Sweet 16 - Drama / Historical / Make Believe: #2 Mad Men vs #3 Deadwood
Sweet 16 - Drama / Historical / Make Believe: #2 Mad Men vs #3 Deadwood 27 votes
11 votes
16 votes
Comments
-
#2 Mad MenHardest vote for me thus far in this circle jerk. Edge for me goes to Mad Men based on longevity. It kept a high level through all 7 seasons which is no small feat in TV.
-
#3 DeadwoodA very difficult choice.
-
#3 DeadwoodCocksucker wins in a landslide.
-
#2 Mad Men
I won’t feel bad losing to Wu. Gonna feed Thrones to the pigs.DerekJohnson said:A very difficult choice.
-
#2 Mad MenThis is the toughest matchup so far. Deadwood ending prematurely was the tie breaker.
-
#3 DeadwoodPSA to the Mad Men voters (great show too):
-
#3 DeadwoodIf there's any single word that describes those of us? who poast here it's DEADWOOD
-
#3 Deadwood
It's certainly not a place for sermon seekersdnc said:If there's any single word that describes those of us? who poast here it's DEADWOOD
-
#3 DeadwoodLooks like Deadwood has punched Mad Men right in the face.
-
#3 Deadwood
Yeah but people getting shot in a cat house in next level.YellowSnow said: -
#2 Mad Men
The Gem Saloon was a whore house, not a cat house.Swaye said:
Yeah but people getting shot in a cat house in next level.YellowSnow said: -
#3 Deadwood
some of us need to learn the difference?YellowSnow said:
The Gem Saloon was a whore house, not a cat house.Swaye said:
Yeah but people getting shot in a cat house in next level.YellowSnow said: -
#2 Mad Men
Lost in the first round. Total lack of self awareness here.dnc said:If there's any single word that describes those of us? who poast here it's
DEADWOODTrailer Park Boys
I don't see anybody in Deadwood that looks like this:
-
#3 DeadwoodGood Gawd. Is this even a debate??
-
#2 Mad Men
You don’t like dem shows ‘bout NYC, pod?SECDAWG said:Good Gawd. Is this even a debate??
-
#3 DeadwoodYellowSnow said:
You don’t like dem shows ‘bout NYC, pod?SECDAWG said:Good Gawd. Is this even a debate??
-
#2 Mad MenDeadwood is great because "cocksucker".
Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.
And Joan's boobs. Case closed.
-
#2 Mad Men
Yeah, the women of Deadwood are all covered in shit and look haggard as fuck.PurpleThrobber said:Deadwood is great because "cocksucker".
Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.
And Joan's boobs. Case closed.
There’s world class trim in Mad Men. -
#2 Mad Men
I'm fairly certain @Doog_de_Jour would drop panties for Mad Men over Deadwood males, too. Betty Draper and Meagan Draper would clearly be targets.ThomasFremont said:
Yeah, the women of Deadwood are all covered in shit and look haggard as fuck.PurpleThrobber said:Deadwood is great because "cocksucker".
Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.
And Joan's boobs. Case closed.
There’s world class trim in Mad Men.
I know the Throbber would.
-
#3 Deadwood
The ONLY reason Mad Men is in the running is because of that strawberry bitch and her milkers.PurpleThrobber said:Deadwood is great because "cocksucker".
Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.
And Joan's boobs. Case closed.
And she makes it a skrong case. But that’s it. Deadwood all day. -
#2 Mad MenDeadwood wins 16-11. Cocksucker!