Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Class of 2020: Early Signing Day Wrap up/Discussion
Neighbor2972
Member Posts: 4,304
After the early signing period UW has 22 commits, the 14th rated class by composite, 11th by 247.
Who is your favorite player in the class? Least favorite? Most underrated? Most overrated? Most likely to contribute immediately? Coach you want to see fired the most? Player you're most dissapointed we didn't get?
How do you rank the class?
By 247 Rankings:
1. Sav'ell Smalls, 5* OLB, 98 rating, 18th nationally
2. Jalen McMillan, 4* WR, 97 rating, 38th nationally
3. Roger Rosengarten, 4* OT, 94 rating, 89th nationally
4. Sam Adams II, 4* RB, 94 rating, 113th nationally
5. Myles Murao, 4* OL, 94 rating, 122nd nationally
6. Rome Odunze, 4* WR, 91 rating, 187th nationally
7. Geirean Hatchett, 4* OL, 91 Rating, 210th nationally
8. Jacobe Covington, 4* S, 91 rating, 217th nationally
9. Sawyer Racanelli, 3* WR, 89 rating, 403rd nationally
10. Mark Redman, 3* TE, 89 rating, 419th nationally
11. Makell Esteen, 3* S, 89 rating, 425th nationally
12. Ethan Garbers, 3* QB, 88 rating, 492nd nationally
13. Elijah Jackson, 3* CB, 87 rating, 564th nationally
14. Samuel Peacock, 3* OT, 87 rating, 597th nationally
15. Gaard Memmelaar, 3*OL, 87 rating, 614th nationally
16. Jay'Veon Sunday, 3* RB, 86 rating, 796th nationally
18. Cooper McDonald, 3* LB, 86 rating, 866th nationally
19. James Smith, 3* CB, 85 rating, 993rd nationally
20. Mason West, 3* TE, 85 rating 1145th nationally
21. Punter
22. Snapper of Distance
Also feel free to use this format
Who is your favorite player in the class? Least favorite? Most underrated? Most overrated? Most likely to contribute immediately? Coach you want to see fired the most? Player you're most dissapointed we didn't get?
How do you rank the class?
By 247 Rankings:
1. Sav'ell Smalls, 5* OLB, 98 rating, 18th nationally
2. Jalen McMillan, 4* WR, 97 rating, 38th nationally
3. Roger Rosengarten, 4* OT, 94 rating, 89th nationally
4. Sam Adams II, 4* RB, 94 rating, 113th nationally
5. Myles Murao, 4* OL, 94 rating, 122nd nationally
6. Rome Odunze, 4* WR, 91 rating, 187th nationally
7. Geirean Hatchett, 4* OL, 91 Rating, 210th nationally
8. Jacobe Covington, 4* S, 91 rating, 217th nationally
9. Sawyer Racanelli, 3* WR, 89 rating, 403rd nationally
10. Mark Redman, 3* TE, 89 rating, 419th nationally
11. Makell Esteen, 3* S, 89 rating, 425th nationally
12. Ethan Garbers, 3* QB, 88 rating, 492nd nationally
13. Elijah Jackson, 3* CB, 87 rating, 564th nationally
14. Samuel Peacock, 3* OT, 87 rating, 597th nationally
15. Gaard Memmelaar, 3*OL, 87 rating, 614th nationally
16. Jay'Veon Sunday, 3* RB, 86 rating, 796th nationally
18. Cooper McDonald, 3* LB, 86 rating, 866th nationally
19. James Smith, 3* CB, 85 rating, 993rd nationally
20. Mason West, 3* TE, 85 rating 1145th nationally
21. Punter
22. Snapper of Distance
Also feel free to use this format
Comments
Personal Favorite: Rosengarten
Underrated: Redman
Overrated: Mason West, somehow
Early Impact: McMillan/Rome, Covington
Fire: Bob
Most dissapointed: Botelho/Herbig
My rankings:
Smalls
Murao
Rosengarten
McMillan
Rome
Redman
Covington
Adams
Esteen
Racannelli
Hatchett
Gaard
Sunday
Garbers
Bruener
Smith
Jackson
Peacock
Mcdonald
West
Worst: West
Most overrated: Smalls
Underrated: Sunday/Gaard
The Recruits I will hate within 3 years:
Underrated: Bruener
Overrated: Smalls
Early Impact: Murao
Fire: 1. Bob 2. Bush 3. PooPao
Most dissapointed: Botelho/Herbig
Underrated: Esteen
Overrated: Adams
Early Impact: McMillan/Rome
Fire: Bob, Paopao, KB
Most disappointed: Bijan Robinson
Underrated: Gaard/Raccanelli
Overrated: Adams
WTF: Sunday, West, Smith
Early Impact: McMillan, Murao
Fire: Paopao, Gregory, Horndawg
Most disappointed: Botelho, Herbig, Scott Jr. Bijan, Yary.
I think he’s a good prospect and has ability, but he’s really an enigma because he did very little in high school.
Underrated: Jaden Green/ Triston Brown
Overrated: Murao, Rosengarten, Rome
WTF: Smalls, McMillan
Early Impact: McDonald, West
Fire: Lake, Huff, Malloe, Adams
Most disappointed: no scholarship kicker offered
Improbable: Odunze (have we ever gotten a recruit from Gorman, and no, Evan Zeger doesn't count)
Best career: Murao
Fire: Bush
Early impact: McMillan
Underrated: Esteen
Overrated: Rosengarten (he'll be good, but he's 260 pounds and won't make an impact for 3 years)
I'm happier with this class than most on the bored. Also, USC's best recruit so far would be our 9th best recruit.
Edited to add I'm pretty disappointed we didn't get any traction with Ringo.
Didn't watch any film of offense signees this year outside of Redman and by extension bit of Garbers, so no real opinion on the rest of it. I can wait a few years to hate them
Favorite: Odunze
Most important recruit: Smalls
Best player: McMillan
Best highlights: tie McMillan, Rosengarten, Odunze
Most underrated here: Garbers
Most underrated by services: McMillan, Rosengarten, and Murao could all be 5*.
I keep forgetting his name: West, Smith, snapper, punter.
Edit...
Biggest recruiting failures the position coach should be burned alive: Bothello, defensive tackles.
Improbable: Murao / Smalls
Best career: murao
Fire: Bush/gregory
Early impact: mcmillan
Underrated: covington
Overrated: Hatchet