RESULTS of the 2nd Annual Jesse Callier Post Collegiate Career Impact Ranking Survey

CokeGreaterThanPepsi

This is just a rough result post, we will get the data into spreadsheets and shit over the weekend to make it all fancy dancy and so everyone can see everyone's votes, the numbers in parenthesis represent their survey ranking versus their initial scout ranking). Anyways, it was depressing again.... Enjoy (I called out people on high or low end of votes for some players):

Cory Fuavai: 1.2 Average Ranking (-.8) NOC.

Cory Littleton: 3.3 Average Ranking (+1.3) @Fire_Marshall_Bill gave Littleton a 2, maybe because of the Petersen Gif?

Cyler Miles: 2.04 Average Ranking (-1.96) @Del_Griffith @HUSKYFANATIC and @godawgst gave Cyler a 1, probably 12s!!!!1!! But I can't really argue against that too strongly, cylerthrowingoffwrongfootwhileontherun.gif

Dexter Charles: 2.8 Average Ranking (-.2) Thank you for your service, RIP.

Dwayne Washington: 2.76 Average Ranking (-.24) Quite Honestly, looks like we all agree he made a TERRIFIC choice in going to the NFL.

Jarrett Finau: 1.22 Average Ranking (-1.78) Someone using the name of @Boba_Fetters gave Finau a 3, I can only assume this is a relative of Finau. Props on the name, I will hunt you down and find out who you really are @Boba_Fetters (terrific name though).

Jermaine Kelly: 1.22 Average Ranking (-2.78) @TommySQC @TTJ and Boba gave Kelly a 3, They must have been impressed by his effort against VAJ in 2014.

Jaydon Mickens: 2.98 Average Ranking (-1.02) So close to being the DEFINITION of a 3, damnit. Boba, @seatownfunk, @UW2010, @whatshouldicareabout, @HUSKYFANATIC and @Alexis all gave Jay Don a 4. Assuming they appreciated he caught more than he dropped.

Josh Perkins: 3.36 Average Ranking (+.36) @claycha is sleepin' and hatin' on Josh with a 2

Kory Durkee: 2.84 Average Ranking (-.16) Shoutout to @ThomasFremont giving Durkee a 5!

Marvin Hall: 2.04 Average Ranking (-.96) I feel like if we had graded him as a QB he might have been a 5.

Naijiel Hale: 1.3 Average Ranking (-2.7) Nate Dogg's son has moved on to the big city of Bozeman, MT to play for Choate!

Scott Lawyer: 1.66 Average Ranking (-1.34) Wears a doo-rag, he is cool with me.

Sifa Tufunga: 2.62 Average Ranking (-.38) @gladstone must have found out that Tufunga doesn't like Game of Thrones, he gave him a 1.

Tani Tupou: 3.02 Average Ranking (-.98) Man amongst boys, and I heard someone at the NFLPA bowl broadcast called him "electric". In reality, good college player.

Travis Feeney: 4.0 Average Ranking (+2) Highest grade difference recorded in the 2 year history of the survey.

Troy Williams: 1.2 Average Ranking (-2.8) Black Power! If @RaceBannon could have voted he would have gotten a 5.

We are still working out the best way to determine the development of the players, as we've discovered that the difference in grade from scout to our survey can be a bit unfair since high rated players are penalized a bit on this. We'll figure some shit out at some point, but for now, ENJOY and thanks for your help assholes!

ThomasFremont

FREE PUB!!1! Fuck yeah.

In this offense (and the Sark 3 passes and a punt offense prior), a quality punter like Durkee is a MUST.

Easily 5 stars.

claycha

PUB!!!

Ohhhhh Joshua Perkins!!

Throw all my shit out I'm not sure what happened there. Obviously fell asleep at the wheel.

CokeGreaterThanPepsi

claycha said:

PUB!!!

Ohhhhh Joshua Perkins!!

Throw all my shit out I'm not sure what happened there. Obviously fell asleep at the wheel.

Meh, it's not that bad, you were just the only one to give him a 2.

ToddTurnerLIVES

The star differential is a great stat. We?(and by we? I mean @DDY) should track how all the classes performed from the Sark to Petersen era. Should provide some interesting insight going forward as Pete starts graduating some players.

79smoothdawg

Cal way to high

whatshouldicareabout

Are you going to write a report based on your data and hand-deliver it to Petersen?

Gladstone

CokeGreaterThanPepsi said:

Sifa Tufunga: 2.62 Average Ranking (-.38) @gladstone must have found out that Tufunga doesn't like Game of Thrones, he gave him a 1.
]

CokeGreaterThanPepsi

whatshouldicareabout said:

Are you going to write a report based on your data and hand-deliver it to Petersen?

Yes.

LoneStarDawg

I thought booing the kids would be more satisfying

No idea how to do it, but it'd be interesting to know how many careers of sark guys that Peterman saved

kh83

LoneStarDawg said:

I thought booing the kids would be more satisfying

No idea how to do it, but it'd be interesting to know how many careers of sark guys that Peterman saved

The o/u is 5

Doogles

I'm pretty sure i switched tufunga and tupou because i'm an idiot. I wanted to give Tufunga a 2 and Tupou a 3. Oh well. Thanks for compiling the data. It's fun to see how much we've underachieved.

seatownfunk

Giving Jay Don a 4 is something I'll have to live with for quite some time.

His smile has been imprinted on my mind.


FYFMFE






Does Dave Sizer poast here?

H_D

So the 2nd Annual Tyrone Willingham "Who" Award goes to Cory Fuavai?

bananasnblondes

H_D said:

So the 2nd Annual Tyrone Willingham "Who" Award goes to Cory Fuavai?

Better question: how the hell did anyone rate him higher than a 1? He's been on the team 4 years and has never stepped on the field

DugtheDoog

While I can see how one can find this depressing, I came to grips with the fact that this class and the class before that, etc. suck donkey dick, a long time ago. So seeing confirmation of the shit players who are graduating meanwhile having faith that petermen knows how to evaluate actually makes me more optimistic than depressed.

Gladstone

OP should be a front page article. Jude and Landon would post this on their sites. The voting aspect would encourage more HH signups too.

AIRWOLF

For all the shit that Mickens gets, for good reason, Marvin Hall was soooo much worse.

H_D

bananasnblondes said:

H_D said:

So the 2nd Annual Tyrone Willingham "Who" Award goes to Cory Fuavai?

Better question: how the hell did anyone rate him higher than a 1? He's been on the team 4 years and has never stepped on the field

Superior towel waving and crowd hyping ability.

Del_Griffith

I stand by giving a "1" for Cyler. The dude played one mediocre season, failed to keep String out of trouble and quit the team early. Even Jeff Lindquist is sticking with the team as a backup and contributing on special teams; I respect that.

I'm surprised to see the large variance for Feeney; I rated him high (4) because I felt he performed a lot higher in his last 2 years than overall expectations and was the best graduating senior.

godawgst

If Jake Browning could have skipped his sr. year in high, and enrolled (play along, the NCAA allows that and wouldn't count against his 4 years in college) , There's a 50/50 chance Pete would have started him over Cyler in 2014.

If that's not the definition of a one, I don't know what is.

Hell he should get a one for getting pissed about the superbowl and convincing Stringfellow to go out and be stupid.