Sweet 16 - Drama / Historical / Make Believe: #2 Mad Men vs #3 Deadwood

YellowSnow

YellowSnow

#2 Mad Men

Hardest vote for me thus far in this circle jerk. Edge for me goes to Mad Men based on longevity. It kept a high level through all 7 seasons which is no small feat in TV.

DerekJohnson

#3 Deadwood

A very difficult choice.

Swaye

#3 Deadwood

Cocksucker wins in a landslide.

YellowSnow

#2 Mad Men

DerekJohnson said:

A very difficult choice.

I won’t feel bad losing to Wu. Gonna feed Thrones to the pigs.

ThomasFremont

#2 Mad Men

This is the toughest matchup so far. Deadwood ending prematurely was the tie breaker.

Gladstone

#3 Deadwood

PSA to the Mad Men voters (great show too):

dnc

#3 Deadwood

If there's any single word that describes those of us? who poast here it's DEADWOOD

DerekJohnson

#3 Deadwood

dnc said:

If there's any single word that describes those of us? who poast here it's DEADWOOD

It's certainly not a place for sermon seekers

Swaye

#3 Deadwood

Looks like Deadwood has punched Mad Men right in the face.

YellowSnow

#2 Mad Men

Swaye said:

Looks like Deadwood has punched Mad Men right in the face.

@Swaye you dirty watch traitor. The Rolex and Omega vintage porn in MM was great.

Swaye

#3 Deadwood

YellowSnow said:

Swaye said:

Looks like Deadwood has punched Mad Men right in the face.

@Swaye you dirty watch traitor. The Rolex and Omega vintage porn in MM was great.

Yeah but people getting shot in a cat house in next level.

YellowSnow

#2 Mad Men

Swaye said:

YellowSnow said:

Swaye said:

Looks like Deadwood has punched Mad Men right in the face.

@Swaye you dirty watch traitor. The Rolex and Omega vintage porn in MM was great.

Yeah but people getting shot in a cat house in next level.

The Gem Saloon was a whore house, not a cat house.

DerekJohnson

#3 Deadwood

YellowSnow said:

Swaye said:

YellowSnow said:

Swaye said:

Looks like Deadwood has punched Mad Men right in the face.

@Swaye you dirty watch traitor. The Rolex and Omega vintage porn in MM was great.

Yeah but people getting shot in a cat house in next level.

The Gem Saloon was a whore house, not a cat house.

some of us need to learn the difference?

1to392831weretaken

#2 Mad Men

dnc said:

If there's any single word that describes those of us? who poast here it's DEADWOOD Trailer Park Boys

Lost in the first round. Total lack of self awareness here.

I don't see anybody in Deadwood that looks like this:

SECDAWG

#3 Deadwood

Good Gawd. Is this even a debate??

YellowSnow

#2 Mad Men

SECDAWG said:

Good Gawd. Is this even a debate??

You don’t like dem shows ‘bout NYC, pod?

SECDAWG

#3 Deadwood

YellowSnow said:

SECDAWG said:

Good Gawd. Is this even a debate??

You don’t like dem shows ‘bout NYC, pod?

PurpleThrobber

#2 Mad Men

Deadwood is great because "cocksucker".

Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.

And Joan's boobs. Case closed.

ThomasFremont

#2 Mad Men

PurpleThrobber said:

Deadwood is great because "cocksucker".

Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.

And Joan's boobs. Case closed.

Yeah, the women of Deadwood are all covered in shit and look haggard as fuck.

There’s world class trim in Mad Men.

PurpleThrobber

#2 Mad Men

ThomasFremont said:

PurpleThrobber said:

Deadwood is great because "cocksucker".

Otherwise Mad Men is such a superior show it's not even close. Massive character development, writing, true to the period.

And Joan's boobs. Case closed.

Yeah, the women of Deadwood are all covered in shit and look haggard as fuck.

There’s world class trim in Mad Men.

I'm fairly certain @Doog_de_Jour would drop panties for Mad Men over Deadwood males, too. Betty Draper and Meagan Draper would clearly be targets.

I know the Throbber would.