Is Donovan the worst on paper OC P5 hire of the modern era?

RoadDawg55 said:

Gladstone said:

Ugh.

I cannot think of a single redeeming quality about the hire. Just blind hope, except usually in cases of blind hope there aren't so many negative data points in place already.

If it actually works out, Jimmy will come out looking beyond genius. In all likelihood though, he's just going to look dumb.

One of the most concerning aspects is that Donovan has almost no experience developing QB’s. Sometimes the QB obsession by coordinator’s and offensive minds can be frustrating, but it’s important and Donovan’s lack of experience in that area is almost as concerning as the offenses he coached at Penn State.

That decision is almost as baffling as the Donovan hire to begin with. Why not make him the OC/TE coach and bring in a QB coach that you know, has experience coaching QBs. It's not like we were bidding with anyone for Donovan's services yet we gave him everything he wanted.