2016 and 2017 were the years. Fuck.

Gladstone

30 years from now we'll look back at these defenses (especially the DL) and lament how awful our offense was. The pieces were in place for a championship run or two. With our recruiting failures we'll not have a DL like this for many years, if ever.

As always, fuck Johnathan Smith.

TierbsHsotBoobs

Quit plagiarism pumpy's shit.

DerekJohnson

Gladstone said:

30 years from now we'll look back at these defenses (especially the DL) and lament how awful our offense was. The pieces were in place for a championship run or two. With our recruiting failures we'll not have a DL like this for many years, if ever.

As always, fuck Johnathan Smith.

If you're going to lay blame, you need to do so toward Peterson for hiring Smith in the first place and then keeping him here.

haie

I trust the DL recruiters.

Tequilla

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

dnc

They were great opportunities. They won't be the only ones Pete has.

The DL might dropoff (okay, almost certainly will). But the improvement at QB, WR and OC in the coming years will make up for it and then some. OL too most likely.

Gladstone

DerekJohnson said:

Gladstone said:

30 years from now we'll look back at these defenses (especially the DL) and lament how awful our offense was. The pieces were in place for a championship run or two. With our recruiting failures we'll not have a DL like this for many years, if ever.

As always, fuck Johnathan Smith.

If you're going to lay blame, you need to do so toward Peterson for hiring Smith in the first place and then keeping him here.

Somewhat fallacious as he gets credit for everything else in the program that kicks ass. Obviously it ends ultimately with him.

haie

Tequilla said:

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

30 years from now I’ll turn to my life partner and tell him that we would have won the Nat if we wouldn’t have scored 7 points against Todd graham, 8 second half points against Stanford, called plays with a coach who would later set the record for most 0wen twelves at Beavis, recruited with crusty sodbusters and twitter illiterate USU coordinators, relied on a pasty noodle armed qb, had our best lineman blow his knee out, and sat our 2 stars on offense on the bench 70% of the tim.

TierbsHsotBoobs

haie said:

Tequilla said:

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

30 years from now I’ll turn to my life partner and tell him that we would have won the Nat if we wouldn’t have scored 7 points against Todd graham, 8 second half points against Stanford, called plays with a coach who would later set the record for most 0wen twelves at Beavis, recruited with crusty sodbusters and twitter illiterate USU coordinators, relied on a pasty noodle armed qb, had our best lineman blow his knee out, and sat our 2 stars on offense on the bench 70% of the tim.

You have a lot of hate in your life.

RhythmicSlappingDawg

haie said:

Tequilla said:

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

30 years from now I’ll turn to my life partner and tell him that we would have won the Nat if we wouldn’t have scored 7 points against Todd graham, 8 second half points against Stanford, called plays with a coach who would later set the record for most 0wen twelves at Beavis, recruited with crusty sodbusters and twitter illiterate USU coordinators, relied on a pasty noodle armed qb, had our best lineman blow his knee out, and sat our 2 stars on offense on the bench 70% of the tim.

This is our QB. Greek God. Wasted Years. TSIO.

GreenRiverGatorz

You think this defense just happened by accident?

Gladstone

GreenRiverGatorz said:

You think this defense just happened by accident?

Not the point.

Bread

if Pat Haden had never higher ed Sark Troy Williams would have led our team to a record breaking season and cyler would have been door ass out before ever playing a game.

Tequilla

haie said:

Tequilla said:

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

30 years from now I’ll turn to my life partner and tell him that we would have won the Nat if we wouldn’t have scored 7 points against Todd graham, 8 second half points against Stanford, called plays with a coach who would later set the record for most 0wen twelves at Beavis, recruited with crusty sodbusters and twitter illiterate USU coordinators, relied on a pasty noodle armed qb, had our best lineman blow his knee out, and sat our 2 stars on offense on the bench 70% of the tim.

This team was never winning a national title this year

haie

Tequilla said:

haie said:

Tequilla said:

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

30 years from now I’ll turn to my life partner and tell him that we would have won the Nat if we wouldn’t have scored 7 points against Todd graham, 8 second half points against Stanford, called plays with a coach who would later set the record for most 0wen twelves at Beavis, recruited with crusty sodbusters and twitter illiterate USU coordinators, relied on a pasty noodle armed qb, had our best lineman blow his knee out, and sat our 2 stars on offense on the bench 70% of the tim.

This team was never winning a national title this year

Solid doogman take.

Tequilla

haie said:

Tequilla said:

haie said:

Tequilla said:

On a day of over-reaction this is at or near the top of the list

30 years from now I’ll turn to my life partner and tell him that we would have won the Nat if we wouldn’t have scored 7 points against Todd graham, 8 second half points against Stanford, called plays with a coach who would later set the record for most 0wen twelves at Beavis, recruited with crusty sodbusters and twitter illiterate USU coordinators, relied on a pasty noodle armed qb, had our best lineman blow his knee out, and sat our 2 stars on offense on the bench 70% of the tim.

