Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

6th Annual Jesse Callier Commemorative Post-Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Initiative

1235

Comments

  • godawgstgodawgst Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 2,487 Founders Club
    Holy Crap there were alot of Jaggy guys and below on the list. I think I had 4 guys at 4 and the rest 3 of below.

    Even worse is this group of seniors to be may be just as bad
  • SwayeSwaye Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 41,430 Founders Club
  • WoofWoof Member Posts: 770
    49 responses in so far. This is going to be an interesting one to discuss. I would never have guessed how polarizing AJ Carty's career impact would be to the masses. Also, many of you have a lot of hate in your hearts.

    If anyone still wants to take part, just let me know. We're down about 10-15 people from last year. @DerekJohnson you want in?
  • DoogCouricsDoogCourics Member Posts: 5,739
    Ahmed was a 4. Should be able to fill it out today.
  • RoadDawg55RoadDawg55 Member Posts: 30,123
    4 for Ahmed. Wanted to give him 3.
  • biak1biak1 Member Posts: 4,154
    Will fill out today.

    Ahmed is a 3 who with proper coaching would’ve been a 4, easily. We rarely used him right.
  • NoWarningJustDawgNoWarningJustDawg Member Posts: 1,000

    I was torn and would’ve given Ahmed a 3.5

    He was an impact played but I like my 5s to be All Americans or 1st Team all conference; 4s to be 2nd team and super contributors. Ahmed didn’t get there for me.

    And I need to confirm that he wasn’t 2nd team all conference at RB.

    Ahmed was HM, basically the 5th RB behind easy choice Moss, then Benjamin, Kelley, and Verdell.

    At end of regular season he had exactly 1000 yards, with fewer yards but better avg per carry than Benjamin and Kelley.
    I'd say Verdell jumped him for the last spot by going for 208yd and 3TD in the CCG. (Thanks for showing up, Utes!) Until then Ahmed had few more yards, few more TD, and wasn't far behind in avg per carry.
  • whatshouldicareaboutwhatshouldicareabout Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 12,728 Swaye's Wigwam
    One thing I'd love to see is who from the 2018 Ale Kaho/Jessie Callier rankings departed and how that skews the overall impressions of both pre- and post-college rankings.


  • ThomasFremontThomasFremont Member Posts: 13,325
    4 for me. If he came back or had a better OC I think he’d have been a 5, rather easily. But we don’t deal in hypotheticals.
  • haiehaie Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 21,766 Swaye's Wigwam
    He was a 3 that should have been a 5. His most important plays/series was the SC td run this year and the final 2018 AC series where he shared reps with Gaskin sucking the life out of cupg.

    After that you get touchdowns bounced to the outside that showed his potential but were typically early in games we lost.
  • Neighbor2972Neighbor2972 Member Posts: 4,310
    Ahmed between a 3 & 4 for me. I'll give him a 4
  • WoofWoof Member Posts: 770
    I'm closing the survey tomorrow afternoon and will post the results tomorrow night. If anyone still wants to participate, let me know.
  • DoogWhispererDoogWhisperer Member Posts: 1,026
    I'll participate.
  • dtddtd Member Posts: 4,679 Standard Supporter
    edited January 2020
    Can I get in? I don't know anything about any of your? players except Corey Dillon and Ben Ossai.
  • RDRRDR Member Posts: 580
    Ahmed is a 4 for me.
  • RoadDawg55RoadDawg55 Member Posts: 30,123

    I was torn and would’ve given Ahmed a 3.5

    He was an impact played but I like my 5s to be All Americans or 1st Team all conference; 4s to be 2nd team and super contributors. Ahmed didn’t get there for me.

    And I need to confirm that he wasn’t 2nd team all conference at RB.

    I graded tougher this year. Too often I would give out 4 stars for being a 2 or 3 year starter and 2nd team All Pac. Those guys are 3’s now. 4’s for all conference and 5 for All American, dominant players.
  • SwayeSwaye Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 41,430 Founders Club

    One thing I'd love to see is who from the 2018 Ale Kaho/Jessie Callier rankings departed and how that skews the overall impressions of both pre- and post-college rankings.


    I am always in the lower quadrants on all of this. Perhaps I grade too TUFF. Or just hate the kids.
  • FireCohenFireCohen Member Posts: 21,823

    I was torn and would’ve given Ahmed a 3.5

    He was an impact played but I like my 5s to be All Americans or 1st Team all conference; 4s to be 2nd team and super contributors. Ahmed didn’t get there for me.

    And I need to confirm that he wasn’t 2nd team all conference at RB.

    I graded tougher this year. Too often I would give out 4 stars for being a 2 or 3 year starter and 2nd team All Pac. Those guys are 3’s now. 4’s for all conference and 5 for All American, dominant players.
    Nick Harris got a 5 from me
Sign In or Register to comment.