a citizen from birth and doesn’t have to go through a naturalization process to become a citizen.

    If that’s the definition, then Cruz is a natural born citizen by being born to an American mother and having her citizenship at birth. The Congressional Research Service, the agency tasked with providing authoritative research to all members of Congress, published a report after the 2008 election supporting the thinking that "natural born" citizenship means citizenship held "at birth."

    There are many legal and historical precedents to strongly back up this argument, experts have said.

    Those precedents were the subject of a recent op-ed in the Harvard Law Review by two former solicitor generals of opposing parties, Neal Katyal and Paul Clement, who worked for Presidents Barack Obama and George W. Bush, respectively. They wrote that "natural born" had a longstanding definition dating back to colonial times.

    British common law recognized that children born outside of the British Empire remained subjects, and were described by law as "natural born," Katyal and Clement wrote.

    "The framers, of course, would have been intimately familiar with these statutes and the way they used terms like ‘natural born,’ since the (British) statutes were binding law in the colonies before the Revolutionary War,’" they said.

    Additionally, the first Congress of the United States passed the Naturalization Act of 1790, just three years after the Constitution was written, which stated that children born abroad to U.S. citizens were, too, natural born citizens. Many members of the inaugural Congress were also authors of the Constitution.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalization_Act_of_1790

    That act was changed a few times then repealed.

    I think it's not clear that Cruz is a natural born citizen. That being said, I'm fine with him being voted in if the voters approve him. My comment is about the legal mess it creates.