Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Harbaugh
Comments
-
No, but I think he will win something like that.DerekJohnson said:
Chip Kelly has won neither a Super Bowl nor a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
Maybe we have a different definition of incredible. I consider that type of a superlative to be reserved for the greats. He isn't in that category at this point.DerekJohnson said:
Harbaugh took over a 1-11 team and three years later was in a BCS bowl. That's incredible.PurpleJ said:Harbaugh is not an incredible coach. He is a good coach.
And Shaw is average.
Maybe if he had stayed and won a NC. Maybe if he wins a Super Bowl or two someday.
And at least he won the conference when he was coaching in college. -
Saban wasn't special in the pros. NFL coaches > college coaches. Ergo Harbaugh > Saban.PurpleJ said:
Bellichek
Carroll
Harbaugh
Chip
-
Incredible might be a bit far, but he's damn sure better than "a good coach". All he's done is win everywhere he's been, and he's inherited nothing but downtrodden programs usually reserved for coaches wiff more melanin.PurpleJ said:
Maybe we have a different definition of incredible. I consider that type of a superlative to be reserved for the greats. He isn't in that category at this point.DerekJohnson said:
Harbaugh took over a 1-11 team and three years later was in a BCS bowl. That's incredible.PurpleJ said:Harbaugh is not an incredible coach. He is a good coach.
And Shaw is average.
Maybe if he had stayed and won a NC. Maybe if he wins a Super Bowl or two someday.
-
Gene Chizik won a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
No, but I think he will win something like that.DerekJohnson said:
Chip Kelly has won neither a Super Bowl nor a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
Maybe we have a different definition of incredible. I consider that type of a superlative to be reserved for the greats. He isn't in that category at this point.DerekJohnson said:
Harbaugh took over a 1-11 team and three years later was in a BCS bowl. That's incredible.PurpleJ said:Harbaugh is not an incredible coach. He is a good coach.
And Shaw is average.
Maybe if he had stayed and won a NC. Maybe if he wins a Super Bowl or two someday.
And at least he won the conference when he was coaching in college. -
The only reason he won that is because Darron Thomas didn't smoke it all before the game.DerekJohnson said:
Gene Chizik won a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
No, but I think he will win something like that.DerekJohnson said:
Chip Kelly has won neither a Super Bowl nor a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
Maybe we have a different definition of incredible. I consider that type of a superlative to be reserved for the greats. He isn't in that category at this point.DerekJohnson said:
Harbaugh took over a 1-11 team and three years later was in a BCS bowl. That's incredible.PurpleJ said:Harbaugh is not an incredible coach. He is a good coach.
And Shaw is average.
Maybe if he had stayed and won a NC. Maybe if he wins a Super Bowl or two someday.
And at least he won the conference when he was coaching in college. -
You always like to press this badly?DerekJohnson said:
Gene Chizik won a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
No, but I think he will win something like that.DerekJohnson said:
Chip Kelly has won neither a Super Bowl nor a national championship. Do you consider him to be incredible?PurpleJ said:
Maybe we have a different definition of incredible. I consider that type of a superlative to be reserved for the greats. He isn't in that category at this point.DerekJohnson said:
Harbaugh took over a 1-11 team and three years later was in a BCS bowl. That's incredible.PurpleJ said:Harbaugh is not an incredible coach. He is a good coach.
And Shaw is average.
Maybe if he had stayed and won a NC. Maybe if he wins a Super Bowl or two someday.
And at least he won the conference when he was coaching in college.
-
Yeah, but still.DerekJohnson said:
Harbaugh took over a 1-11 team and three years later was in a BCS bowl. That's incredible.PurpleJ said:Harbaugh is not an incredible coach. He is a good coach.
And Shaw is average. -
I hate coaches who are dicks and beat the shit out of my my hometeam
-
Harbaugh is a top 3 football coach in the world as is. D2 natty at USD, Takes 1-11 Stanford and beats Carroll with Tavita Pritchard on the Road in Carroll's prime in year 1 and continues on to the BCS. Takes a shitty fucking Niner team and sends them to 3 straight championship games and a superbowl. He's a fucking beast.
-
Harbaugh is an amazing coach. He's an even greater program builder. You can say he has to put some big wins next to his name before he's great. That's a standard coaches tend to get held to. He'll get there. SF was nearly an even match for Seattle last year and probably would have dismantled Denver in similar fashion.
Shaw inherited a program with the most well defined identity in CFB, and is slowly wearing away at it with predictably inept play calling and a loss of discipline and attention to detail among his players. They're still big and play serious, hard nosed ball at all times on defense and sometimes on offense, but they're a shadow of what they were 4 years ago. It didn't just start this year either.
