Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?
Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.
If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.
We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.
I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.
Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.
Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?
Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.
If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.
We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.
I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.
Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.
Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?
Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.
If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.
We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.
I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.
Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.
Man, I'm fucking double-post fired up right now about this. Why did Cyler start over Williams, especially after the Oregon game? You'd have to think the main reason was potential int's from Williams, but we just got our assholes shredded by Oregon (BONEM, TSIO), so why is the potential to throw more picks out-weighing the opposing defense knowing your qb can't throw it 10+ yards and loading up the box on your ass 100% of the snaps?
Jesus, this again? Who says Troy can throw it more than 10 yards? He didn't against Oregon even though they weren't even trying.
If anyone gives Troy a 2 or Jaydon a 4 they should have their voting privileges revoked.
We aren't handing out participation trophies here. Make them earn it.
I didn't know the parents of Cyler were still reading these boreds.
Troy's a 2, and he threw it more than 10 yards in his only start. Doog.
Doogs always love the backup QB.
You're taking Cyler in this case? lol
What does Cyler have to do with Troy being a 1?
I'm sorry, let me go back and change my bracket and bump Troy back down to a 1 because he left the program after he realized the coaches were going to start a piece of shit the rest of the year.
I gave Mickens a 3, but an unbiased observer probably gives him a 4.
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
I gave Mickens a 3, but an unbiased observer probably gives him a 4.
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
Mickens started for 300 years and never sniffed all Pac-10.
I gave Mickens a 3, but an unbiased observer probably gives him a 4.
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
Maybe an unbiased observer of stats. I don't think anyone could watch that guy for any time at all, even his highlight tape, and call him an all Pac 12 caliber player. That seems to be a widely accepted criteria for awarding 4*.
He didn't have good hands, he didn't create many explosive plays, he didn't return punts or kicks which is something you'd expect from a supposed star player of his style. Opposing defenses didn't fear him. If anyone ever game planned for UW by putting their best db on him then it was only by default due to the lack of real receiving threats on the team during most of his career.
If career achievement in terms of stats is a standalone way of earning 4* as a receiver then he would qualify. I don't see it any other way.
I gave Mickens a 3, but an unbiased observer probably gives him a 4.
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
Mickens started for 300 years and never sniffed all Pac-10.
Whoever gave Mickens a four, would be the same guy who thinks participation ribbons, not keeping score, and orange slices for everyone in youth sports is the way to go.
If Mickens is a four, then Kasen Williams (pre-injury) would have been a 7 (Heisman winner, college and pro hall of famer)
I gave Mickens a 3, but an unbiased observer probably gives him a 4.
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
Mickens started for 300 years and never sniffed all Pac-10.
Whoever gave Mickens a four, would be the same guy who thinks participation ribbons, not keeping score, and orange slices for everyone in youth sports is the way to go.
If Mickens is a four, then Kasen Williams (pre-injury) would have been a 7 (Heisman winner, college and pro hall of famer)
Uhh, Kasen was never anywhere near that good. He was a little better than Mickens, for sure.
I gave Mickens a 3, but an unbiased observer probably gives him a 4.
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
Mickens started for 300 years and never sniffed all Pac-10.
Whoever gave Mickens a four, would be the same guy who thinks participation ribbons, not keeping score, and orange slices for everyone in youth sports is the way to go.
If Mickens is a four, then Kasen Williams (pre-injury) would have been a 7 (Heisman winner, college and pro hall of famer)
Uhh, Kasen was never anywhere near that good. He was a little better than Mickens, for sure.
That's my point. Kasen isn't a 7 and no chance on god's green earth Mickens is even remotely close to a 4.
Comments
Oh wait...
...
Feeney was a 4. With a redshirt year, Littleton could have been a 4 as well. Fucking waste of his freshman year. They put him in because they were sick of Shirley, but it was still pointless.
He didn't have good hands, he didn't create many explosive plays, he didn't return punts or kicks which is something you'd expect from a supposed star player of his style. Opposing defenses didn't fear him. If anyone ever game planned for UW by putting their best db on him then it was only by default due to the lack of real receiving threats on the team during most of his career.
If career achievement in terms of stats is a standalone way of earning 4* as a receiver then he would qualify. I don't see it any other way.
If Mickens is a four, then Kasen Williams (pre-injury) would have been a 7 (Heisman winner, college and pro hall of famer)