Henry: 2000 rushing and 23 TDs, 100 rec yards McCafferey: 1850 rushing and 12 TDs, 500 rec yards
Although he didn't get as many receiving yards, Henry had almost twice as many TDs and played on a playoff team. But I'm sure it's ESECPN or something, right?
Henry: 2000 rushing and 23 TDs, 100 rec yards McCafferey: 1850 rushing and 12 TDs, 500 rec yards
Although he didn't get as many receiving yards, Henry had almost twice as many TDs and played on a playoff team. But I'm sure it's ESECPN or something, right?
But what about the kick/punt return yardage McCafferey had you didn't include?
Also, didn't Stanford have a fb who had 13 one yard td runs? If McCafferey gets those and Henry still wins (which he would have) then what about the ESECPN thing?
Henry: 2000 rushing and 23 TDs, 100 rec yards McCafferey: 1850 rushing and 12 TDs, 500 rec yards
Although he didn't get as many receiving yards, Henry had almost twice as many TDs and played on a playoff team. But I'm sure it's ESECPN or something, right?
But what about the kick/punt return yardage McCafferey had you didn't include?
Also, didn't Stanford have a fb who had 13 one yard td runs? If McCafferey gets those and Henry still wins (which he would have) then what about the ESECPN thing?
Henry still plays for a playoff team. I'd say hand out the award after the playoffs, but the point stands. The Heisman traditionally goes to the best player on the best team.
It's hard to get really upset over the most overrated trophy in American sports (which Gino Toretta won) but McCaffrey had a ton of all purpose yards.
If you want to go by YPC, Fournette and Dalvin Cook had way better averages. They weren't even finalists though.
Voters in the Souf, Midwest, and East (probably 80% of the total) watch Bammer at 2:30 or 3:30 or 7-8 p.m. and miss late Stanfraud games. Plus there are assholes like Tony Kornheiser who openly admit they don't watch West Coast games unless they're on at the right time.
I cared when I was 12. That was before I figured out that it was a popularity contest and networks sunk billions into tv contracts did their best to influence outcomes.
I don't normally watch west coast games either and I won't continue to argue about a subjective award. McCafferey should make the fucking playoffs and then pop off. Same with Fournette and others. The stats were just to show that they have very similar numbers, but it's about winning.
Henry: 2000 rushing and 23 TDs, 100 rec yards McCafferey: 1850 rushing and 12 TDs, 500 rec yards
Although he didn't get as many receiving yards, Henry had almost twice as many TDs and played on a playoff team. But I'm sure it's ESECPN or something, right?
Remound Wright was Stanford's goal line back and had 13 TD's. That hurt McCaffrey. 28.9 yards per kick return for McCaffrey too. Leading rusher and receiver for a top 10 team. He's had an amazing season.
I think McCaffrey deserved it, but it's splitting hairs really because all 3 guys had great seasons.
Five $EC players have won the Heisman from 2007 through 2015.
Over the previous 36 years, four won it. South Carolina was an independent in 1980.
All of a sudden around 2006 or 2007, the SEC players must have just magically become far superior. It just magically happened because they just recruited and developed players and fed them more PEDs.
Maybe the award should be voted on by former Heisman winners instead of voters who only see/hear about whatever player in the geographical region they live/work in?
The current format is like the presidential election, where it comes down to name recognition.
Comments
3....2.....1.....
ND's defense is absolute garbage and he got what? 100 yards on 30 carries or something
orrrrrrrrrr it might have something to do with espn being heavily invested w/ the SEC
w/e fuck the heisman
been a bullshit trophy for yrs
McCafferey: 1850 rushing and 12 TDs, 500 rec yards
Although he didn't get as many receiving yards, Henry had almost twice as many TDs and played on a playoff team. But I'm sure it's ESECPN or something, right?
But what about the kick/punt return yardage McCafferey had you didn't include?
Also, didn't Stanford have a fb who had 13 one yard td runs? If McCafferey gets those and Henry still wins (which he would have) then what about the ESECPN thing?
If you want to go by YPC, Fournette and Dalvin Cook had way better averages. They weren't even finalists though.
Voters in the Souf, Midwest, and East (probably 80% of the total) watch Bammer at 2:30 or 3:30 or 7-8 p.m. and miss late Stanfraud games. Plus there are assholes like Tony Kornheiser who openly admit they don't watch West Coast games unless they're on at the right time.
I cared when I was 12. That was before I figured out that it was a popularity contest and networks sunk billions into tv contracts did their best to influence outcomes.
I think McCaffrey deserved it, but it's splitting hairs really because all 3 guys had great seasons.
Five $EC players have won the Heisman from 2007 through 2015.
Over the previous 36 years, four won it. South Carolina was an independent in 1980.
All of a sudden around 2006 or 2007, the SEC players must have just magically become far superior. It just magically happened because they just recruited and developed players and fed them more PEDs.
J?
The current format is like the presidential election, where it comes down to name recognition.