"Who is the best coach in the Power Five conferences? Well, unless you've been living under a rock for the last 20 years, odds are you know who checked in at No. 1. But what about the rest?"
Jimbo won a ship. People can (justly or unjustly) debate the merits of that particular accomplishment for him, but he won a ship.
He also chose TAMU over FSU which makes his judgement suspect, but I agree he’s above Pete.
You are one of my favorite posters on here, but that is just ridiculous.
Fisher has a better resume than Petersen, but that is not the same thing as being a better coach.
That's fair. I don't think he's actually a better coach than Pete. I do think for these types of rankings I'm weighing resume more heavily. If the question is simply "who would you rather have as your coach" I'd weight things differently.
Jimbo won a ship. People can (justly or unjustly) debate the merits of that particular accomplishment for him, but he won a ship.
He also chose TAMU over FSU which makes his judgement suspect, but I agree he’s above Pete.
You are one of my favorite posters on here, but that is just ridiculous.
Fisher has a better resume than Petersen, but that is not the same thing as being a better coach.
That's fair. I don't think he's actually a better coach than Pete. I do think for these types of rankings I'm weighing resume more heavily. If the question is simply "who would you rather have as your coach" I'd weight things differently.
Accomplishments - Jimbo Who I'd hire first - Pete
Fisher is a slightly more astute version of Mack Brown.
Jimbo won a ship. People can (justly or unjustly) debate the merits of that particular accomplishment for him, but he won a ship.
He also chose TAMU over FSU which makes his judgement suspect, but I agree he’s above Pete.
You are one of my favorite posters on here, but that is just ridiculous.
Fisher has a better resume than Petersen, but that is not the same thing as being a better coach.
That's fair. I don't think he's actually a better coach than Pete. I do think for these types of rankings I'm weighing resume more heavily. If the question is simply "who would you rather have as your coach" I'd weight things differently.
Accomplishments - Jimbo Who I'd hire first - Pete
Fisher is a slightly more astute version of Mack Brown.
This is an apt comparison- i.e., coaches that have won a natty, but never really dominated the way a truly elite coach would have given the MONEY, TRADITION and LOCATION of their respective schools. Dabo's natty is a heck of a lot more impressive than JimBob's.
Comments
Herm Edwards.
Fisher has a better resume than Petersen, but that is not the same thing as being a better coach.
Accomplishments - Jimbo
Who I'd hire first - Pete
Lol.
The modern day Mack Brown.
He rode a great QB to a Natty after taking over a team that needed an attitude adjustment. Slightly above Gene Chizik, but in the same class.
They were a losing BCS team last year in his 8th year - and every year he’s been there they’ve been in the top 10 in recruiting. They averaged 5th!!!
LOFL.
He sucks so bad.
If you have a cheat code QB and a roster full of talent you can sometimes make it happen.
FSU WENT 5-6 against BCS comp last year.
They averaged the 5th best recruiting class in the prior 5 years!
Holy Fuck you guys are dumb.