This team was never winning a national title this year

Solid doogman take.

You have a lot of hate in your life

guntlove

dnc said:

They were great opportunities. They won't be the only ones Pete has.

The DL might dropoff (okay, almost certainly will). But the improvement at QB, WR and OC in the coming years will make up for it and then some. OL too most likely.

Disagree.

Improvements at QB & WR aren't going to mean much if the OL they have blocking for them is total shit. And after next season, because of Strausser's recruiting, that's what's going to happen.

Huff's been a huge step up, but we're going to have the same problem at OL that we had at WR this year... except worse, because unlike WR, offensive linemen very rarely contribute their first couple of years in the program.

The exact same thing will happen on the DL starting in 2019, sooner if Levi or String get hurt next season. Our OL & DL depth and talent going forward is a fucking joke compared to the teams we aspire to compete with.

Praise allah that Petersen was smart enough to fuck-can Strausser & Pease. He needs to do the same with Malloe, and I'm confident he will. But even if/when he does... we're not going to sniff the playoffs for a bunch of years because of the massive recruiting failures on both lines during the last couple of years.

dnc

guntlove said:

dnc said:

They were great opportunities. They won't be the only ones Pete has.

The DL might dropoff (okay, almost certainly will). But the improvement at QB, WR and OC in the coming years will make up for it and then some. OL too most likely.

Disagree.

Improvements at QB & WR aren't going to mean much if the OL they have blocking for them is total shit. And after next season, because of Strausser's recruiting, that's what's going to happen.

Huff's been a huge step up, but we're going to have the same problem at OL that we had at WR this year... except worse, because unlike WR, offensive linemen very rarely contribute their first couple of years in the program.

The exact same thing will happen on the DL starting in 2019, sooner if Levi or String get hurt next season. Our OL & DL depth and talent going forward is a fucking joke compared to the teams we aspire to compete with.

Praise allah that Petersen was smart enough to fuck-can Strausser & Pease. He needs to do the same with Malloe, and I'm confident he will. But even if/when he does... we're not going to sniff the playoffs for a bunch of years because of the massive recruiting failures on both lines during the last couple of years.

You think Pete's leaving in the next four or five years?

I said 16 and 17 won't be Pete's only shot at an NC (the premise of this thread). It won't. A couple years of bad Strausser recruiting delays that, it doesn't change it, unless Pete laves.

I think he's here for at least 10 more years. If so, he makes the playoffs at least 2 or 3 times in that span.

GATSSYN

Tequilla

guntlove said:

dnc said:

They were great opportunities. They won't be the only ones Pete has.

The DL might dropoff (okay, almost certainly will). But the improvement at QB, WR and OC in the coming years will make up for it and then some. OL too most likely.

Disagree.

Improvements at QB & WR aren't going to mean much if the OL they have blocking for them is total shit. And after next season, because of Strausser's recruiting, that's what's going to happen.

Huff's been a huge step up, but we're going to have the same problem at OL that we had at WR this year... except worse, because unlike WR, offensive linemen very rarely contribute their first couple of years in the program.

The exact same thing will happen on the DL starting in 2019, sooner if Levi or String get hurt next season. Our OL & DL depth and talent going forward is a fucking joke compared to the teams we aspire to compete with.

Praise allah that Petersen was smart enough to fuck-can Strausser & Pease. He needs to do the same with Malloe, and I'm confident he will. But even if/when he does... we're not going to sniff the playoffs for a bunch of years because of the massive recruiting failures on both lines during the last couple of years.

I disagree big time with the OL comments ...

The OL next year has a chance to be our best OL in a while. I'm thinking the starting 5 next year will be in some order Adams - Bain - Harris - Wattenberg - McGary ... that's going to be a really good OL. We'll lose Adams and McGary but have the tackle replacements playing G next year in Bain and Wattenberg. I suspect that Jaxson Kirkland will be ready to play come 2019 and it wouldn't shock me if either Mele or Curne would be ready as a RS Frosh. The upper class depth may be lacking a bit in spots but as long as Huff is able to follow up this year with another solid class next year we will be fine. We're going to have 2 pretty decent OL classes in a row - really encouraging there.

DL as a whole is a big issue in 2019. We should be fine next year. We desperately need Josiah Bronson to be a significant factor. It would not shock me if we're in the transfer market this offseason and in the graduate transfer market after the 2018 season (possibly even this season).

