Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Greatest Music Biographical Film?
YellowSnow
Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 35,348 
Greatest Music Biographical Film? 16 votes
The Buddy Holly Story
12%
2 votes
Coal Miner's Daughter
0%
The Doors
18%
3 votes
Walk The Line
6%
1 vote
Straight Outta Compton
6%
1 vote
Amadeus
25%
4 votes
Ray
0%
Sid & Nancy
0%
What's Love Got To Do With It?
12%
2 votes
F.O. Row Peter Puffer, You Left Off...
18%
3 votes
Comments
Ive seen The Doors, Amadeus, Sid and Nancy, and Tina/Ike. I think I saw Straight Out of Compton too but I don't remember for sure.
Larry Fishburne has always been a favorite going back to high school or even before. Pretty easy choice really. He was amazing as Ike Turner.
I find most biopics corny
Surprised Yella didn't include Bohemian Rhapsody
It's a terribly corny genre. Amadeus is a legit wonderful film that never feels like a corny biopic at any point, which is why it gets my vote.
Best Pic Oscar of 1984 of course.
Walk Hard
I'll be honest, Stalin, I've never seen the film.
My relationship with Queen is complicated and my confirmation bias seeps in on this one. I appreciate their talent and greatness, but their sound doesn't do it for me much of the time. I can't take the constant bombast.
Also, Mrs Snow loves Queen and over plays the shit out of them on her shitty little Amazon sound device thingy. She's not allowed to touch the record player.
Great flick. Cox wasn't a real person though you bonio.
Buddy Holly was second
Imagine a world where Gary Busey is an academy award level actor. I miss America damn it!!
Music biopics are mega overrated and lazy. I think they get made a lot because they're super easy, already have built in audiences, stars want to play musical heroes, and a lot of studios I think have or are connected to record labels so it's a win-win.
The Doors rules though. I'd damn near put it in like a perfect movie category.
Val Kilmer is fucking awesome as Jim. So it Joaquin Phoenix as Cash and the dude in the recent Elvis movie. All the films have some Hollywood cheese, but I enjoyed them.
My sleeper music biopic is Love and Mercy. Paul Dano is excellent as young Brian Wilson and the collapse of the Beach Boys is my all time favorite rock subject to discuss in great detail.
Love and Mercy was great and an underrated subject. Pretty rare to see people who actually fully disappear in a zenith. I have enjoyed a chunk of music biopics and they have a low floor.
The Greatest Beach Boys collapse of 1967 is like none other in rock history. SMILE wasn't going to be on the level of Pet Sounds or Sgt Pepper, but if they had done it right and finished the damn thing, it would have been critically successful and kept them relevant.
Good call, Love and Mercy is up there with Amadeus for me. Not much Hollywood cheese and the studio scenes where Brian’s recording Pet Sounds & Good Vibrations are incredible
I haven’t seen most of them, but I saw this one many tims growing up, as it was a favorite of Mom and Pops…saw it so much that I believed that Jimmy Stewart was actually Glenn Miller…
I'm not a Queen guy either.
Huh?
No love for the Von Trapps?
Nazis.