Elite 8 (late 1980s to Present) - #1 Nirvana vs #2 Metallica
Elite 8 (late 1980s to Present) - #1 Nirvana vs #2 Metallica 55 votes
24 votes
31 votes
Comments
-
#1 Nirvana
-
#2 MetallicaIt pains me but it's true.
-
#1 Nirvana
This is the first game so far in the tournament where I am totally stumped.Mad_Son said:It pains me but it's true.
-
#1 NirvanaThey are both great. My taste is more Nirvana, but they didn’t do that many great things.
When I’m doubt I go with SEA people and the fact that Nirvana totally changed the music industry. -
#2 MetallicaDamn you Dennis.
-
#2 MetallicaHey @PurpleJ kill yourself
-
#2 MetallicaIf I were voting on their post 91' body of work I would vote Nirvana so that tells you something but 80's Metallica is bar setting material.
-
#2 Metallica
I agree. Black album has aged pretty well, but I was very meh on it when it came out. Everything since is meh to crap, with a few song exeptions here and there. But those first four albums from Kill em All to Justice are all fucking legendary.UW_Doog_Bot said:If I were voting on their post 91' body of work I would vote Nirvana so that tells you something but 80's Metallica is bar setting material.
-
-
-
#1 NirvanaIt's funny because I don't like Nirvana either. I just did that to be hurtful.
-
#2 MetallicaPurpleJ said:
It's funny because I don't like Nirvana either. I just did that to be hurtful.
-
#1 NirvanaI could have gone either way here, and taste wise, like DDY, I lean more Nirvana. Alas, I didn't want them to get totally obliterated. Please forgive me Kemosabe for my sins.
-
#1 NirvanaI judge bands entirely based off the drummer anyways. Grohl >>> LAAAARS
-
#1 NirvanaThey are both great. My taste is more Nirvana, but they didn’t do that many great things.
When I’m doubt I go with SEA people and the fact that Nirvana totally changed the music industry.
-
#1 Nirvana
Multiple make up poundin's inbound.dnc said:They are both great. My taste is more Nirvana, but they didn’t do that many great things.
When I’m doubt I go with SEA people and the fact that Nirvana totally changed the music industry. -
#1 NirvanaA coin flip matchup for me
-
-
#2 Metallica
Lots of fags on here. Not that surprising.YellowSnow said:Man, Metallica only up by 7 votes here and @Cohen12 has already voted.
-
#1 Nirvana
Tell me about it. I have an electric weed whacker, only 1 firearm in my home, and don't even think I could drive a stick anymore.Swaye said:
Lots of fags on here. Not that surprising.YellowSnow said:Man, Metallica only up by 7 votes here and @Cohen12 has already voted.
-
#2 MetallicaLet the record state I meant to hit nirvana but fat fingered it!
-
#2 MetallicaThis has less to do with Metallica being good and Nirvana being overrated. I said overrated I didn't say bad so don't twist. Grunge is a type of music you can only listen to for so long before you want to blow off your head with a shotgun.
-
#2 Metallica
Disagree on all accounts.CuntWaffle said:This has less to do with Metallica being good and Nirvana being overrated. I said overrated I didn't say bad so don't twist. Grunge is a type of music you can only listen to for so long before you want to blow off your head with a shotgun.
-
#2 MetallicaMad_Son said:
Disagree on all accounts.CuntWaffle said:This has less to do with Metallica being good and Nirvana being overrated. I said overrated I didn't say bad so don't twist. Grunge is a type of music you can only listen to for so long before you want to blow off your head with a shotgun.
-
#1 NirvanaNirvana was from Tacoma. People forget that.
-
#2 MetallicaNirvana had 1 good album. Should have never made it this far.
-
#2 MetallicaDying gets you all kinds of undeserved cred
-
#1 NirvanaNirvana is the only band that can possibly beat the Beatles in the natty game.
-
#1 Nirvana
Natty game is anyone's guess as this point. Winner of Beatles vs Stones will have a very hard time getting past Zeppelin. AC DC more than likely takes the side of the bracket and is on to the Natty game.oregonblitzkrieg said:Nirvana is the only band that can possibly beat the Beatles in the natty game.
-
#1 Nirvana
I think they had more like 4. Nevermind and In Utero are both essential listening. The live album was by far the best and most interesting of the "unplugged" rage of the 90's; their choice of covers here was fantastic and might make this my favorite Nirvana recoding. Insecticide had plenty of important tracks as well. Yeah, their career was very short but extremely productive.salemcoog said:Nirvana had 1 good album. Should have never made it this far.
