HH Favorite Rock Album Round 2 (1965- 71) - #4 The White Album vs #5 Who's Next

RaceBannon said:

YellowSnow said:

chuck said:

huskyhooligan said:

chuck said:

Fuck.

You.

Guys.


The White Album has both the best and the worst of The Beatles. Yes, there is filler. There are also about 10 songs better than anything The Who ever conjured, and 5-10 more that are worthy album material. The filler takes up about 20 minutes or less, most of that on Revolution 9.

Hard disagree. Baba Oreilly is timeless, and constantly gathers the ear of multiple generations. White Album maybe gets more points if Revolution 1 weren't the album version, as opposed to the single version which was much better. Also Yoko Ono sings on the album, which probably should have eliminated it from contention. Much of the White Album sounds like a precursor to McCartney's Wings.

Not a bad take. You only mentioned one song though (a great one). The white album has many that stack up well with it..

Yoko is easy enough to miss if you ignore Bungalo Bill and Rev. No. 9 which is easy to do. Throw out Honey Pie, Wild Honey Pie, Obla Di blah blah, and Dont Pass Me By and everything else is good to great and there's a shitload of it.

I agree the single version of Rev. 1 is superior. John was into some blues at the time though and vastly preferred the album version.

Don't touch #MyRockyRacoon

I will die on that hill.

Loved that song






In grade school

dflea said:

chuck said:

huskyhooligan said:

chuck said:

Fuck.

You.

Guys.


The White Album has both the best and the worst of The Beatles. Yes, there is filler. There are also about 10 songs better than anything The Who ever conjured, and 5-10 more that are worthy album material. The filler takes up about 20 minutes or less, most of that on Revolution 9.

Hard disagree. Baba Oreilly is timeless, and constantly gathers the ear of multiple generations. White Album maybe gets more points if Revolution 1 weren't the album version, as opposed to the single version which was much better. Also Yoko Ono sings on the album, which probably should have eliminated it from contention. Much of the White Album sounds like a precursor to McCartney's Wings.

Not a bad take. You only mentioned one song though (a great one). The white album has many that stack up well with it..

Yoko is easy enough to miss if you ignore Bungalo Bill and Rev. No. 9 which is easy to do. Throw out Honey Pie, Wild Honey Pie, Obla Di blah blah, and Dont Pass Me By and everything else is good to great and there's a shitload of it.

I agree the single version of Rev. 1 is superior. John was into some blues at the time though and vastly preferred the album version.

You don't need to set aside any songs on Who's Next. They're all good.

This was a tough call for me, but there are songs on the White Album that I just cannot stand. I won't name them, so nobody needs to get all spooled up, but there are a few on there that do not belong in any kind of rock tournament, and settled the decision for me.

GrundleStiltzkin said:

dflea said:

YellowSnow said:

dflea said:

chuck said:

huskyhooligan said:

chuck said:

Fuck.

You.

Guys.


The White Album has both the best and the worst of The Beatles. Yes, there is filler. There are also about 10 songs better than anything The Who ever conjured, and 5-10 more that are worthy album material. The filler takes up about 20 minutes or less, most of that on Revolution 9.

Hard disagree. Baba Oreilly is timeless, and constantly gathers the ear of multiple generations. White Album maybe gets more points if Revolution 1 weren't the album version, as opposed to the single version which was much better. Also Yoko Ono sings on the album, which probably should have eliminated it from contention. Much of the White Album sounds like a precursor to McCartney's Wings.

Not a bad take. You only mentioned one song though (a great one). The white album has many that stack up well with it..

Yoko is easy enough to miss if you ignore Bungalo Bill and Rev. No. 9 which is easy to do. Throw out Honey Pie, Wild Honey Pie, Obla Di blah blah, and Dont Pass Me By and everything else is good to great and there's a shitload of it.

I agree the single version of Rev. 1 is superior. John was into some blues at the time though and vastly preferred the album version.

You don't need to set aside any songs on Who's Next. They're all good.

This was a tough call for me, but there are songs on the White Album that I just cannot stand. I won't name them, so nobody needs to get all spooled up, but there are a few on there that do not belong in any kind of rock tournament, and settled the decision for me.

What’s a spool @dflea ?

Spooled up
Wound up
Butthurt

Same, same.

Urban guysm just don’t get it.