Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Penix playing terrible

But with us still just winning and winning makes me feel better about next season.

Winners win.
«1

Comments

  • OreDawg
    OreDawg Member Posts: 673

    Because Rome is the best receiver UW has ever had.

    Fair but we’ll hopefully get everyone else back next season. I don’t think Polk can leave after his oddly bad performances the past two weeks
  • LaZoris
    LaZoris Member Posts: 1,734 Standard Supporter
    He almost threw 2 picks on the winning drive

  • bisonduck
    bisonduck Member Posts: 715
    edited November 2023

    What was the postgame with his head in the cabinet then sneaking off the field with a couple jackets over his head?

    I think he sees the same online therapist as Caleb Williams, and he just had the feels. That, or he got hurt on the sack.
  • Doog_de_Jour
    Doog_de_Jour Member Posts: 8,041 Standard Supporter

    What was the postgame with his head in the cabinet then sneaking off the field with a couple jackets over his head?

    Not sure. At first I got angry thinking he was pulling a Browning and pouting like a bitch (which wasn’t fair).

    Now I’m wondering if he was injured again and he was in pain and didn’t want the fact to distract from the field goal.
  • BleachedAnusDawg
    BleachedAnusDawg Member Posts: 13,193 Standard Supporter
    Starting to look like playing two full seasons in a row has broken him down.
  • SkipBoyd
    SkipBoyd Member Posts: 403
    bigcc said:

    What was the postgame with his head in the cabinet then sneaking off the field with a couple jackets over his head?

    It was his last game at husky stadium, he was probably just emotional
    His agent called him.
  • RoadTrip
    RoadTrip Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 8,146 Founders Club
    OreDawg said:

    But with us still just winning and winning makes me feel better about next season.

    Winners win.

    Next season? I guess if we get a mobile QB, a 6'4" WR, 2 LBs, 2 DL, 2 safeties and 2 corners in the portal next season might be ok. If DM is the QB, this team wins 8 or 9 max.
  • CuntWaffle
    CuntWaffle Member Posts: 22,499
    At a certain point when does it become he is playing terrible vs he was playing completely out of his mind and has now leveled out?
  • RoadTrip
    RoadTrip Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 8,146 Founders Club

    At a certain point when does it become he is playing terrible vs he was playing completely out of his mind and has now leveled out?

    The variances are two far from each other IMO. I think His leveled out is closer to playing out of his mind. We may not hear about it until after the season or never but something is off. I’ll beat this drum until it breaks.
    He looks scared in the pocket not that he has ever looked comfortable but he almost never runs and lately he's throwing off his back foot and looking like he has almost no confidence. He's a slight build and won't last in the NFL playing like this.
  • gmo
    gmo Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 3,849 Founders Club
    gmo said:

    it is the worst he has looked in two full seasons doing this.

    clearly he's not 100%... physically, mentally... whatever the fuck it is he doesn't look close to the same.

    if by some miracle someone can fix he and McMillan ahead of the game Friday we can win this. That doesn't happen i have a very hard time thinking this game is even close, let alone a W.


    I should have actually mentioned DJ as well.

    3 of our top 4 offensive weapons are dealing with something physically or mentally.
  • 1to392831weretaken
    1to392831weretaken Member Posts: 7,696

    At a certain point when does it become he is playing terrible vs he was playing completely out of his mind and has now leveled out?

    He played completely out of his mind for the entirety of 2022, and then did so this year up until the ASU game. I'm inclined to believe that that's his steady state.

    But I'm becoming more convinced that Grubb has designed an offense that is keyed on him playing with very little deviation from that elite play - throws across the field, supplemented by a high hit rate on downfield shots, and converting long third down conversions if the above didn't work - all of that became routine when the offense was humming.

    You see this in the NFL pretty regularly - these high difficulty throws are necessary to beat the elite athletes that populate defensive rosters, and as a result even an MVP is going to have his handful of clunkers in a season where not everything is hitting. But you don't see this in college because defenses are vastly inferior and a Heisman level QB is still given plenty of easy completions with simple scheming - ala Bo Nix. For whatever reason Grubb has not given Penix this release valve, and an overwhelming amount of pressure has been put on him to play at 100% of his ability, where even a 99% performance will gum up the entire offense. And I think last night was the culmination of a long overdue meltdown from Mike.
    POTM
  • YellowSnow
    YellowSnow Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 37,237 Founders Club

    At a certain point when does it become he is playing terrible vs he was playing completely out of his mind and has now leveled out?

    He played completely out of his mind for the entirety of 2022, and then did so this year up until the ASU game. I'm inclined to believe that that's his steady state.

    But I'm becoming more convinced that Grubb has designed an offense that is keyed on him playing with very little deviation from that elite play - throws across the field, supplemented by a high hit rate on downfield shots, and converting long third down conversions if the above didn't work - all of that became routine when the offense was humming.

    You see this in the NFL pretty regularly - these high difficulty throws are necessary to beat the elite athletes that populate defensive rosters, and as a result even an MVP is going to have his handful of clunkers in a season where not everything is hitting. But you don't see this in college because defenses are vastly inferior and a Heisman level QB is still given plenty of easy completions with simple scheming - ala Bo Nix. For whatever reason Grubb has not given Penix this release valve, and an overwhelming amount of pressure has been put on him to play at 100% of his ability, where even a 99% performance will gum up the entire offense. And I think last night was the culmination of a long overdue meltdown from Mike.
    The biggest variable for us has always been Penix health. You’d hope they can game plan for him to move the ball when he’s only 81%.
  • HFNY
    HFNY Member Posts: 5,386
    I am guessing he has been banged up for half the season and may have aggravated something in the crappy weather against Oregon State. @RoadTrip made a good point about throwing off his back foot more and that also tells me he has something going on.

    It also seems like defenses have adjusted better to UW's motions, audibles, and different looks. Maybe the secondaries are understanding the keys Penix is looking at when the receivers are running routes and reacting accordingly since more passes have been more closely contested.

    McMillan mostly back is great since Polk has had a bit of the dropsies / yips lately. DJ didn't look 100% yesterday and maybe we'll see more of Tybo against Oregon.

    What helps is that Oregon's secondary isn't the best and Evan Williams (portaled from Fresno State) has a massive club on his hand since he probably broke it or sprained it badly. He's a very good player so that thankfully reduces his effectiveness.