I'm more aligned to the idea that we can do better than Malloe. That being said, let's also see how the class ends up. Regardless it looks like we're going to have a strong class in terms of quantity with while we may not have a huge number of elite guys, we have a number of guys that project to be at worst very solid rotational players that will form a really nice core in the DL starting as early as 2020.

As it stands right now, 2019 is shaping up to be a bit of a potential rebuilding year ... we're going to be replacing Browning at QB and even though we'll have talented options to choose from, it'd be far from shocking if we'll have some growing pains there. On the OL, we won't be terrible but we'll likely be starting a RS Jr - RS Soph - Sr - RS Frosh - FR Soph along the line. It's possible to probable that we'll have some really good skill position players on offense. We should be ok in the secondary although not a complete given as we could lose a lot after next year (will lose Miller and McIntosh to graduation, could lose Rapp and Murphy to the Draft). LB is a bit of an unknown as there will be a bit of a transition in 2018 and we won't have a great view until we see how guys like Eifler are progressing as part of the rotation next year. And then obviously the DL is a bit of an issue. It could be a situation where the offense will need to outscore some teams and an 8-4 or 9-3 year is very possible. But by 2020, we should be back to being in very good shape on both sides of the ball with the offense in a position where they could be very, very elite.

CuntWaffle

Pete has a ways to go when it comes to recruiting the program changing blue chips. Definite weak spot of his coaching at the moment. He knows he needs those guys though and it’s dumb to think he is content with the weak areas of the team. I’m sure he is trying to figure out ways to improve this. Shit just doesn’t happen overnight though.

RhythmicSlappingDawg

Tequilla said:

guntlove said:

dnc said:

They were great opportunities. They won't be the only ones Pete has.

The DL might dropoff (okay, almost certainly will). But the improvement at QB, WR and OC in the coming years will make up for it and then some. OL too most likely.

Disagree.

Improvements at QB & WR aren't going to mean much if the OL they have blocking for them is total shit. And after next season, because of Strausser's recruiting, that's what's going to happen.

Huff's been a huge step up, but we're going to have the same problem at OL that we had at WR this year... except worse, because unlike WR, offensive linemen very rarely contribute their first couple of years in the program.

The exact same thing will happen on the DL starting in 2019, sooner if Levi or String get hurt next season. Our OL & DL depth and talent going forward is a fucking joke compared to the teams we aspire to compete with.

Praise allah that Petersen was smart enough to fuck-can Strausser & Pease. He needs to do the same with Malloe, and I'm confident he will. But even if/when he does... we're not going to sniff the playoffs for a bunch of years because of the massive recruiting failures on both lines during the last couple of years.

I disagree big time with the OL comments ...

The OL next year has a chance to be our best OL in a while. I'm thinking the starting 5 next year will be in some order Adams - Bain - Harris - Wattenberg - McGary ... that's going to be a really good OL. We'll lose Adams and McGary but have the tackle replacements playing G next year in Bain and Wattenberg. I suspect that Jaxson Kirkland will be ready to play come 2019 and it wouldn't shock me if either Mele or Curne would be ready as a RS Frosh. The upper class depth may be lacking a bit in spots but as long as Huff is able to follow up this year with another solid class next year we will be fine. We're going to have 2 pretty decent OL classes in a row - really encouraging there.

DL as a whole is a big issue in 2019. We should be fine next year. We desperately need Josiah Bronson to be a significant factor. It would not shock me if we're in the transfer market this offseason and in the graduate transfer market after the 2018 season (possibly even this season).

I'm more aligned to the idea that we can do better than Malloe. That being said, let's also see how the class ends up. Regardless it looks like we're going to have a strong class in terms of quantity with while we may not have a huge number of elite guys, we have a number of guys that project to be at worst very solid rotational players that will form a really nice core in the DL starting as early as 2020.

As it stands right now, 2019 is shaping up to be a bit of a potential rebuilding year ... we're going to be replacing Browning at QB and even though we'll have talented options to choose from, it'd be far from shocking if we'll have some growing pains there. On the OL, we won't be terrible but we'll likely be starting a RS Jr - RS Soph - Sr - RS Frosh - FR Soph along the line. It's possible to probable that we'll have some really good skill position players on offense. We should be ok in the secondary although not a complete given as we could lose a lot after next year (will lose Miller and McIntosh to graduation, could lose Rapp and Murphy to the Draft). LB is a bit of an unknown as there will be a bit of a transition in 2018 and we won't have a great view until we see how guys like Eifler are progressing as part of the rotation next year. And then obviously the DL is a bit of an issue. It could be a situation where the offense will need to outscore some teams and an 8-4 or 9-3 year is very possible. But by 2020, we should be back to being in very good shape on both sides of the ball with the offense in a position where they could be very, very elite.