Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

911 I would like to report a crime in Palo Alto

24

Comments

  • PineapplePirate
    PineapplePirate Member Posts: 4,651
    I didn’t watch the coog game but apparently they were twash in that one too.
  • DerekJohnson
    DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 70,256 Founders Club
    ntxduck said:

    ntxduck said:



    In the NCAA, defensive pass interference is contact beyond the neutral zone by a defensive player intentionally and obviously impeding an eligible opponent to prevent the opponent from catching a legal forward pass

    It’s too bad Penix gets blamed for this, although it was not his best throw

    The ball had already hit the defender in the back at this point, no?
    I don’t see the ball in that picture plus the rule book does not allow a defender to face guard even if the ball hits him
    The ball is directly in front of the defender’s face, after it hit him in the back. It may have been PI before that, but the photo isn’t proof of anything.

    It def was PI, but the shot you are looking for is the blatant jersey grab before the ball gets there


  • NeGgaPlEaSe
    NeGgaPlEaSe Member Posts: 6,017
    edited October 2023
    ntxduck said:

    ntxduck said:



    In the NCAA, defensive pass interference is contact beyond the neutral zone by a defensive player intentionally and obviously impeding an eligible opponent to prevent the opponent from catching a legal forward pass

    It’s too bad Penix gets blamed for this, although it was not his best throw

    The ball had already hit the defender in the back at this point, no?
    I don’t see the ball in that picture plus the rule book does not allow a defender to face guard even if the ball hits him
    The ball is directly in front of the defender’s face, after it hit him in the back. It may have been PI before that, but the photo isn’t proof of anything.

    It def was PI, but the shot you are looking for is the blatant jersey grab before the ball gets there


    Jesus dude what the fuck are you looking at. That is face guarding and a PI
    Red circle for vision impaired…. That’s the ball
  • ntxduck
    ntxduck Member Posts: 6,269


    ntxduck said:

    ntxduck said:



    In the NCAA, defensive pass interference is contact beyond the neutral zone by a defensive player intentionally and obviously impeding an eligible opponent to prevent the opponent from catching a legal forward pass

    It’s too bad Penix gets blamed for this, although it was not his best throw

    The ball had already hit the defender in the back at this point, no?
    I don’t see the ball in that picture plus the rule book does not allow a defender to face guard even if the ball hits him
    The ball is directly in front of the defender’s face, after it hit him in the back. It may have been PI before that, but the photo isn’t proof of anything.

    It def was PI, but the shot you are looking for is the blatant jersey grab before the ball gets there


    Jesus dude what the fuck are you looking at. That is face guarding and a PI
    Red circle for vision impaired…. That’s the ball
    This is a different photo than the first one you posted….
  • NeGgaPlEaSe
    NeGgaPlEaSe Member Posts: 6,017
    ntxduck said:


    ntxduck said:

    ntxduck said:



    In the NCAA, defensive pass interference is contact beyond the neutral zone by a defensive player intentionally and obviously impeding an eligible opponent to prevent the opponent from catching a legal forward pass

    It’s too bad Penix gets blamed for this, although it was not his best throw

    The ball had already hit the defender in the back at this point, no?
    I don’t see the ball in that picture plus the rule book does not allow a defender to face guard even if the ball hits him
    The ball is directly in front of the defender’s face, after it hit him in the back. It may have been PI before that, but the photo isn’t proof of anything.

    It def was PI, but the shot you are looking for is the blatant jersey grab before the ball gets there


    Jesus dude what the fuck are you looking at. That is face guarding and a PI
    Red circle for vision impaired…. That’s the ball
    This is a different photo than the first one you posted….
    Does it matter? Still an illegal play, even if Penix threw the ball at the back of the defender’s head it’s Pi. The ball has absolutely nothing to do with face guarding, which you are not allowed to do in College
  • LawDawg1
    LawDawg1 Member Posts: 3,946
    It was only a 14 point swing.
  • ntxduck
    ntxduck Member Posts: 6,269
    edited October 2023

    ntxduck said:


    ntxduck said:

    ntxduck said:



    In the NCAA, defensive pass interference is contact beyond the neutral zone by a defensive player intentionally and obviously impeding an eligible opponent to prevent the opponent from catching a legal forward pass

    It’s too bad Penix gets blamed for this, although it was not his best throw

    The ball had already hit the defender in the back at this point, no?
    I don’t see the ball in that picture plus the rule book does not allow a defender to face guard even if the ball hits him
    The ball is directly in front of the defender’s face, after it hit him in the back. It may have been PI before that, but the photo isn’t proof of anything.

    It def was PI, but the shot you are looking for is the blatant jersey grab before the ball gets there


    Jesus dude what the fuck are you looking at. That is face guarding and a PI
    Red circle for vision impaired…. That’s the ball
    This is a different photo than the first one you posted….
    Does it matter? Still an illegal play, even if Penix threw the ball at the back of the defender’s head it’s Pi. The ball has absolutely nothing to do with face guarding, which you are not allowed to do in College
    I said it was PI.

    Showing a screenshot where the ball has already hit 2 players and the corner is touching odunze isn’t proof of anything, though (the original pic). The cb could have tackled him at that point and that contact would have been legal.

    The 2nd screenshot you posted is def proof of PI, as the ball hasn’t arrived yet. I would have gone with a pic of the blatant jersey tug when the ball is first released and the CB is trying to undress odunze—that should be an insta-flag from any competent officiating crew.
  • 1to392831weretaken
    1to392831weretaken Member Posts: 7,696
    ntxduck said:

    I didn’t watch the coog game but apparently they were twash in that one too.

    In the usc cal game, they sent the players in for halftime, then during half determined there was actually :01 left on the clock. So they started the 2h with a usc fg attempt (missed).
    No. Fucking. Way.